Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unite the left to meet the challenge of Stalinism's collapse!

Socialist Organiser no. 433, 8 February 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 1,850 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Death in Azerbaijan. After Stalinism, the alternative may be The left and the EETPU Such of world politics M for a long time to come may depend on what socialists do in the coming weeks.

In Eastern Europe the collapse of the old Stalinist regimes has put politics in flux. Socialist groups compete for workers' allegiance with nationalists, social democrats, pro-Western bourgeois parties, Stalinists-turned-Thatcherites, Stalinists-still-Stalinists, and, often, After years of the misappropriation of socialism as the ideology of nasty self-serving dictatorships, the East European masses are unfamiliar with the ideas of socialist democracy. Anti-Stalinist socialists are a minority, on the whole, and for the moment, in the democracy movements.

The undoubtedly more democratic Western European capitalist model is viewed with envy by many in the East. That we may know that their image of Western capitalism is naive, does not change the force of capitalism as an actually existing alternative.

The apparent attractiveness of capitalism makes the work of the anti-Stalinist socialists even harder. With deepening crisis, they may find rapidly growing audiences. But we have to acknowledge their weakness in most of the countries of Eastern Europe, some of which have been starved of political culture for decades.

The socialist groups lack experience, information, and the most basic material resources - printing presses, telephones, typewriters, duplicators, photocopiers.

A priority for socialists in the West is to help those socialists in the East. It is of course in our own interests to do so: a victory for socialists in Eastern Europe would be an incalculable victory for us, while a victory for capitalist forces an incalculable defeat.

So we need a campaign in the British labour movement in solidarity with socialists in the We need to publicise their activities, organise speaking tours for their representatives, raise money for their organisations. We need to do whatever we can to help them grow into the decisive force in their societies. For the Left, this must be a priority beyond merely one more solidarity campaign to add to all the rest. Upon what we do could hang the whole future of socialism in the coming years and decades.

We could only hope to achieve this solidarity if the Left unites to campaign for it. Isolated propaganda gestures will not be enough.

The Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc took the first steps towards such a united campaign at its 500-strong Conference on 27 January. We call on all the groups of the left to contact this campaign and discuss joint work.

The organisers of the campaign (including SO) have committed themselves to unity. As soon as it proves possible they are willing to dissolve their structures into a broader, more powerful, more representative campaign to build "The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race Karl Marx Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Newsdesk: 01-639 7965. Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by socialism or barbaric nationalist slaughter.

solidarity with the working class opposition and the left in Eastern Europe.

The stakes are too high for us to afford petty sectarianism, with each different left group choosing its "own" special support effort for some selected group in Eastern Europe.

The tumult in Eastern Europe has implications for Western politics, too. For decades, the Eastern Bloc has seemed to be the "actually existing" proof that capitalism can be replaced, that a different society is possible.

Demoralisation and disorientation must be extreme for the dwindling group of Western socialists who regarded Eastern Europe as a model of socialism. For the much greater number who were critical but nevertheless saw Eastern Europe as some, albeit imperfect, version of the new society to replace capitalist exploitation, the blow must be almost as great.

Those who held no brief for the USSR and Eastern Europe, but find other Stalinist system - Vietnam or Cuba, maybe — are sure to be disillusioned in their turn. And even that minority of Western socialists who insisted long before the recent upheavals that the state-monopoly systems were no nearer socialism than is capitalism - even they will feel the pressure of the deafening chorus of bourgeois triumphshouting all around us.

The collapse and discrediting of Stalinism can open the way for a great revival of the politics of workers' self-liberation - but only if socialists know how to resist and respond to the bourgeois pressure.

phone Monday.

Published by J.O'Mahony, PO Box B23, London SE15 4NA. Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. Otherwise that pressure can back a long way.

All political orientations and demarcations on the left must be re-examined in this new situation. Socialist Organiser repeats, with redoubled urgency, our appeal for the left to discuss unity which we first made in June last year.

We need to maximise and unite the force behind the argument for working class socialism as the alternative both to Stalinism and to capitalism.

We need a united left which fights to build a militant rank and file movement in industry.

We need a united left which fights for the politics of working-class self-liberation within the We need a united left which fights for solidarity with workers' and liberation struggles everywhere, West and East.

We need a united left which fights for workers' internationalism Over 1,600 electricians, members of the EETPU, have gone on strike at Ford plants across the UK.

They are on strike over two main issues: the erosion of traditional pay differentials and the imposition of a new flexibility package.

This strike raises some important questions for those on the left who would dismiss the EETPU out of hand as a 'scab outfit'.

