Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Slit wrist solidarity?

Socialist Organiser no. 432, 1 February 1990 · scan p. 11 · about 1,388 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

By Sleeper Now sit down somewhere talking about the ambulance dispute and in a bit I'm going to come out with some pretty wild, ultra-left stuff. So brace yourselves.

First, the problem: as we've noted before, Roger Poole and his PR team have done a pretty good job in winning the war of words against the Fat Man from Ronnie Scott's... but.. Mr Poole and his associates have no visible means of actually winning beyond something rather nebulous called "People Power" . Extensive enquiries amongst the lower and middle reaches of the trade union bureaucracy have so far failed to uncover any precise meaning to the expression "People's Power" • The nearest to something vaguely resembling an actual "strategy' that I have so far discovered is the idea that events like the forthcoming double-figure pay award to NHS managers and even the forthcoming (May!) local government elections, will somehow force the government's hand. The problems with this sort of "strategy' seem to my unsophisticated mind, fairly obvious.

1. It's rather long term. Well before the government is punished by the righteous indignation of the voters in May, the dispute could have begun (at least) to fray at the edges, demoralisation could have set in, collection buckets could have lost their magical appeal to the public etc etc.

2. Since when has this government -of all governments - been particularly prone to such emotions as embarrassment, shame, etc., etc?

More to the point, since when has this government's actions been dictated by such considerations? They reckon they can ride the storm of public approbation, just as they've done over the health service 'reforms' and the very slick BMA campaign.- Meanwhile the Fat Man at the bar in Ronnie Scott's will lean back and wait for the dispute to crumble.

Two possible ways out of this impasse are presently being canvassed by the left and by the increasing number of rank and file ambulance workers who realise Things Can't Go On Like This, and even (privately) by some sections of the bureaucray (NALGO) in particular. The two options are not necessarily mutually exclusive, but in practice probably would be. They are:

1. Up the stakes in the ambulance service itself by balloting for all-out strike (without emergency cover?). This (the argument goes) would galvanise the will of the ambulance workers and shock the government to the negotiating table. Any adverse effect in terms of 'public opinion' would be outweighed by the likelihood that the public would blame the government for the crisis at least as much as they blamed the ambulance workers and pressure on the Fat Man and Co would become irresistable.

2. Keep the dispute itself more or less at its present level the question of whether or not ambulance crews are formally 'on strike' being not particularly important, one way or the other) but drop the nonsense about "People Power" and go for solidarity strike action throughout industry, taking the calculated risk that the government wouldn't dare invoke its anti-union legislation in such a popular dispute..

The second argument was the common wisdom of the left in the early days of the dispute. Increasingly now, it is being superseded in papers like "Socialist Worker' by the first argument. The reason for this has more to with good old-fashioned opportunism than with any objective analysis of the facts. Crucially, a lot of rank and file militants in the ambulance service itself are now advocating Option 1, while Option 2 appears to them too difficult, too abstract and just plain unlikely to happen...

As I said, Option 1 does not necessarily preclude Option 2. But... developing a strategy for winning a dispute is often a question of priorities. Where do you devote your energies? At this point I must come clean and confess to a possibly heretical opinion: that is, that nothing the ambulance crews on their own do will be sufficient to win a decisive victory. Only if solidarity strike action on a pretty massive scale can be organised, will this dispute be brought to a satisfactory conclusion. If I am right about this (and I have yet to hear a convincing argument to the contrary) then questions of whether or not the ambulance crews declare themselves on strike, withdraw emergency cover, etc etc, become at best, secondary tactical matters.

There may, in fact, be a case for a national strike but there is no case that I can fathom for voluntarily withdrawing emergency cover (the two issues have tended to get confused in the course of the debate so far). If it were true that withdrawing emergency cover would increase the pressure on the government to reach a settlement, then how do you explain the eagerness with which local managements have attempted to sabotage ambulance workers' efforts to provide an emergency service?

If we accept that organising solidarity action is the key to winning this one, then there are powertul arguments against withdrawing emergency cover voluntarily. It is sometimes forgotten that trade unionists are also members of the public (and vice-versa). The goodwill that has been built up by the ambulance crews' well-publicised efforts to provide an emergency service ought to be a strong lever for solidarity action. The only argument I've ever heard against this is "How can we ask other workers to go on strike in support of a group of workers who aren't even on all-out strike themselves?". This argument invariably comes from lefties who've never done a hand's turn in their lives outside of a student's union or an FE lecture room. Any industrial trade unionist who used such an argument would be immediately branded a Grade "A' Hypocrite and a Shit by the vast majority of honest workers. The student revolutionary and the NATHE activist at least have the excuse of ignorance.

Now for the ultra-left bit you've all been waiting for! If we accept that the ambulance workers' willingness to provide an emergency service is potentially beneficial to the prospects of widespread solidarity action, then it surely makes sense to up the stakes in efforts to provide an emergency service. One problem with the dispute so tar has, in fact, been the willingness of bureaucrats and rank and file alike to accept legality in this matter: in the West Midlands the mere withdrawal of insurance cover by management per suaded crews to abandon efforts to provide an alternative service using regular ambulances. Instead, Sandwell Council brought in a small fleet of renovated old knackers from a firm in Wigan who usually specialise in the Third World market. Why not say (to management) "Sod you, we're taking our ambulances out with or without insurance"? Who would have objected?

In Camden, ambulance crews have occupied their stations. They made contact with the local NCU branch who agreed not to cut of the 'phones even supply yuppie 'phones as well.

The problem was that all emergency calls went first to the Controllers at Waterloo (members of the same unions as the ambulance crews) who were ordered by management to stop sending calls direct to the stations: instead *'999" calls had to be diverted to the police. The unions instructed the controllers to strike in protest, but only six responded and they were immediately suspended. Similar things have occured all over the country.

The obvious answer is for the ambulance crews and the NCU to defy the Ambulance Service Management and (more importantly) a whole host of laws of the land and set up their own emergency centre under workers control. Not easy. Shades of the Barcelona telephone exchange which workers helf for 10 months during the Spanish revolution until they were attacked by the police and communist party thugs. But it would certainly up the stakes and put management and government on the defensive. Most importantly, it would provide a dramatic focus for solidarity action. The only worthwhile alternative I've heard so far came from a TGWU militant who replied to the suggestion of an all-out strike without emergency cover with the memorable words, "that's not militant enough — we should all go out into the streets and slit our own wrists in solidarity with the ambulance crews" • Was that ultra-left enough for you? ("No - Ed").

----- pull-quotes -----

N comfortable and pour yourself a stiff drink. We're

KIC WHy PRACTUFCHYOU

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 432

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →