Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

'Soviet troops

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · Edward Ellis · about 1,345 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

out of this bureaucracy or in any way other than in the course of struggle against it.

Most insupportable of all is the position on the war to which you have committed yourselves. The third world war which threatens humanity confronts the revolutionary movement with the most difficult problems, the most complex situations, the gravest decisions. Our position can be taken only after the most earnest and freest discussions. But in the face of all the events of recent years, you continue to advocate, and to pledge the entire movement, to the defense of the Stalinist state. You are even now supporting the armies of Stalinism in the war which is being endured by the anguished Korean people. I cannot and will not follow you in this.

As far back as 1927, Trotsky, in reply to a disloyal question put to him in the Political Bureau by Stalin, stated his views as follows: For the socialist fatherland, yes! For the Stalinist regime, no! That was in 1927; now, 23 years later Stalin has left nothing of the The Fourth International da the withdrawa! of all foreign armies, including the Red Army, from all occupied territorles. It opposes all annexations, reparations, forced transfers of populations and the detention of millions of German and Japanese workers as prisonate of war, either by the Malet or by the Soviet bureaucracy. The Fourth International c*- males no other frontiers than those drawn by the culture and freely expressed preferences of the populations concerned.

The masses of the countries at present must feel absolutely free, without any pressure, to determine their own fate. The occupation of these countries by the Red Army, the burdens imposed upon them, their treatment as defeated countries, can only harm the fundamental interests of the world socialist revolution. (Statement of the Fourth tional, June 1946)

Scan page 9

Zakes Mokae (left) and Donald Sutherland go on a journey of discovery white man Edward Ellis reviews 'A Dry White Season"

Dry White Season' is in many ways very similar to 'Cry Freedom'.

Indeed, the opening few minutes invite the comparison: starts where 'Cry Freedom' ends, with a dramatic reconstruction of the South African security forces gunning down protesting school students in Soweto, June 1976. Like "Cry Freedom', it is a story of a white South African having his eyes opened to the truth.

Two questions are raised by such a film: whether it is right to make films about South Africa from such an almost exclusively white perspective; and whether, even if it was right once, the exercise has now lost its point completely.

Almost by definition, both 'Cry Freedom' and 'A Dry White Season' are liberal pictures. They concern the battle for truth and decency, justice and integrity, from the point of view of white people. Blacks feature in both films, even prominently, but the central characters, the vantage point of the drama, are liberal-minded whites.

Donald Woods in 'Cry Freedom' is, at the beginning, self-consciously liberal, working for a liberal newspaper and condemning evenhandedly the racism of the apartheid state and the 'racism' of the burgeoning Black Consciousness movement, led by Steve Biko. Woods believes he knows how bad apartheid is. It is his friendship with Biko that transforms both his view of apartheid and his understanding of the struggles of black people against it.

In *A Dry White Season' former rugby star now working comfortably as a teacher (Donald Sutherland) is gradually confronted by the realities of South Africa as a result of the imprisonment of his gardener (Winston Ntshona), who had been trying to find out what had really happened to his young son, allegedly killed 'during the s the truth — for example the horribly beaten man who denies his forced testimony in court knowing he will probably be killed for it. But black people mainly suffer. They fight back, get killed, grow embittered. But this is very much a kind of elemental, unsophisticated revolt. The real psychological and moral drama is elsewhere, in Johannesburg's white areas. What happens to the blacks is second-hand Even so, both 'Cry Freedom' and this film manage to pack a formidable moral, political and emotional punch. There is no denying that 'A Dry White Season' is extremely moving and disturbing.

A major part of this film's plot is precisely to ridicule liberalism' albeit in a narrower sense. cynical, dry-humoured English lawyer (Marlon Brando) agrees to take on Sutherland's çase against the police simply to prove that it has no hope of success. In court, ne proves beyond any doubt that the gardener was murdered, and that the judge has no intention of finding the police guilty whatever the evidence may be.

"Justice and law are remote cousins," Brando's lawyer tells Sutherland. "And in they are simply not on speaking terms."

So the facade of fairness, due process, justice, runs up against the reality of racist political power. Real justice, the film suggests, only comes from stepping outside this framework of formal law, by defying the authorities: Sutherland in his quest for truth becomes, in effect, an outlaw, and he understands that by pitting himself against the unjust state he was put his own perhaps others' lives in danger. When Mokae's lawyer takes the law into his own hands in the film's closing sequence, exacting revenge upon the Special Branch thug responsible for so much death, we at least feel that there is some justice in what he is doing, even if it is a mistake.

There is some exploration of the "Afrikaner mind'. Sutherland's wife leaves him, and although we can feel no sympathy for her - she is a bigot — her reasoning has some internal coherence that does not depend solely on malevolence. She knows that the gardener was murdered by the police, and that horrible things are being done. But she believes you have to take sides: otherwise, the whites will lose everything.

And much more than for Donald Woods, here we have a sense that Sutherland has 'taken sides'. He is not merely broadening an already liberal-democratic idea of how South Africa should be run: he loses his family (except his son), his everytangs because he is a . As a result of his desire to ree instice done. he has to he prepared completely to reconstruct his life. A journalist friend asks him if he wants to go back to his wife, and he tells her not to be ridiculous.

Nevertheless, the dilemmas of Afrikanerdom, if that is a legitimate subject for drama, are not explored very extensively or with much subtlety. Essentially, 'A Dry White Season', despite stabs at something different, is just about a white man finding out the truth.

Ultimately this is not very satisfying, even if it can carry, as this film does, a great sense of moral outrage. Compare, for example, the film 'Mapantsula!', made secretly in Soweto. Here a black man, who ekes out a living as a petty thief and police informer, gradually comes to understand the necessity of struggle. Not only is the entire portrayal of South Africa vastly more intricate and complete, the dramatic imnact Ithink is far more nower ful.

It is also less pessimistic. Real transformations in society are made not by men of affluence making stands against injustice; they are only the ripples on the surface. Change comes because the downtrodden of the earth make a different sort of moral choice and choose no longer to endure oppression.

So 'A Dry White Season' only covers old ground, ground which it must be increasingly difficult to justify covering. Did we need another "Cry Freedom"? For sure, it is a well made film (directed, interestingly, by a black woman, Euzhan Palcy, from Martinique), and avoids 'Cry Freedom's' more irritating 'escape from apartheid' theme. There are some excellent performances, especially from Janet Suzman and Marlon Brando (who virtually steals the film). It is a story told with passion and anger. I would not deter anyone from seeing it; far from it.

But surely there are other South African stories to be told.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →