'Stalinism has nothing in common with socialism'
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The media are trying to throw socialism and Leninism into the grave of Stalinism and to bury them together with the discredited tyrannies of In fact Stalinism was the negation of socialism and Leninism. Stalinism came to power only bymaking a bloody counter-revolution against the Leon Trotsky was the voice and the symbol of those socialists and Leninists. The movement callec "Trotskyist" continued the struggle for his ideals and ideas after he was murdered by a Stalinist They opposed the Stalinisation of Eastern Europe, calling for the withdrawal of Soviet troops in 1946. -After 1948 many would-be Trotskyists fell victim to confusion, concluding that the Stalinist systems in Eastern Europe and China must be some sort of workers' state. This led the movement to grievous errors; persistently, repeatedly, the logic of the argument led to the industrial development of underdeveloped countries being substituted for workers' self-liberation as the goal of socialism.
As early as 1951 Trotsky's widow, Natalia Sedova, protested, in the letter printed below. The Trotskyists to whom she was protesting did, whatever their errors, maintain a commitment to workers' liberty against Stalinism; and the group with which Sedova associated herself in 1951 took an ultra-left and sectarian course on many issues Nearly 40 years later, however, with hindsight, is clear that Sedova was right in the basic page o Truman and his atomic bombs.
If Stalinism were merely totalitarian police state in the USSR and a terrorist apparatus in the labour movement of the capitalist countries, then the struggle against the terrorists by publicity, exposure and any other means at our disposal would be the main, if not the only, task. But the problem doesn't enc there; it only begins. The real fight against Stalinism, the main fight, takes place on the political field That is the way Trotsky explained the question and conducted his struggle. And that is why the Stalinists have always regarded Trotskyism as their most serious and consistent enemy. Trotsky's method must be the model for the revolutionary workers of the present day...
On the other hand, reports from Eastern Europe, where the first approaches of the victorious Red Army were greeted by revolutionary uprisings and mass acclaim, indicate that the workers have already been sadly disillusioned and the moral position of Stalinism has apparently been hopelessly shattered. The conditions are maturing there for the construction of genuine Socialist (or Communist) parties -anti-Stalinist as well as anticapitalist.
What, then, can be the real situation within the Soviet Union itself after all the bitter, bloody years? Can the masses still believe in Stalinism? Are there any illusions left? The known reaction of the should give us the answer. The very mases in the occupied territories fact that the terror, instead mitigating, grows worse from year to year, with the police apparatus swelling to ever more monstrous proportions - all this testifies not to the strength of the Stalinist regime within the country, but to its weakness, to its isolation and lack of mass support. The Stalinist regime in the USSR, isolated from the masses and ruling by terror alone, is weakest at the moment when it appears to be most secure The strongest assaults of the Nazi military machine proved unable to bring about the downfall of the regime in the USSR from within. And that is convincing evidence, we think, that the Russian masses don't want liberation from accursed and hated Stalinism in the shape of capitalist restoration and the colonial dismemberment of the country. But one strong revolutionary demonstration from the outside can bring the whole regime, with all its apparatus of repression and terror, crashing down in ruins.
The salvation of the Soviet Union, or rather what is left of it, from the curse of Stalinism, depends in the first place on strong revolutionary impulse from Europe or America, or some other part of the world. This impulse will come, we firmly believe, and this will change Greything. This task of liberation belongs to the workers. It cannot be farmed out to their class enemies, the Anglo-American perialist gang, in the hope thai somehow something good will come from the greatest evil. To assign the task of liberating the Soviet Union and the labour movement of the West from Stalinism to Truman and his atomic bombs is to renounce faith in the future of humanity, to pass a premature death sentence on civilisation.
mation that "the emancipation of the working class is the task of the working class itself. Only on that basis can we make an effective common front against Stalinism and free the labour movement from its malign power and influence. Only on that basis can we see the future clearly and prepare for it. socialists and Leninists in the USSR.
agent in 1940. not to do with the Stalinist states.
arguments of her letter.
You know quite well that I have not been in political agreement with you for the past fix or six years, since the end of the war and even earlier.
The position you have taken on the important events of recent times shows me that, instead of correcting your earlier errors, you are persisting in them and deepening them. On the road you have taken, you have reached a point where it is no longer possible for me to remain silent or to confine myself to private protests. I must now express my opinions publicly, The stop which I feel obliged to take has been a grave and difficult one for me, and I can only regret it sincerely. But there is no other way. After a great deal of reflections and hesitations over a problem which pained me deeply, I find that I must tell you that I see no other way than to say openly that our disagreements make it impossible for me to remain any longer in your ranks.
