Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Lay Fever Nostroune

Socialist Organiser no. 432, 1 February 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 437 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Dey Catarre «E Ter MALAL NUANE (omer :

Truman ordel Clive Bradley ast week, Socialist Organiser reproduced the famous letter from Trotsky's widow, Natalia Sedova, in which she announced her decision to part company with the Fourth International.

In our introduction, we commented that whatever the subsequent politics either of Sedova or of those she was criticising, in the substance of her letter, she was right against them - that is, in her more vehemently critical attitude to Stalinism.

But in one important respect, Sedova was wrong: she appears, in her letter, to endorse a position of opposition to both sides in the Korean War of 1950-53, both to the United States and its imperialist allies, and to the North Koreans, backed by China and the USSR.

This is a position associated also with the British Socialist Workers' Party, whose leader, Tony Cliff, originally broke with orthodox Trotskyism' precisely over this question.

It cannot follow from general hostility to Stalinism that we are indifferent to the right of nations to self-determination. Even if the Koreans were led by Stalinists and allied to the Stalinist superpower, they had the right not to be invaded right to resist them. the socialists who supported the North Koreans were right, even if on the broader issues of Stalinism they were wrong.

Cliff, for example, later implicitly shifted his ground, by supporting North Vietnam against the United States, arguing that the Vietnamese did 1 have the right to self-determination.

There were socialists who opposed the US without giving any support to the Stalinist National Liberation Front, led by Ho Chi Minh. But in reality this was an evasive attitude; moreover, it was one shared by the pro-Moscow communist parties, who thought that too overt support for the struggle in Vietnam would alienate public opinion in the West.

In fact, it was clear commitment such support that June 11 054 Britain backs SKETCH Russia is told:

• borend A LINGA North retreats miles ION - 00 From page restoration of capitalism. Yet "penury, austerity and vast exploitation" is the price the workers have paid to Stalinism for decades - plus a totalitarian state which Trotsky said was worse than fascism (in The Transitional Programme, which is precisely why they are tearing it down!

For Socialist Outlook the key is preventing the victory of imperialism, rather than bettering the lot of the working class.

Imperialism triumphant especially US imperialism, would wreak an orgy of revenge against its opponents in the third world. New inter-imperialist conflicts would much more easily turn into wars."

----- pull-quotes -----

forces to Korı AAYHYAPK im change

gains lini

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 432

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →