[Clive Bradley looks at the latest controversy surrounding…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Clive Bradley looks at the latest controversy surrounding Salman Rushdie's "Satanic Verses'. W Rushdie's eloquent hether Salman defence of his novel, The Satanic Verses, and his motives in writing it, will prove effective in convincing any significant number of those Muslims who now wish to see him dead, remains to be seen.
If anything might convince them, Rusdie's essay in last week's Independent on Sunday would surely be it.
Rushdie states clearly that he is not a Muslim (therefore cannot be accused either of blasphemy or apostasy), though he was born one. he writes from the point of view of a non-believer. The book is not, however, intended primarily as a critique of Islam, but as an examination of the conflict between the sacred and the profane in people's lives - in particular, the lives of "formerly-colonised, stilldisadvantaged peoples.
"If The Satanic Verses is anything it is a migrant's-eye view of the world. It is written from the very experience of uprooting, disjuncture and metamorphosis... that is the migrant condition."
He cannot be blamed for the violence that has been associated with the book: in India, Pakistan and Iran, fundametalist politicians had their own reasons to stir up religious conflicts; in Britain, too, "secular and religious leaders had been vying for power in the community for over a decade... (and) the 'affair' swung the balance of power back towards the mosques."
Nor is the criticism cogent (often heard particularly form other writers, like the abominable Roald Dahl, who exhibit undisguised envy of Rushdie's literay abilities) that he "knew what he was doing" and should suffer the consequences. «When the students filled Tiananmen Square to ask for freedom, were they not also, knowingly, asking for the murderous repression that resulted? When Terry Waite was taken hostage, hadn't he been "asking for it"?...
"Even if I were to concede (and I do not concede it) that what I did..
was the literary equivalent of flaunting oneself shamelessly before the eyes of aroused men, is that really a justification for being, so to speak, gang-banged?"
The controversy is now focused on the issue of whether or not Penguin should publish a paperback edition of the book. Many well-known writers, including some surprising ones (like the Marxist art critic John Berger), think they should not. Rushdie himself argues publication of a book, and to fail to publish it would be, in effect, to ban it by the back door.
Opposition to its paperback publication, from nonfundamentalists depends on the idea that innocent people, like shop assistants, could be attacked, or even killed, for the sake of a very abstract principle (an 'outmoded') principle in Roald Dahl's view, so maybe the BBC should deprive him of his right to freely inflict Tales of the Unexpected' on innocent viewers), and - the harshest critics would add - the ego of one man. John Le Carre has argued this case most forcefully.
You could say with greater force still that books likely to prove half as controversial as this one should never be published. In countries which rountinely ban books, booksellers that stock them run the risk of imprisonment or worse. Shops selling socialist books might, in future, run the serious risk of fascist attack. In Eastern Europe today, some bookshops must run the risk of attack from antisemites.?
Anyone who concludes that therefore authors and booksellers should bow down before the threat of violence is an idiot, whose supposed humanitarianism will in fact only contribute to the spread of