Defeat the threat from the right!
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
socialist als for solidarity Iready there are fascist A groups organising in Poland," said Milka Tyszkiewicz from the Polish Socialist Party (Democratic Revolution).
*There have already been attacks by fascists on a leftist group in Warsaw.
"People who are glad that we have finished one totalitarian system in Eastern Europe are wrong to think Analyse ary tor this means we are finished with all authoritarian regimes. There is still a struggle.
"If we don't receive any help from the Western left -money, information, books, help from intellectuals -there could soon be no left current in Poland.
'The economic situation is very bad. We have price rises like there were in Germany before Hitler came to power.
"In Warsaw, gangs of children hunt cats and dogs, not as a game, but to kill them and eat them.
*The situation is very urgent."
Bill Lomax assessed the historical significance of the Hungarian workers' uprising of 1956.
Scan page 8
Liz Millward reviews 'Socialist Organiser and the Eastern Bloc a pamphlet by Paul Stevens, published Socialist Outlook Over the last two years • Socialist Organiser has been conducting a public debate on the nature of the Stalinist states.
Articles have been written, debates held. Through our paper and magazine we have invited contributions from the left. Recent events have brought a new sharpness and urgency to the debate.
Workers in the Eastern Bloc have been demonstrating their feelings, their response to decades of Stalinist rule. That response has been overwhelming: Stalinism must go. Secret police terror must go. Shortages must go. Instead, the masses of the Eastern Bloc demand democracy, freedom to travel, freedom to organise and enough to eat.
It seems that millions of East European and USSR workers are — mistakenly - willing to look to the free-enterprise market as the fulcrum of both freedom and prosperity.
A series of revolutions and attempted revolutions are sweeping established Stalinists from direct political power to be replaced by — what? The world is changing.
We may be witnessing the beginning of a struggle for genuine socialism in these countries. Workers in the streets have begun to take power away from their Stalinist oppressors and exploiters, and they may take power into their own hands. But that outcome is not inevitable, or even likely, unless the workers learn fast, and organise strongly and quickly.
Because world capitalism is also ready to step in to the Eastern Bloc. Its propaganda machine is already there, aided by social democracy, East and West.
These events will be decided and shaped by class struggle. One class will win and another be defeated. The working class is in a position to make history. It is only the active intervention of the working class which will make socialism, the active participation of its organisations and parties in the class struggle which can ensure a good outcome for the proletariat and for socialism.
So socialists in this country have a duty to help the working class in Eastern Europe. They need every weapon we can give them. One weapon is solidarity, another is theory - the historic overview which (for now) a combination of Stalinist censorship over decades and Stalinist lies about what socialism is obscured from the eyes. of most newly awakened workers in the East.
One thing is vital and irreplaceable - and that is to get it across that the present and coming events are a class war, which workers must win or lose. There can be no compromises on basics, and another chance may not come again for a long time.
For socialists our call to the East European and USSR working class must be first and foremost a call to action - action in defence of their conditions, inadequate as they are, against such things as the prospect of mass unemployment, and action to better those conditions and to secure a socialist outcome from the crisis and breakdown of Stalinism. Outlook's polemic The Socialist Outlook pamphlet issued at the CSWEB conference is full of distortions, as you would expect, and strange, factionallygenerated misconstructions about Socialist Organiser's politics.
They have the polemical stupidity and political dishonesty to suggest that Socialist Organiser thinks - or logically should think because we see nothing "progressive' in Stalinism that the October revolution should hot have happened!
But worse than that, it gives no help to East European or USSR workers struggling for political clarity about the crisis of Stalinism. Instead it tells them how lucky they were under the Stalinist yoke. It tells them the same things that their Stalinist exploiters have been telling them for years. Outlook dwells on the horrors full blown marketism will inflict on the East European and USSR workers, if it can. They do this only to contrast marketism unfavourably with the Stalinist status quo, and build up ludicrously false and positive picture of the very Stalinist systems whose horrors and deficiencies have driven millions of workers in the East — for example, Solidarnosc in Poland - to embrace, or look favourably on marketism.
