Marxism Today
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
But, says Sivanandan, 'all that it shifted was the focus of responsibility for the impoverishment of struggle against and conflict with the state.
So New Times is live in poverty and squalor to be a socialist, as Beatrix Campbell so derisorily implies,' Sivanandan comments acidly, 'but the capacity to identify yourself with those who do, helps.' Indeed.
And there is nothing to be sneered at in Sivanandan's essentially moral case against the New Timers. But there is an element lacking in his alternative that substantialiy weakens it. Crudely, Sivanandan's own conception of class has too exclusively moral a tone to it; he seems, even, unhappy with the notion of class, aggressive though he is against what the New Timers say.
"The old marxists were...too wedded to orthodoxy to see that the old relations of production were disintegrating...they could not bear to think that it was Capital that was now being emancipated from Labour.' "The productive forces were pregnant with a new economic and social order...It required Mrs Thatcher to take a knife to the unions before the new order could be born.
So Sivanandan concludes his assault with a quick survey of the struggles that demonstrate a conwhole range of working class people who have been involved in 'traditional' class struggles, against the employers and against the state.
Why do these struggles get no mention in Sivanandan's account? Because he also has a New Times theory, albeit one on firmer moral ground than Marxism Today's. I'm not sure every aspect of it is coherently thought out: but Sivanandan seems uncomfortable with traditional working class struggles. He seems to doubt their relevance.
Of course there are many new issues to be addressed by socialists; of course there have been important changes, to the economy, to the working class, even to 'culture' that broad concept so adored by Marxism Today. But it is important also not to lose sight of what is not new, or of the elements of newness that do not at all justify the New Timers' conclusions. Sivanandan says that what he calls their 'apostasy' is 'premature'; and so it is. But perhaps it is still more premature than he seems to believe.
This treatment will kill all bacteria and viruses except the scrapie organism, which resists not only heat but also ultra violet light and irradiation.
So does the scrapie organism get into the meat and bone meal? There is concern that the government ban on brain and nerve tissue is being negated by such slaughterhouse practices as sawing cows' heads in half with chainsaws to remove the brains. Brain tissue is splattered everywhere, and it is difficult to ensure that none gets through.
Is this relevant to us? It has been pointed out by government spokespeople that scrapie has been known for at least two hundred years, and yet there is no recorded case of a human catching it. Humans do get degenerative brain diseases but there is no evidence to link them with scrapie. Why worry about BSE?
The reason for worry is the small but real chance that the scrapie organism, having crossed into another species, will change. The different environment may allow the selection of mutants better able to flourish.
This may well be what happened when the AIDS virus crossed the species barrier into humans. If the scrapie organism has changed in its passage through cows, it may become more infective or less. There is no way of predicting it but, in view of the devastating consequences if it were to spread into people, the utmost caution is justified.