The reasons for this final action on my part are known to most of you. I repeat them here briefly only for those to whom they are not familiar, touching only on our fundamentally important differences and not on the differences over matters of daily policy which are related to them or which follow from them.
Obsessed by old and outlived formulas, you continue to regard the Stalinist state as a workers" state. I cannot and will not follow you in this.
Virtually every year after the beginning of the fight against the usurping Stalinist bureaucracy, LD Trotsky repeated that the regime was moving to the right, under conditions of a lagging world revolution and the seizure of all political positions in Russia by 1 the bureaucracy. Time and again, he pointed out how the consolidation of Stalinism in Russia led to the worsening of the economic, political and social positions of the working class, and the triumph of a tyrannical and privileged aristocracy. If this trend continues, he said, the revolution will be at an end and the restoration capitalism will be achieved.
That, unfortunately, is what has happened even if in new and unexpected forms. There is hardly a country in the world where the authentic ideas and bearers of socialism are so barbarously hounded. It should be clear to everyone that the revolution has been completely destroyed by Stalinism. Yet you continue to say that under this unspeakable regime, Russia is still a workers' state. I consider this a blow at socialism. Stalinism and the Stalinist state have nothing whatever in common with a workers' state or with socialism. They are the worst and the most dangerous enemies of socialism and the working class.
You now hold that the states of Eastern Europe over which Stalinism established its dominion during and after the war are likewise workers' states. This is equivalent to saying that Stalinism has carried out a revolutionary socialist role. I cannot and will not follow you in this.
After the war and even before it ended, there was a rising revolutionary movement of the masses in these Eastern countries. But it was not these masses that won power and it was not a workers' state that was established by their struggle. It was the Stalinist counter-revolution that won power, reducing these lands to vassals of the Kremlin by strangling the working masses, their revolutionary struggles and their revolutionary aspirations.
By considering that the Stalinist bureaucracy established workers' states in these countries, you assign to it a progressive and even revolutionary role. By protesting this monstrous falsehood to the workers' vanguard, you deny to the Fourth International all the basic reasons for existence as the world party of the socialist revolution. In the past, we always considered Stalinism to be a counterrevolutionary force in every sense of the term. You no longer do so. But I continue to do so.
In 1932 and 1933, the Stalinists, in order to justify their shameless capitulation to Hitlerism, declared that it would matter little if the fascists came to power because socialism would come after and Natalia Sedova with Trotsky in Norway, 1936 through the rule of fascism. Only dehumanised brutes without a shred of socialist thought or spirit could have argued this way. Now, notwithstanding the revolutionary aims which animate you, you maintain that the despotic Stalinist reaction which has triumphed in Europe is one of the roads through which socialism will eventually come. This view marks an irremediable break with the profoundest convictions always held by our movement and which I continue to share.
I find it impossible to follow you in the question of the Tito regime in Yugoslavia. All the sympathy and support of revolutionists and even of all democrats, should go to the Yugoslav people in their determined resistance to the efforts of Moscow to reduce them and their country to vassalage. Every advantage should be taken of the concessions which the Yugoslav regime now finds itself obliged to make to the people. But your entire press is now devoted to an inexcusable idealisation of the Titoist bureaucracy for which no ground exists in the traditions and principles of our movement.
This bureaucracy is only replica, in a new form, of the old Stalinist bureaucracy. It was trained in the ideas, the politics and morals of the GPU. Its regime differs from Stalin's in no fundamental regard. It is absurd to believe or to teach that the revolutionary leadership of the Yugoslay people will develop Socialist fatherland. It has been replaced by the enslavement and degradation of the people by the Stalinist autocracy. This is the state you propose to defend in the war, which you are already defending in. Korea.
I know very well how often you repeat that you are criticising Stalinism and fighting it. But the fact is that your criticism and your fight lose their value and can yield no results because they are determined by and subordinated to your position of defence of the Stalinist state. Whoever defends this regime of barbarous oppression, regardless of the motives, abandons the principles of socialism and internationalism.
In the message sent me from the recent convention of the SWP you write that Trotsky's ideas continue to be your guide. I must tell you that I read those words with great bitterness. As you observe from what I have written above, I do not see his ideas in your politics. I have confidence in these ideas. I remain convinced that the only way out of the present situation is the social revolution, the self-emancipation of the proletariat of the world.
----- pull-quotes -----
The socialists who said out!'