Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[REVIEW n the new issue of Race and…]

Socialist Organiser no. 433, 8 February 1990 · scan p. 10 · Clive Bradley · about 1,109 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

REVIEW n the new issue of Race and not so much factual as moral, on the ideology of 'New Times' put forward by Marxism Today.

He calls it the 'hokum of New Times' , denounces the whole political project behind it as "Thatcherism in drag' ', 'an eat, drink and be merry socialism, because tomoragai we a socialism that holds try everything that is ephemeral and evanescent and passing as vital and worthwhile, everything that melts into air as solid, and proclaims that every shard of self is a social movement."

Sivanandan's focus is that the New Timers' simply blot out the world as it is experienced by the poor and dispossessed of Britain, and of the Third World. When they talk about changing culture, they mean the culture of the better-off sections of the working class. Their language, their 'discourse', , as they would put it, does not articulate the experience of poor people.

*Who are these people who, in our own societies, "with however little money play the game of using things to signify who they are" unless it is those who use cardboard boxes under Waterloo Bridge to signify that they are homeless?' Such concerns, says Sivanandan, for the destitute, for the millions living on social security, for the black people who organise a campaign to defend their communities after the death of one of their number in police custody, not to mention for the impoverished masses of the Third World, are right and proper for a 'socialist conEven where the New Times addresses such issues, it empties them of socialist, that is political, significance, and converts everything into the quest for identity of individual consumers. So he quotes Stuart Hall and Martin Jaques from 1986: 'With the rise of the Band Aid/Live Aid/Sports Aid phenomenon, the ideology of selfishness - and thus one of the main ideological underpinnings of Thatcherism - has been dealt a further, severe blow."

Slic the Third World from Western governments to individuals...In the language of the new Marxists, a discourse on western imperialism was transmogrified into a discourse on western humanism."

The central theoretical error of the New Timers, Sivanandan argues, is that they dissolve collectivist identifies, the starting point of which is class, into fragmented 'The central theoretical error is that they dissolve collective identities.

"cultural' identities: all struggle is supposed to take place in the cultural sphere, 'civil society', as if the state did not exist, or at least frame that cultural sphere; in the New Times there is no place for a TO NEU AND with the 'new social movements' -of women, blacks, gays, Greens.— than with class. But it then 'falls into a new sectarianism'. It is not to say that there should be no attempt to redress the balance of racial, sexual and gender discrimination, but that these solutions deal not with the politics of discrimination but its arithmetic - giving more weightage to women here and blacks there and so rearranging the distribution of inequality as not to alter the structures of inequality themselves.' There is nothing inherently socialist about any of these movements, says Sivanandan, lif these issues are fought in terms of the particularistic oppressions of women qua women, blacks qua blacks and so on, without being opened out to and informed by other oppressions'; 'to the extent that the Green movement is concerned more, say, with the environmental pollution of the western world than with the ecological devastation of the Third World caused by western capitalism, its focus becomes blinkered and narrow, and its programmes partial and susceptible to capitalist overtures.' Sivanandan's polemic is forceful and impressive. 'You don't have to sciousness among working class people that is not simply consumerist, individualist, and all the other market-based -isms associated with Thatcherism and lauded by Marxism Today. He mentions the struggles of black people, in Broadwater Farm and Southall, against the deportation of Tamils, activities of Jewish women in support of the intifada and so on.

And no one would wish to diminish the significance of all of these struggles, nor to dispute that they contradict the post-Fordist certainties of the New Timers. But there are other struggles which also contradict them, which Sivanandan does not mention - of London transport workers for better wages, of hospital workers, including the ambulance crews currently in dispute, for more money but also for a better health service, of the 'Sivanandan also a New Times theory albeit on firmer The latest news from the world of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) is that laboratory mice can catch the "mad cow" disease just by eating brain tissue from infected cows.

This is a far more worrying finding that the previous one that mice could contract the disease after innoculation of infected material straight into their brains. After all, (some) humans eat cows. Many must have eaten infected material before BSE was recognised, and many are still eating it from cows incubating the disease but not displaying symptoms by the time of their slaughter.

The research that led to this finding was carried out at the Royal Veterinary College. Mice were fed up to about 9 grams of minced brain from cows with BSE over a week. Those that ate most developed symptoms of nervous disease similar to those in mice infected by the sheep disease scrapie.

Autopsy of the "mad mice" revealed signs of BSE in their brains: protein fibres disrupting brain cells and holes where clumps of brain cells had died.

These findings are important for two reasons:

• they strengthen the assumption held by many scientists that BSE is caused by the same organism that causes the degenerative brain disease scrapie in sheep;

• they show it is possible to contract it through eating infected material. This is in line with the widely-held theory that cows picked up the disease through being fed protein supplements made from various left-over bits of sheep and other unsavoury ingredients.

Potentially more worrying may be the results of similar experiments feeding other parts of infected cows to mice. If they can get BSE from these parts as well, it makes the government's ban on the use of just brain and spinal cord tissue rather less effective.

At present, unwanted bones (including skulls), intestines and other organs are stewed up for hours at pressure cooker temperatures. The water and fat are removed, the latter for use in soap and make-up, and the resulting powder fed to cattle, pigs and poultry as meat and bone meal.

----- pull-quotes -----

Class magazine, its editor, A. Sivanandan, launches a sustained and powerful assault,

the New Timers, Sivanandan argues,

moral grounds than Englishmen

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 433

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →