The 'crisis of socialism'
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-02-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Is everybody tells us, through "crisis of socialism".
In the East, the "actually existing socialisms" have collapsed or are collapsing. Everywhere in Europe, outside the USSR and Albania, the central pillar of the old authoritarian structure, the politica monopoly of the Stalinist party, has gone. In the USSR, the Stalinists' monopoly has been very badly shaken, and to a considerable extent is already breached.
The rulers, those who in the name of socialism strutted for decades on the dizzy ramparts of dictatorial political power above a regimented and terrorised people, now disavow themselves and their system. They also disavow socialism and declare that the moral, political and economic bankruptcy of East European and Russian Stalinism is not their bankruptcy alone, but the bankruptcy of socialism.
The leading "mainstream" oppositionists against the old system make the same condemnation of gusto. Communism is addin na gusto. sky" was Boris Yeltsin's sales pitch when he toured the USA a few weeks ago.
Socialists in the Trotskvist tradi. tion have for decades advocated that the workers in the Stalinist states should rise against their bureaucratic rulers, overthrow them, and reorganise the economy, replacing bureaucratic "nationalisation" with socialisation, authoritarian pseudo-planning with democratic planning, the totalitarian political rule of the bureaucrats with workers' democracy. The workers should go forward from the Stalinist state monopoly system to what might be described as "democratic collectivism"
In fact, the movement now is in the opposite direction back towards market economics and bourgeois restoration. Millions of workers, in Poland for example, follow intellectuals, priests, and drop-out bureaucrats, and choose to worship an idealised image of "the market" seeing it as the fulcrum of both prosperity and liberty.
Outside the old Stalinist bloc, the Communist Parties remain true to their vocation of the last 60 years. Now too they dutifully echo - and even anticipate - the official line from Moscow. Socialism is bankrupt, Marxism is no more than a strain of academic sociology. It is time to move on.
On? Well, back to an updated, "modernised" version of the pre socialist populist radicalism which flourished in Britain in the 1880s! No joke, or intended paradox: that is just about where the ex-Stalinists are now, politically.
But there was once a world - so they tell us, the preachers of the "crisis of socialism" - with big workers' parties. The Stalinists were revolutionary, and even the reformists talked, often sincerely, of a socialism that would abolish crisis-ridden capitalism. "The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all uman beings without distinction of ex or race".
Karl Marx Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Newedesk: 01-639 7965. Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by There was a great socialist state, the USSR, and then many socialist states, covering one third of the globe. World war and economic collapse discredited capitalism, and convinced large parts of a whole generation of bourgeois intellectuals in Europe and the USA that capitalism could not long survive and that they should work for socialism.
By contrast, Stalin's Russia burgeoned, and seemed to be the crisis-free economic model that would replace capitalism.
the aid of revolutionaries in advanced countri isolation and suffered a blor Stalinist count revolution"
How did the socialist movement come to suffer such setbacks? The "crisis" started long ago, in the early years of this century, when the movement suffered internal defeats because the ideas of the ruling class conquered a layer of its organised leaders and militants.
It collapsed politically at the outbreak of World War 1, and a renaissance was stymied by the bloody defeat of the rebel workers in Germany, Italy, Hungary and Poland at the end of it. The movement did take power in Russia, in conditions of material and economic backwardness where, according to all the teachings of Marxism and the beliefs of the leaders of the Russian Revolution, socialism could not possibly come into existence, let alone thrive.
Revolutionary Russia, deprived by bourgeois victory of the aid of revolutions in the advanced countries of the West, stagnated in isolaton and suffered a bloody Stalinist counter-revolution. The leaders of that counter-revolution continued to masquerade under the "Communist" label, but in reality they changed into its very opposite everything that Lenin's and Trotsky's communism stood for.
Misled by Stalinists and old-style reformists, the movement suffered a succession of avoidable and bloody defeats in the 1930s, with fascism triumphing in Germany and Spain. The representatives of genuine socialism were isolated from their natural base, the would-be communist workers of the 30s, who rallied to Stalin because he seemed to represent the Russian Revolution of 1917; the Trotskyists were murdered and persecuted by Stalinism and fascism all over the globe until they were marginalised and almost extirpated.
Monday.