Surely, the EETPU is behaving very much as a recognisable part of the broad trade union movement? It is defending it's member wages and conditions. It does it in a bureaucratic and sectional way, but hardly more so than the TGWU's Jack Adams has done at Ford's recently.

The EETPU in Ford is fighting flexibility and team working. EETPU leaders Eric Hammond and Roy Sanderson may be keen on 'Japanese' style working practices and single-union deals, but they can still be forced to back action by their members against those techniques.

It is time to rethink for those on the left who still advocate that militant electricians and plumbers should quit the as our answer to the growing internationalisation of capital, and the 1992 reforms in particular.

We also a need a united left to fight to make the labour movement accessible to, and responsive to the demands of women, black people and lesbians and gays.

Single issue unity will always be necessary; there will always be groups on the left which have unbridgeable divisions on one issue but need to unite on another, and we need to learn that unbridgeable divisions on one issue should not exclude unity on another. But single-issue unity is a second best.

We need to fight for unity -which means trying to thrash out a political basis for unity by debate and discussion, rather than just agreeing to disagree.

In every area, we need to take stock of ourselves, and see whether the divisions of the 1980s really correspond to the needs of the 1990s. Let's start now!

EETPU• Some breakaway unions can be liberating but the small Electricians and Plumbers Union (EPIU) and the holding branches set up by the TGWU and MSF for electricians have served only to separate activists from the great bulk of the EETPU rank and file. People who are clearly not scabs, but have chosen to stay with this union.

It won't be easy for EPIU activists to get back into the EETPU. The Hammond regime is the least democratic in the British labour movement. But that is where militant plumbers and electricians London Socialist Forum Revolution in Eastern Europe - towards socialism or capitalism?

Speakers from the opposition in tr Eastern Bloc, Socialism and Revolution (Iran) and Socialist Organiser 7.30 pm, Monday 12 February, Student Union, Institute of Education, Bedford Way WC1 After years of government denials and media dismissal, it is now established that at least some of Wallace's allegations are true.

There was indeed a 'disinformation' campaign, code-named 'Clockwork Orange', run via the army's Press Office in Northern Ireland in the mid-"70s.

Wallace's other allegations - of plots to discredit Wilson and his government, of army involvement in assassination campaigns, and of a cover-up of sexual abuse at the Kincora boys home — now begin to look a bit more plausible.

The Independent last week devoted more space than most papers to the Wallace case, but regular readers may have been surprised by the absence of anything from Ireland correspondent David McKittrick. This was all the more telligence matters and the fact that his personal contact with Wallace goes back to the mid-"70s -precisely the time that 'Clockwork Orange' was in operation.

Could this strange omission have had anything to do with the Independent's 'investigation' into Wallace's claims, written by McKittrick and published on September 2 1987? These articles fairly comprehensively rejected Wallace's case and - more importantly -smeared Wallace and his fellow exarmy defector, Fred Holroyd, as liars, fantasists and Walter Mittytype characters.

McKittrick's reputation as an authority on the more byzantine aspects of the Northern Irish situation, ensured that this demolition job was accepted by most of the rest of the media. It certainly helped the government dismiss Wallace and Holroyd...until last week.

Wallace sent a lengthy and detailed complaint to the Press Council in January 1988. This complaint has yet to be heard, due to Independent editor Andreas Whittam-Smith's repeated prevarication. Last week's silence from McKittrick can reasonably be presumed to have resulted from length consultations on how exactly to respond to the government's admission that the Wallace story was at least partly true.

Finally, on Saturday (four days after the official admission) an article by McKittrick appeared. The introduction to this piece referred to the 1987 article and the Press Council case, stressing that McKittrick had not dismissed all of Wallace's allegations. McKittrick himself went on to repeat his general doubts about Wallace's reliability.

Some journalists notably Paul Foot and Private Eye) have suggested that McKittrick's apparent determination to undermine Wallace's credibility has some sinister ulterior motive. I'm not so sure. People like Wallace (or, come to that, Peter Wright) are shifty characters and a serious journalist would be right to mistrust them. McKittrick has a pretty good record as a serious and well-informed commentator on Northern Ireland. He was one of the few journalists to pursue the Guildford Four case with any vigour. Why can't McKittrick simply admit that he made a mistake when he wrote off Wallace back in 1987? We all make mistakes, after all.

----- pull-quotes -----

their "actually existing" new socie- ty in an idealised vision of some

mistake uddenly, Colin Wallace Saner years of BoNe-

remarkable, given McKittrick's reputation as an 'expert' on in-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 433

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →