Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Eleanor Marx: a life of struggle

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan p. 16 · about 1,768 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

The top officials of the GMB today would be horrified to know it, but Karl Marx's daughter, a dedicated revolutionary like her father, played a major leading role in the early history of their movement. She was an active strike organiser and a member of the executive of the Gas Workers and General Labourers' Union, one of a number of unions which later fused to form the General and Municipal Workers Union, which became the GMB.

Fran Brodie, in a two part series, describes the life of Eleanor Marx and the early days of the Marxist organisation in the British labour movement Eleanor Marx was born into the workshop and armoury of scientific socialism on the 16 January 1855.

Her father Karl Marx was immersed in the economic research for his great work, Capital. Volume 1 of Capital, which eventually appeared in 1867, was to be decisive in transforming socialism from a moral ideal to a theory based on the most exact analysis of capitalist society and the contradictions driving towards its overthrow.

Meanwhile, the Marx family was plagued by illness and abject poverty. They had been forced into exile in Britain after Karl Marx's active participation in the German revolution of 1848, and Marx was keeping his family through journalistic work supplemented by help from his friend and comrade, Friedrich Engels.

Eleanor was the Marxs' sixth child. They had already lost two sons and a daughter and were left with three girls, Jenny, Laura and Eleanor.

Eleanor Marx, more notably then either of her sisters, was to grow into a dedicated fighter for socialism. She organised and led the unskilled workers of the East End of London, and was for decades the foremost fighter in the British labour movement for the cause of internationalism.

One of the first international issues which engaged her attention was Ireland. She was 12 years old at the time. Two Fenians, Thom as elly and Timothy Deasey, he 1 een arrested for their part in the March uprising of 1867 against British rule in Ireland. They were rescued from a prison van in Manchester, and in the incident a Kelly and Deasey escaped, shot. manhunt was begun which ended in the arrest of over 30 Irishmen.

Three of these men - William Allen, Michael O'Brien and Michael Larkin - were publicly hanged on 23 November. They became known as the Manchester Martyrs.

This atrocity awakened in Eleanor a passionate interest in the "Irish Question" , and from then on her political sympathies were strongly with the Fenians.

When she was 16 she went to France. It was the time of the heroic rising of the Paris Commune, the first proletarians to seize power.

During the rising, despite the weakness of conscious socialist organisation in Paris, the Communards carried out policies of a socialist nature: they abolished rents, confiscated the means of production, abolished the standing ar my and state bureaucracy, and had all social affairs managed directly by workers and their elected representatives.

The Commune lasted from 18 March to 28 May, when it was drowned in the blood of the workers of Paris.

The Communards, Marx wrote, *had been starved for six months into submission by internal treachery rather than by the external enemy. History has no like example of a like greatness. The first proletarians to seize power, they were storming heaven: the most glorious deed of our party."

This period of revolution was to have a great effect on Eleanor, both politically and personally. Refugees flooded into London from Paris to escape the slaughter there: Paris lost 120,000 of its workers at this time. But there was not much support for them. "The saddest of all is the fact that in England the workers, with a few exceptions, were as bitterly hostile to the Commune the ruling class, she recalled later. "While all the world was against the Commune, one great organisation stood by the revolution, holding aloft the red flag: the International Working Men's Association. The Communards bore hunger and misery and privation, disappointment and the agony of hope deferred without faltering or falling. All honour to their memory."

Among the refugees, Eleanor Marx met Prosper-Olivier Lissagaray. She was 'engaged' to him for nine years (despite her father's resolute disapproval) and translated his History of the Commune into English.] Eleanor's political work began in earnest in 1881.J During the 30 years to 1879, British capitalism had monopolised the world market. Britain was known as the workshop of the world; and the British working class movement settled down to seeking minor reforms, losing the revolutionary edge that had marked its struggles in the '30s and '40s.

In these decades, reformism entrenched itself, growing ont he crumbs tossed from the tables of the ruling class, at the expense of workers in other countries, and primarily in Britain's vast colonial empire.

But in 1879 there was a severe trade depression. with repercussions which reverberated throughout the working class. The next decade saw a growth in communist ideas.

Not many people at this time in Britain had thought about independent working class politics, and there was no socialist movement to kept alive in a few Working Men's Clubs. And German Social Democratic exiles were in touch with some of the old revolutionaries of the 1840s who had kept their socialist ideas.

