James Patrick Cannon 1890-1974
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: the machine split had run this page-9 article into Bob Fine's 'The politics of Nelson Mandela' and filed its last columns, with the boxed Cannon quotation 'Revolutionaries or cheering squad?', as a separate item. Transcribed from the scan of page 9, the box at the end. 'success ws registered' and 'they lead' are as printed; the photo captions are left out.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 9
James P Cannon was born one hundred years ago this week. Until his death in August 1974, he remained one of the leading socialists of the generation shaped by the Russian Revolution of 1917.
Socialist Organiser is one of the currents shaped and influenced by Cannon’s ideas and example.
Cannon, who lived just short of 85 years, was uniquely a product of the American labour movement. Cannon was born on 11 February 1890 in Rosedale, Kansas. His parents were radicals and Irish immigrants. His father spent over 20 years in the early Socialist Party (SP). At the age of 12, Cannon was working in a local meat packing house. At 18, he joined the SP — the great radical Socialist Party of Eugene Debs, which had deep roots in the labour movement. Its success ws registered when Eugene Debs, SP candidate for President in 1912, gained over a million votes.
As was common at the time for American radicals, Cannon joined the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) and the SP. The IWW was active, with its slogan ‘One Big Union’. It organised thousands of unskilled and foreign-born workers shunned by the conservative, craft based racist unions of the American Federation of Labour. Cannon became an IWW travelling organiser, arguing for workers’ solidarity and militant industrial trade unionism.
In 1919 the left in the SP broke away to found the Communist Party. It wasn’t easy. Many CP members were foreign born communists only used to illegal activity in Europe, many not even speaking English. Many of them argued against legal work in the labour movement. This was the time of the ‘Palmer Raids’, when many thousands of foreign-born leftists were deported and the young American CP was driven underground. But when conditions improved and legal work became possible, many communists made a principle of underground work and denounced those who wanted to take advantage of legal openings as “liquidators of the revolutionary party”!
Cannon and others successfully opposed these ideas. In 1921 the CP launched a legal party — the Workers Party — with Cannon as its first national chairman.
American Communism was born into difficult times. In 1921 capitalism stabilised after a wave of workers’ militancy following the Russian revolution and the end of the war. Lenin’s Communist (or Third) International was faced with the task of building stable sections in every country. But the rise of Stalinism prevented healthy CPs being built.
The rise of Stalin and the growing bureaucratisation of the Communist International locked some American Communists into a life of permanent factional gang warfare inside the party.
In 1928, Cannon was a delegate to the Communist International’s 6th World Congress in Moscow. At the Congress, he came across Trotsky’s ‘Criticism of the Draft Programme of the Communist International’, which was a systematic criticism of the long record of criminal blunderings which made up the story of the CI’s history from 1923.
This document was given to commission members only accidentally. With a Canadian comrade, Maurice Spector, Cannon read the document and was instantly convinced by Trotsky’s ideas.
Cannon and Spector realised that siding with Trotsky was a serious business. It was five years into the campaign against Trotsky, who was already defeated and exiled to a remote region of the Soviet Union. Siding with Trotsky meant isolation and expulsion. Smuggling the ‘Criticism’ out of the USSR — in the teddy bear of a delegate’s daughter — they cautiously showed it to comrades in the American CP. Slowly Cannon gained the support of two other members of the CP’s leading committee: Martin Abern, a leader of the Young Communist League, and Max Shachtman, a gifted journalist.
Rumours spread in the CP about what Cannon was doing. He refused to confirm them, knowing that this would mean instant expulsion. Eventually the situation became unbearable for the CP leaders. Cannon, Abern and Shachtman were tried for Trotskyism.
The star witness against them was the manager of the CP’s bookshop, who said that they had to be Trotskyists...because they had asked for books about China!
Stalin’s misleadership of the Chinese Communists during the Second Chinese Revolution (1925-7) was one long series of criminal stupidities and subsequent cover-ups. It was one of the key questions around which the initial nucleus of Trotskyists was organised.
The three drew out the trial until the audience grew to a hundred — and then Cannon boldly came out for Trotskyism, indicting the party leaders in the name of the Left Opposition.
They were expelled from the CP. It was October 1928. Within a week they were selling their own Trotskyist newspaper, The Militant, outside the CP offices on Union Street in New York!
The Militant carried all of Trotsky’s major articles. Within a year, over a hundred CP members had joined the Trotskyists.
