Ambulance rank and fil debate the way forward
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
DOWN... MEN SiR ONESTOUR Solidarity action. UCATT members stop work at Pilkingtons in St Helens in support of the ambulance workers. Photo: John Smith In this page we present a debate between rank and file Merseyside ambulance workers about how to escalate the action.
This debate should be of great interest to all socialists and trade The debate revolves around two options: to strike without cover or to attempt to stay on the job, just doing accident and emergency work.
However, there is a third option for escalating the action that avoids the defects of the other two - an all out strike with emergency cover.
This would be the best way of unifying the ambulance workers and escalating the action. It would break down the divisions between those on strike, those locked out or suspended in some form, and those still on full pay.
A national strike ultimatum could also increase the pressure on management to concede some elements of trade union control There are growing calls many services around country for all-out strike tion.
Indeed, a number of individual stations have already taken this action. So far, on Merseyside, the call for an all-out strike has not been very great.
It may, however, be useful to discuss at this stage the arguments for and against an escalation to this level. The lists below are not meant to be exhaustive or comprehensive. The intention of this article is to provoke thought and stimulate debate.
over emergency cover. Having every ambulance worker out on strike would make the argument for solidarity strike action from other workers much easier.
It is vital to distinguish this option from that of no cover. We need occupations to prevent lock-outs, and appeals to the army and police to stop scabbing (not just by walking off the job, but by arranging a transfer of emergency duties under workers' control).
Ambulance workers should not be frightened off this option by threats of injunctions or the withdrawal of insurance cover.
Let's dare the Tories to jail a professional life-saver for refusing to let unqualified troops and police do their job.
Tactically, it would backfire in the propaganda war, making it much more difficult to convince other groups of workers to take strike action in support.
If the ambulance workers had been on all out strike with no cover during the storms on 25 January, ARKE A PIC LRI For • The resources of the police and army would be stretched to breaking point.
• Every ambulanceman and woman in the country would be in exactly the same position.
• The dispute would be brought to a head.
• Public sympathy on its win an industrial dispute.
Against • We would lose the exceptionally high levels of public support we currently enjoy.
• The people who have been supporting us with our bucket collections and peitions would be the very people we would hurt.
• The press and television would have a field day highlighting the cases where people had died.
• The amounts money we were able The Tories have really got the skids under them. I welcome any move the ambulance workers make, but they and had refused to lift the action, can anyone honestly believe that it would not have eroded their base of support?
Major walk-outs would almost inevitably split the ambulance workers' ranks, as many people who are by no means strikebreakers would work to maintain some sort of emergency service.
Those who would stay on strike would - whether they like it or not — be forced to accept police and army scabbing as necessary in order to save lives.
Strikes in the NHS are generally weaker than those in, say, engineering, because they don't hit profits. The countless deaths of ordinary working class people as a result of the Tories' NHS policies has not led to a U-turn by this vicious government. They don't care about us.
If they did then they wouldn't let thousands of pensioners freeze to death every winter. The tragedies that would result from the total withdrawal of cover (or provoking enough lock-outs and suspensions to collect from the public to pay would decrease dramatically.
As we have said, this is not meant to show all the arguments of either side. We are not advocating one case or another. All we want is for people to be fully aware of the issues involved.
Time to strike Wise a mement ge one e've been in dispute now are no nearer settling the dispute or achieving our objectives than when we started.
I believe we have acted with the utmost restraint despite all the provocations. We have conceded most of our original claims. We have dropped early retirement, longer holidays, the reintroduction of overtime rates, a shorter working week; and now Roger Poole is to overstretch the police and army)
would not force this evil government to back down.
They have dug in their heels.
They hope that if they can stick it out and beat the ambulance workers then they will have halted the pay revolt that has been gathering steam since the Ford strike two years ago. With their economic policies fraying at the edges, Thatcher fears that if they lose this dispute they will also lose the next Therefore, the key to beating the Tories in this battle is to get other groups of workers who do have economic and political muscle to use it.
Let's force the bosses across industry to put pressure on Thatcher to surrender.
• Last week the Liverpool ambulance stewards voted to campaign for a national ballot a strike with emergency cover. Articles from Merseyside Ambulance Worker saying our original claim of 11.4% is negotiable and a pay formula need not be linked to the Fire Brigade. The government has conceded nothing and has maintained a hard line against us.
We have escalated the action to such an extent that for most of the country, including Merseyside, a large proportion of staff are on strike in all but name. Roger Poole is now out of touch with the strength of feeling running throughout the country. He has always told the people of Britain that we would never strike, but he has never had a mandate from ambulance staff to make a statement like that.
Ambulance staff have had just about enough of the government's intransigence and strike action will show Clarke that we are determined to fight for what we believe to be our legitimate and fair claims.
Stations in Southern England have already taken the initiative and have gone on unofficial indefinite strike. The next step for the leadership should be to call for a national strike ballot.
Here on Merseyside we should be pressing our stewards for a branch meeting and a ballot for a strike should be called for.
However, we must be clear about the consequences of a strike. Any vote in favour of a strike must be followed up with a firm commitment by individuals to follow it through to the end.
I don't believe a strike would last as long as the miners' strike, but it certainly wouldn't be over within a week or even possibly a month. But it is the only course of action left open to us now and we should pursue it. Boxing clever Sportion a hare met in ome stations in some services portion - have withdrawn all cover, voluntary or otherwise.
Notably, due to the publicity which it attracted, Crawley ambulance station has withdrawn cover.
I was present at the march in London and noted there was a banner and a parThe Interim Advisory Committee (IAC) on Teachers' Pay has just presented its report to the Government.
From the reactions of the press and the National Union of Teachers you'd swear it was a simple percentage rise.
The NUT has sent a newsletter into schools containing the basic details, but excluding the hidden message of the report and any hint that we might take action against it.
The award itself is pretty confusing. It comes in two stages — April 1990 and January 1991 - and represents an average increase of over 8%. However, many teachers on the bottom scales will get less than 7% and those that receive extra next year will have to wait 9 months to get it.
But these are minor details. Hidden beneath the trumpeting about 8% is a cocktail of regional pay, plant bargaining and individual contracts. The IAC recommend that schools and Local Education Authorities be given powers to make extra payments above the basic scales and existing incentive allowances.
Such payments could be used for shortage subjects, in shortage areas or, most likely, for just plain grovelling to the authorities.
With poll tax and Local Management of Schools, Heads and governors will have less public money but more power to decide who gets it.
And who will be rewarded? Not NUT activists, not part-time women teachers, not lesbian or gay teachers, not black teachers, not pregnant teachers. These are more likely to get the sack.
It will be teachers like those who arrange sponsorship from local industry and accept the dismantling of state education that get the perks. And with individual contracts who needs a national union?
The second biggest union, the NAS/ UT have at least got some plans for strike action over the basic award, but neither of the teaching unions has begun to grapple with the hidden meaning of the report. Like in the ambulance dispute, the Tories want to divide workersd amongst themselves, and so far the unions are letting them get away with it.
But workers can't afford to see their national union destroyed even if the leaders aren't prepared to defend it. So the Socialist Teachers Alliance and the Campaign for a Democratic, Fighting Union must join forces to highlight the bankruptcy of the leadership's 'new realism' They must ensure that the membership discover the hidden messages of the report. If this is done successfully, the membership themselves could spearhead the beginnings of a massive campaign of action against the government's pay award and go on to bring down the right wing 'Broad Left' majority in the forthcoming National Executive elections.
----- pull-quotes -----
To strike not to strike?
SUPPORT TI AMBULANCE
BAe - Reject this offer! Step up the action!