Published by J.O'Mahony, PO Box 323, London SE15 4NA. Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Aegistered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser. debating When capitalism recovered after World War 2, there were powerful workers' organisations able to impose serious reforms on the still-inplace ruling class.
But there they stopped. Capitalism began to boom and develop at a great pace. The workers' parties stagnated and began to decay.
The reformist parties became increasingly just alternative parties of government, at ease running capitalism, concerned only with petty reform. The Stalinists in Italy and France were kept from the goal natural to their domestic politics, government office, by their links with Moscow; but their social programmes were moderate.
The whole movement drifted to the right. Socialism was a meaningless party tag for the reformists, and what existed behind the hon Curtain for the Stalinists. Millions of workers continued to believe in socialism, even if only as an ill-defined anti-capitalist aspiration. But what was socialism?
The Russian model, and the others copied from it, ceased to inspire any but a dwindling core of West Europeans + though they did inspire Third World revolutionaries, and gave them a model to aim for. Stalinism came to inspire horror in more and more workers as the facts about Russian and East European reality filtered out into an increasingly prosperous bourgeois Europe.
Over the years the Stalinised CPs moved ever more to the right. In their definition of socialism as the nationalisation of all property (even small shops) under a totalitarian state; in the practice of the Russian state, which "communists" had to endorse and glorify; in their conduct in the class struggle of the workers - in everything that makes the difference between a living, vigorous, learning, fighting working-class movement and a bureaucratic, corrupt, turbid movement, Stalinism dirtied and dragged down the working class.
The proper symbols of the crisis of socialism are not the images on our TV screens of Moscow's satraps being hounded from power in East Germany and the other satellite states, but the millions of German Obiansteho communist workers being led by Stalinists peacefully into Hitler's prison camps, and the systematic slaughter of the Trotskyists of the Soviet Union at the Vorkuta prison camp in 1938.
It is an old crisis, not a recent one. What is happening in Eastern Europe and the USSR does not indicate a deepening of that crisis, yet another degree of malaise and sickness for socialism. These are the most hopeful events in the last 60 years from the point of view of socialism - events which open the possibility of a rapid regrowth of a mass socialist working-class movement. themselves socialist not as the media tells us a crisis of socialist ideas"
The "crisis of socialism" is a crisis of those calling themselves socialists — not, as the media tells us, a crisis of socialist ideas. The Stalinist states had nothing to do with the genuine ideas of the socialists, of Marx, of Rosa Luxemburg, of Lenin. The victory of the bourgeoisie over the Stalinist socioeconomic formations does not vindicate the bourgeoisie as against socialism, despite what their propagandists, echoed by the erstwhile official socialists, say and perhaps believe.
Paradoxically this victory of the bourgeoisie may even help, by clearing away the powertul statecentred Stalinist falsification of socialism, and thus excavating the space on which socialism can revive.
The prospects of the victory of free market economics in the formerly statified East European countries does not register a crisis of socialist ideas. It is not that the genuine East European socialists lack "answers" ', lack a viable programme of socialism for those states — it is that decades of Stalinism have decimated the ranks of socialists and poisoned the social ground on which socialism can grow.
What the East European states and the USSR need instead of free market economics is:
• Social ownership of the means of production, on the basis of cooperative production.
• Democratic planning of basic economic choices. Subordination of those elements of a free market economy found to be useful to overall social needs as defined in the democratically worked-out and implemented plan.
• Democracy -effective, real democracy in which the people, in the first place the working people, daily administer their own lives in all their dimensions, including the economic. Such democracy would prove as impossible in a capitalist Eastern Europe, where the major means of production are privately owned, as it has always done in bourgeois democratic countries like Britain.
This programme derived initially from the working-class response to market capitalism. It has as its irreducible core the fight to abolish wage slavery and to destroy the state power of the bourgeoisie. The idea that it ceases to be valid because of the introduction of free market economics is as nonsensical as the idea that the exploitative Stalinist state tyranny over the people was identical with the socialist programme of a democratic, cooperative, self-administering society!
Socialists today who stand by their programme and let the bourgeois and Stalinist babblers (echoed here and there by fainthearts who should know better) get on with their quack diagnoses -these will be the very people who will prove that the disintegration of Stalinism is not the end of socialism, but the beginning of the end of the crisis that has eclipsed genuine Marxist socialism for many decades already. Socialism is reviving, not dying!