Through the Thirties, they worked hard: first relating to the industrial militants in the CP; then to left currents outside the CP. They did consistent work in the unions. In 1934 they lead a historic and successful battle for unionisation in Minneapolis.
During the rise of German fascism, The Militant came out twice and then thrice weekly, telling the truth about the politics of the Stalinists which allowed Hitler to power.
Cannon and his group also played a central role in building the Fourth International (FI), the world party founded by Trotsky in 1938. The Transitional Programme, the founding document of the FI, was put to the FI’s first congress in the name of the US Trotskyists.
In later life, Cannon moved to Los Angeles, but maintained membership of American Trotskyism. In the Sixties he saw it filled with youth and students cheered by the Cuban revolution and angry at the Vietnam war.
Their organisation has since degenerated into crypto-Stalinist apologists for Castro’s Cuba.
Cannon tried to warn them against holding illusions in Stalinists like Ho Chi Minh and Castro, stressing the need to build working class socialist parties, even in countries where, in his opinion, or in that of the younger comrades, the Stalinists were making or had made an anti-capitalist working class revolution.
In his last major work, ‘The Revolutionary Party’, he opposed those who said that workers in the developing capitalist countries could take power with ‘blunt weapons’ — reformist or Stalinist parties. “It would be foolish and fatal to hold that workers in the imperialist strongholds will be able to get rid of capitalism under the direction of the bureaucratised, corrupt and ossified Social Democratic or Communist parties. Here the injunction to build revolutionary Marxist parties is absolutely unconditional.”
By then, however, Cannon and his contemporaries were long in retirement. The leadership of the American Trotskyist group didn’t listen. The Socialist Workers Party (SWP — not to be confused with a British namesake) in the early ’70s was dominated by ex-students who identified radicalism more with third world nationalism than working class struggle.
Between 1979 and ’83 they broke with Trotskyism — opting instead the role of press agent for the Cuban, Nicaraguan, Afghan and other Stalinists, and purging those who defended Trotskyism.
In Cannon’s last speeches and writings, collected in ‘James P Cannon — a political tribute’ we can read Cannon defending working class socialism — sotto voce, alas — against those who strangled the SWP.
Cannon died in Los Angeles in 1974 on August 20 — the same day, bar one, Trotsky died 34 years earlier. He was the last unbroken soul of the generation of Marxists forged by the years of the 1917 revolution.
Above all, Cannon remained loyal to the spirit of his rebel youth. His last public speech was delivered in May 1974. He said: “We believe in the socialist future and are confident that it will be realised. But this will not happen by itself. The perpetuation of capitalism can lead to nothing but destruction in economic crises, wars, and eventual destruction of the entire human race, if it is allowed to go on its course. But we firmly believe it will not be allowed to do that. The working class of the world, whose power is unlimited, will act in time to avoid such a catastrophe by eliminating capitalism and inaugurating the socialist society of the future.”
Cannon’s writings are still available today. They are a lifeline; a chronicle of building up Marxist ideas in the labour movement. When the history of socialism is written by a working class freed from capitalist exploitation, Cannon will undoubtedly rank with the great revolutionary socialists of our century.
Without the long heroic work of James Patrick Cannon and his comrades in defence of democratic working class socialism and unfalsified Marxism, our chances of rebuilding a mass working class socialist movement would be immensely less than they are now, when the historical space so long occupied by Stalinism is opening up for us, and the tide of history is turning.
Revolutionaries or cheering squad?
“The degeneration of the Communist Party began when it abandoned the perspective of revolution in this country, and converted itself into a pressure group and cheering squad for the Stalinist bureaucracy in Russia — which it mistakenly took to be the custodian of a revolution ‘in another country’...What happened to the Communist Party would happen without fail to any other party, including our own, if it should abandon its struggle for a social revolution in this country, as the realistic perspective of our epoch, and degrade itself to the role of sympathiser of revolutions in other countries. I firmly believe that American revolutionists should indeed sympathise with revolutions in other lands, and try to help them in every way they can. But the best way to do that is to build a party with a confident perspective of revolution in this country. Without that perspective, Communist or Socialist Party belies its name. It ceases to be a help and becomes a hindrance to the revolutionary workers’ cause in its own country. And its sympathy for other revolutions isn’t worth much either.”
James P Cannon, 2 March 1954