"First, capitalist production would be re-introduced on the basis of destroying the real social gains — in terms of job security, social services, health care, rhythm of work which the masses in these countries have won... [my emphasis] "Penury, austerity and vast exploitation would be the price paid by the workers...
"(We must) build on and extend the social gains of the masses under bureaucratic rule...
..the states...have seen both horrible repression and irrationality and tremendous social progress...
In the whole pamphlet there is not one word about democracy democracy which is the demand of workers fighting Stalinism. There is nothing about the freedom to travel or even the freedom to think and organise, ie. the prerequisite of a creative self-activating working class movement, which is for socialists the only protagonist of the struggle for socialism.
But then the tendency to which Socialist Outlook belong have spent 40 yeas spinning scenarios about an "ongoing" world revolution from which the working class has been absent - which is to produce the play "Hamlet' and forget the Prince of Denmark!
Outlook are so out of touch with the world outside their formulas that their response to the revolutions in Eastern Europe is to tell the workers how well off they are compared to their brothers and sisters under capitalism - even as Eastern Bloc peoples are demonstrating in action that they know it is not so.
Many of the East European revolutionaries do not know the bad side of capitalism - the poverThey do not know that private homelessness, unemployment. ownership strangles freedom as much as the Stalinist bureaucracy. Part of our job is to tell them.
But we have to tell them the truth about capitalism in a way which makes sense according to their own experience of life under Stalinism. democracy is a big improvement on Stalinist authoritarianism. Simply to ignore this issue as Outlook does is to cut yourself off from the struggle, not to speak of making it impossible to talk to workers willing to risk their lives in a struggle for democracy - even though it is for an ill-defined 'democracy'. To say that in terms of the quality of life capitalism is worse than the tyranny which they have suffered for the last 60 years is to lose the respect of people who walk into Berlin and see well-stocked shops. well-fed people and the open sale of Czech workers' general strike goods and travel tickets - for the first time in their lives.
At the moment, the East European states are 'led' by people who want to embrace capitalism, at least in a limited way. But until the last few months, the Stalinist rulers, whilst admitting that a few mistakes had been made in the past, contrasted their own system with capitalism in the same terms that Outlook does.
Using such talk about the social gains' since the revolution does not make Outlook a bunch of Stalinists, but it does make one doubt their grip on reality. They are like people who have been too badly shocked to be able to register what's going on around them!
Outlook does not engage with real workers in the real world. Their concerns are reflected in banal passages like this:
*Just contemplating the disastrous consequences of the restoration of capitalism reveals the fact that the very existence of the post-capitalist states, despite everything, is a vital component of the political relationship of forces on a world scale." You didn't know that now did you?
Disentangled, the logic of this must be a call for the retention of Stalinism as a counter to imperialism — until we can replace it with socialism. They engage in shame-faced defence of the old Stalinist status quo after the Stalinists have moved on!
For Outlook the world falls into two camps - imperialism and the rest. The USSR and its 'allies' form an anti-imperialist bloc and the world is divided between the two camps.
In Outlook's programme, people do not fight imperialism, "anti-imperialism" does! We know that imperialism will be overthrown by the working class. Socialist Outlook's support for the "anti-imperialist" bloc is de facto support for Stalinism itself. Polemical exaggeration? Look at the facts!
Throughout the Afghan war, the two groups from which Socialist Outlook originate both refused to call for the withdrawal of Russian troops. Even when the Russian armies were fighting not imperialism but the Afghan people, they were supported by Outlook. A defeat for the Russians would have equalled a victory for imperialism according to the theory and that must be avoided even if the cost is the lives of thousands of Afghan peasants, and the driving of 5 million (out of about 20 million population) over the borders as refugees.