Scan page 4
s Britain go Republican?
LPE LORIVER,— YouR March in support of ambulance workers, 30 January. Photo: ike without emergency cover!
s Britain going Republican?
According to recent surveys, given wide publicity, especially in the Sunday papers, perhaps a majority of people think the Queen should abdicate before she dies - in favour, of course, of Charles, rather than an election, or something like that.
This only goes to aggravate the alarm of sections of the Establishment, including the popular press, who think Charle is a complete lunatic, dangerou radical, ozone-protector, pervayor of embarrassing opinions on architecture and language, and all-round odd-ball.
Certainly, over the past few years we have seen unusual degrees of criticism of member: of the Royal family in the media Not the Queen, mind you. Nor the Queen Mother, Britain's favourite granny. Princess Ann, in fact, is liked a lot more than she used to be, thanks to her Good Works with the Save the Children Fund, and despite her unseeming marital failure.
But everyone knows that the future King is a bad husband who allows his wife to cavort in public with other men, knows that Andrew and Fergie are bad parents who desert their baby in favour of holidays, and knows that Edward is a bad son who can't even stick it out in the marines like a real man and prefers to ponce around on television in medieval costume getting pies thrown at him.
The popular press thus have difficult job to do. On the one hand, they resolutely don't want to inflame anti-Royalist emotions to the point where the Great British Monarchy might be in danger as an institution. On the other, they don't want Charles to be King - but worse, there no one he can very easily abdicate in favour of.
There are a few facts they tend not to tell us very often, though. Did you know, for example, that the Queen stnds to save £12,000 on her Sandringham estate in Norfolk alone, as a result of the poll tax. Being Queen, you see, she won't have to pay it. She saved £5,698 las we should nationalise her prope ty. And Charles to-be-the-third should remember what happened to Charles L.... A produced in Michigan, ccording to a study USA, old people who drink coffee are nearly twice as likely to be sexually active as those who don't.
Experts in the United States have insisted that no causal link has been proven; it could just be that sexually active people like strong flavours.
Reports don't say if has to be caffeinated.
"I'm sure to eat"' Mike Gatting, after black South African workers refused to serve him.
*It is up to them, as long as they do the job the same. Blacks make good soldiers except they can't swim.
Corporal Gordon Muirhead, army instructor, explaining that the army isn't racist.
'I know an occasion when a black soldier and a white soldier were up to their necks in mud and barbed wire. One was calling the other a black so and so, and the other was calling his colleague a white so and so. It proved nothing."
Lt Colonel Donald Campbell, ex plaining that the army isn' racist "Each person is an individual to JUSTICE Geoff Ward have been following the debate on the progress of the ambulance dispute in your paper with interest. I believe your position, both in its orginal form and the one taking into account the letters printed in last week's paper, fundamentally flawed.
In my opinion, the way forward to secure a speedy and successful conclusion is to call for all-out strike action with no emergency cover, backed up wherever possible CHAUFFEUN OR by solidarity action from other workers.
As socialists we should be able to differentiate between correct 'theoretical' positions and the solutions required to respond to actual situations. Theoretically the way to win the ambulance dispute is for a general strike to take place. Regretfully, this is not an option at present. Faced with this, we should not fall into the trap of substituting what we would like to see for what is achievable at a given moment.
Whilst the call for 15 minutes of action by the TUC should be used to argue for half or one-day strikes, this is still a long way short of the required solidarity action needed to win. In view of this, we must look NCE to the ambulance the strike.
As with all strikes we should accept that when action is at its most effective, the bosses make concessions. Effective action does not mean a withdrawal of labour on the one hand, with a service provided on the other.
The situation in the West Midlands is a good example. A Labour authority providing a service instead of the NHS does nothing to pressurise Thatcher at all; neither does a strike which means the employees agreeing to carry on with their most important duties.
Effective action is based on workers withdrawing their labour in total, in this case it would mean that working class people would be hit. However, I believe that when this
----- pull-quotes -----
Revolutionary Russia, deprived bourgeois victory
of the West, stagnated in
"The 'crisis socialism' is a crisis of those calling
MR CLARKE İF YOU WERE SICK OR IN HIRED. WHOWOULD. You CALL? A Bus DRiVER, ATAxi B
US? DY TOKE