Children lose out
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Since I first wrote about the effects of parental separation on children, Mrs Thatcher has put forward her plan to maintain the family unit. As there are two sides to this debate the Tories are dealing with both.
Firstly research, originating in the United States, has chronicled the psychological effect of divorce on children. This research, conducted over 15 years by-Julie Wallerstein of the Institute for the Family in Transition, concludes that children are traumatised by their parents splitting up.
Julie Wallerstein has found that such children worry that if one parent can 'leave them' so can the other. The effect of this is to induce profound insecurity and leads to difficult in forming stable relationships in later life.
Other institutions and individuals (including my critics) feel that concentration on the psychological harm done to children obscures the other, more pressing problem of the poverty which often results from divorce.
Thatcher's response is to lecture parents on the importance of family life (the psychology question) and to insist that the parent who leaves pays maintenance (the poverty question).
In fact Thatcher's proposals will not solve either problem. A lecture on family life will not mend a relationship in trouble. Organisations like 'Relate' and other counselling and conciliation services might.
Yet Thatcher has presided over the financial running down of organisations like these. In some areas of the country you can wait months for an appointment with a trained counsellor - and in the meantime the relationship continues to collapse.
Thatcher is also proposing to chase partners for maintenance. This, admits Minister Tony Newton, is no more than an attempt to lessen the amount of welfare benetits claimed by single parents.
Single parents will still be poor if the absent partner is poor. The absent partner may have a second family - who might start claiming. And some women may not want the father of their children "found" because he was violent or abusive.
What then would help the children of separated parents? To deal with the psychology question, a recognition of the needs of children for both parents. But we need more research - because many of the problems raised by Julie Wallerstein seem to affect children from 'nuclear' families also.
We have to accept the crying need of children for the presence of the absent parent (male or female), and, as a society, make it possible for both parents to spend time with their children. Too often 'access' is an artificial 'two hours on Sunday' when the parent takes the child to the park, or McDonalds, week after week. Under these circumstances it is not surprising that parents lose touch with their children, and the access visits become fewer and further between.
At the same time, we have to recognise that for the parents, constant meetings to 'exchange' children serve to re-open wounds best allowed to heal. How can a mother, left holding the baby, be expected to present the father in a good light, or be pleased to see him when he turns up once a week?
Thatcher proposes nothing to help with these problems, which for the sake of the child, must be solved. Thatcher is going to exacerbate these problems by introducing bitterness and financial wranglings into an already fraught relationship.
The problem of financial hardship is more easily dealt with, but Thatcher still offers no solution. Obviously a man (or a woman) should not simply walk away and leave his family to cope without his financial help. But that is secondary to providing for the family left behind.
A mother with young children cannot simply go out to work to provide for them unless she has a support network behind her. Yet social services, nurseries, public transport, after-school events and welfare benefits have all been cut and cut.
The vast majority of parents would, far rather provide for their children by their own efforts than spend the day waiting for the Giro, or queued in the DSS, but Thatcher's policies have made this harder and harder.
My critics are right to say that there is no real solution to these problems this side of socialism. They are right to say that poverty, bad housing, lack of nurseries are more pressing and immediate problems than the possible trauma of relationship breakdown.
But they are wrong to forget or ignore those needs because they are so difficult to deal with. As I said in my original article, children are always the innocent party, and adult convenience should never be allowed to come before children's needs.
For all its faults, the American research convinces me that children are damaged when one parent leaves, however unpleasant he or she may have been. We have a responsibility to face up to that, and to argue for better conciliation services, more sympathetic access arrangements, and above all for a society which gives rights to children.