No cover is a soft option
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
downstairs put the biggest McDonalds restaurant in Eastern Europe. It's a wonderful idea!"
Poland's 'Communist Youth Minister, on what to do with the old Central Committee building in Warsaw Party Constitutional Changes • Accountability of lected Representative:
On the Friday evening before the conference a rally will be held, organised by Wakefield CLP. Further informatior from CLPs Conference, Gc/o 11 Egremont Promenade, Wallasey, Merseyside L44 8BG Mribution to the debate on. ark Serwotka's letter (SO tribution to the debate on the ambulance workers dispute.
By clearly and unambiguously stating the case for a strike without emergency cover, Mark has given us the opportunity to clarify what is at stake in the Mark supports the "no cover" position as more realistic than solidarity action, a better "theoretical" idea but not practical.
Of course, socialists must base themselves on a realistic assessment of Women and Liz Millward's Women's Eye article Freedom is Fashion Slavery' struck me as ill-informed.
Does Liz think the Islington set' in their bare faces and baggy jeans - presumably worn in their expensive houses - are by virtue of this more progressive than working class women in Eastern Europe who have never had any choice about what they wear?
Her article certainly implies this. For women in Eastern Europe, wearing stilettoes after years of uniformity is, in its own way, liberating.
Fashion the state of the movement, but we must also advocate what is necessary to win. If Mark really believes his approach is preferable then surely he must also believe that Arthur Scargill was crazy for advocating a general strike in solidarity with the miners in 1984-5.
Trotsky was equally certifiable for advocating a workers united front to stop Hitler in German in the early '30s. In both circumstances the dominant forces in the labour movement opposed what was necessary politically to defend working class interests, making it "unrealistic" to believe it would ever happen.
Nevertheless, socialists still had to advocate what was necessary, and link the fight for it, to the struggle to transform the. existing labour movement in the dividuality (or should be). Yet it is only the 'Islington Set' who have that choice, by virtue of their high wages.
For many working class people, decent housing is a mere dream. Clothes are often an affordable consumer item which gives us some pride and chance to express our individuality.
Liz should read an old Women's Fightback article by Angela Fraser about a working class woman, downtrodden and tired, whose life is momentarily transformed by dolling herself up and winning a glamorous granny contest.
Tracy Smith Walworth here and now.
If we reject this approach, are only two other options:
• Sectarianism in the style of the SWP and RCP: ie, build a brand new "pure" labour movement. Use demands for solidarity action simply to "expose" the existing leadership.
• "Soft option", ie, pretend that we can win by adopting tactics that go round and ignore the existing leadership and the state of rank and file consciousness.
Mark goes for the second option.
At no point does Mark show how an all-out strike without cover would bring the Tories to their knees.
This is his argument: "Effective action is based on workers withdrawing their labour in total, in this case it would mean that working class people would be hit. However, I believe that when this occurs we must put the blame squarely on the Tories, not on the ambulance workers themselves. It will be when the crisis is at its height that the possibility for victory will be at its greatest."
Very militant, but not very convincing.
Mark's argument about strikes in essential services is confused. We are not aiding the Tories' attempt to ban such action. SO is resolutely opposed to any such bans and advocates the labour movement fights them with every means at our disposal.
To advocate emergency cover in some services is not to undermine the right to strike. It will make it easier to defend this right by taking away a propaganda ploy from the Tories.
Tom Rigby Peckham page