Now, after the event, they have changed their position. But there is no sell-crucisin and younger com rades probably don't know the group's history phlet even says it was "criminal" -ten years too late. What word fits these "Trotskyists" who gave shame-faced support to the "Red" Army when it was dropping napalm on Afghan villages? "Criminal" perhaps? Today, even Gorbaches probably thinks it was "criminal"
The anti-imperialist bloc is not an abstract concept. It is the Stalinist states, states ruled by bureaucracies as exploitative and as oppressive as anything capitalism can come up with, and with a history just as bloody. Being part of an anti-imperialist bloc dreamed up by Outlook theorists does not wipe the blood from the bureaucrats' hands. There is no case for support for the continuation of these states -unless from the point of view of a Moscow cold warrior. Anti-imperialism, like charity, begins at home.
The final defeat of imperialism will come from the hands of the working class of the imperialist nations - as Lenin and Trotsky pointed out. Outlook would do well to remember that rather than place their faith in imaginary anti-imperialist blocs. The ruling classes have too much in common with each other for us to have any faith in either.
Outlook in its theory makes a distinction between defence of the property relations of the Eastern Bloc "against imperialism" and the bureaucracy which rules those states. In this pamphlet the distinction is blurred - probably the result of polemical overexcitement. But in the world outside "the world historical process" , the distinction between property relations and those who control them for personal gain is also blurred.
What 60 years of Stalinism shown us more than anything else is that nationalised property can be a tool for exploitation. It is only better than capitalism when it is under workers' control. Socialist Outlook, in their defence of nationalised property, fall into the trap of seeing it as somehow separate from the bureaucracy, as if it had an inherent purity, quite separate from who controls it.
Outlook do appear to blur this distinction in phrases like "the social gains of the masses under bureaucratic rule which imply that the bureaucracy itself has a positive role to play.
In fact, the distinction itself is false. In China, which Outlook rightly points out, we do not think is, or ever has been a workers' state, the nationalised property was created by the bureaucracy. The workers have never had control of that property, even though it was supposedly held by the bureaucracy for them. Chinese workers are cruelly exploited by the bureaucracy and nationalised property, by itself has done nothing for them.
The rigid control of the Chinese economy by the bureaucracy has allowed the alleviation of the worst of the periodic famines. Rigid control under the feudal emperors used to do the same thing. But that rigid control, allied to some of Mao's policies also caused famine in China. For example: 20 million and possibly a lot more - died between 1958-61 as a result of Mao's "Great Leap Forward'.
So when Outlook talk of defence of nationalised property, they are also in fact, and whatever they might want defending the bureaucracy, which controls it and profits from it.
Socialist Outlook believes these Stalinist societies are "transitional societies" better than capitalism, but not yet socialism. They know that a political revolution is needed to make the final step to socialism.
In the real world, the bureaucracy will not simply melt away as part of a smooth transition'. It has to be smashed, to allow the workers time and space to organise to take power. That has begun — and because of the nature of the Stalinist states there is no organisation which can take the workers to victory like the Bolsheviks did in 1917. For many decades the Stalinists have systematically uprooted the beginnings of such an organisation. That means there is the risk of "imperialism" getting in.
The question must be asked -would Socialist Outlook rather not stick with the "gains" brought by the bureaucracy, than take the risk of standing with the workers? Logically they should stick with the bureaucracy. If they choose to side with the workers, as they must and will - they will have to abandon their previous theory and engage in a serious debate.
Instead they fudge the issue in passages like this:
"While the experience of the mass movement-against Stalinism is itself an important gain for workers everywhere - and only on the basis of this is there the possibility of the overthrow of the Stalinist bureaucracy - if the outcome is the restoration of capitalism it would be a world-historic disaster.
It can only be a "world-historic disaster" if it were a regressive step, rather than simply a step out of a blind alley. The restoration of capitalism is in no sense a progressive step. But it is only regressive if you accept, as Outlook does, that there is something positive about Stalinism. Outlook says that "Penury, austerity and vast exploitation would be the price paid by the workers" for the urn to page 10