But after 1879 the labour movement was on the upturn; the major organisation in the revival of socialism in Britain was the Democratic Federation.

The DF was founded by Henry Hyr dman in 1881. Within three years it evolved from being a Radical movement to adopting generally Marxist positions. In 1883 it adopted the name Social Democratic Federation, following the German Social Democratic Party.

Soon after it was founded, Eleanor Marx joined the DF. At that time the organisation was concerned mainly with the Irish question, campaigning vigorously in defence of the oppressed nation.

• i also at this time that path crossed with that of veling. She lived and ch him until her death in 1898.

Enge Eleanor's cather s deach in lide, was very her wary in his assessment of the SDF. He welcomed it, but was concerned that the people who turned towards Marxism were of bourgeois origin. They needed, Engels said, to turn themselves outwards, to implant themselves into the working class, if they were not to remain a sect.

To understand Engels' and Eleanor's perspective, we must look at the historical development of socialist ideas.

Since the French revolution of 1789-99 socialist sects had existed, especially in France. At their best they embodied a fiery revolutionary "Eleanor Marx, more notably than either of her sisters, was to grow into a dedicated fighter for socialism. She organised and led the unskilled workers of the East End of London, and was for decades the foremost fighter in the British labour movement for the cause of internationalism"

courage and hostility to capitalism. All of them, however, failed to see a link between the daily organisation and struggle of the working class within capitalism and the realisation of the future socialist society based on their ideals.

As industry and the working class expanded, these sects took on a more and more negative role. They were usually indifferent or even hostile to trade union struggle. Instead they confined themselves to endless discussions on the details of the future socialist society, or conspiratorial organisation for armed uprisings.

From 1850 onwards, the guiding idea of Marx's and Engels' was the liquidation of the era of sects and the building of a broad class movement. That perspective did not mean indifference to theory: on the contrary, Marx and Engels laboured for the utmost theoretical precision. But they wanted their theory to be "not a dogma but a guide to action". The theory would be assimilated by the workers as a result of their experience, not as a result of incessant lecturing by an 'enlightened' few.

In Germany, socialist organisation developed as the working class developed, from the 1860s onwards. The trade union movement in Germany was a direct product of the socialist movement. In Britain, the working class had developed from the end of the 18th century, long before scientific socialism. Its early, more or less confused rebellion was defeated.

By the 1880s a sizeable trade union movement had developed, but it was a bourgeois-minded, non-socialist movement, confined mostly to skilled workers. In the 1880s the unskilled workers began to unionise on a large scale. For Eleanor, the touchstone was always this mass movement of the working class. Groups like the SDF would be valuable educating influences, or mere sects, depending on how they related to that movement.

The SDF was, despite everything, the first avowedly Marxist organisation in Britian, and in its time it contributed to the education of thousands of socialists. Later, having changed its name to the British Socialist Party, and having disposed of its old leader Hyndman, it was the major component of the British Communist Party when it was formed.

He poisoned the internal life of the organisation with petty intrigues, leading Engels to describe him as "a pretty unscrupulous careerist" and to comment: "In every sect everything turns to scandal-mongering."

The SD's policy towards the working class was sectarian too. In its manifesto it declared that the trade union movement was a diversion from the class struggle. One of the many able workers who joined the SDF and quickly left it, Tom Mann, said that "the SDF tagonised the trade unionists without drawing any considerable percentage to socialism."

But the first big clash between Eleanor and Hyndman came over internationalism. In spite of his support for some colonial struggles, Hyndman had strong nationalist tendencies (he ended up as an all-out chauvinist during the First World War).

When Eleanor proposed sending an SDF delegation to the Roubaix Congress of the French Workers' Party, Hyndman spread malicious gossip and slander against her and dismissed the proposal as a 'family manoeuvre' . Eleanor's sister Laura, and her brother-in-law Paul Lafargue, were prominent members of the French Workers' Party.

In December 1884 it came to the point of a break. There was a 10 to 8 vote of no confidence in Hyndman on the executive of the SDF. But because Hyndman personally owned the SDF's paper, he was able to keep control of the organisation, and it was the executive majority who left the SDF with 500 of the SDF's 1500 members.

The breakaway organisation, the Socialist League, never expanded outside London.

Part 2 in next

----- pull-quotes -----

speak of, unlike in Germany and France. The ideas of socialism were

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →