STALINISM 7 Our anti-Stalinism
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
political oppression. In conditions of Russian backwardness and the isolation of the revolution, the worst features of class society were grafted on to the collectivised property initially established by the workers' revolution. The totalitarian bureaucracy owned" the state, which owned the means of production, and ruled through a tight "Communist Party" monopoly of power.
Does the historical fate of the Russian workers' revolution endorse in retrospect the verdict of those scholastic Marxists like Karl Kautsky who condemned Lenin and the Bolsheviks as adventurists -people who took a leap in the dark?
It is best to let the splendid revolutionary Marxist Rosa Luxemburg answer that question. Luxemburg was an ardent supporter of the Russian Revolution, but also a sharp critic of the policy of the Bolsheviks. She differed with them on their land policy and on their national policy. She criticised the Red Terror and argued that the Bolshevik Revolution could and should have been won with less repression and more democracy than the Bolsheviks felt they could foster after the outbreak of civil war in mid-1918.
She wrote against the Kautskys:
*That the Bolsheviks have based their policy entirely upon the world "The Bolsheviks.!
were absolutely righ the international socialist revolution proletarian revolution is the clearest - of their political far+- and firmness of princit and of the bold scope of their nothing can be further emin's and Trotsky's] than to believe that all the • have done or left unanditions of bitter necessity in the baring whirlpool of events, should be regarded by the International as a shining example of socialist policy towards which only uncritical zealous imitation are in order, ne But:
*Whatever a party could offer of courage, revolutionary farsightedness and consistency in a historic hour, Lenin, Trotsky anc the other comrades have given in good measure. All the revolutionary honour and capacity which western social democracy lacked were represented by the Bolsheviks. Their October uprising was not only the actual salvation of the Russian Revolution, it was also the salvation of the honour of international socialism."
The Bolsheviks — socialists, proletarian revolutionaries, and consistent Marxists - were absolutely right to seize power, to base themselves on the perspective of the international socialist revolution. It was not their fault that the working class was everywhere defeated in the advanced countries of Europe and that the Russian Revolution was left isolated and subsequently degenerated.
If a group of old Bolsheviks, led by Stalin, finally betrayed the revolution, they could only feel secure in that work when they had slaughtered almost the entire membership of the revolutionary party that Lenin had built.
If the European labour movement had had more of Bolshevism in it, then the Russian Bolshevik-led revolution would not have led to Stalinism but to the inauguration of the liberation of the working class at least of Europe.
Their method, their programme, and their spirit is today still the only serious working class answer to capitalism, and now also to the Stalinist system.
Let the writer Maxim Gorky, a friend of Lenin though not always an uncritical one — he opposed the October insurrection, and very bitterly criticised the Red Terror -have the last word on Lenin's character and motives:
"I have never met...nor do I know of, any man who hated, loathed and despised so deeply and strongly as Lenin all unhappiness, grief and suffering...Lenin was exceptionally great, in my opinion, precisely because of this feeling in him of irreconcilable, unquenchable hostility towards the sufferings of humanity, his burning faith that suffering is not an essential and unavoidable part of life, but an abomination which people ought and are able to sweep away." and theirs The American Trotskyist, James P Cannon, wrote this analyzia of the diffarance batween socialiet and middle-class anti-St=li=is, in 1947, at time when broad antiStall-is. was swasping the USA, although alsowhare in the world Staliniar. still held mass support In understanding of the A perfidious character of Stalinism is the beginning of wisdom for every serious, class-conscious worker; and all anti-Stalinists who are also anticapitalist should try to work together.
But anti-Stalinism, by itself, is no programme for common struggle It is too broad a term, and it means different things to different people. There are more anti-Stalinists now than there were when we started our struggle...But very few of the current crop of vociferous antiStalinists have anything to do with us, or we with them. That is not because of exclusiveness or quarrelsom eness, either on their part or on ours, but because we start out from different premises, conduct the struggle by different methods and aim at different goals.
Many anti-Stalinists devote their arguments exclusively to the terrorist activities and totalitarian methods of the Stalinists. This is a rather common approach to Stalinism nowadays, but in our opinion it is an incorrect one. believe it puts the question in too narrow a frame and provides neither an explanation of the monstrous phenomenon of Stalinism nor an adequate programme by means of which the revolutionary workers can rid the labour movement of this plague.
Stalinism manifests itself in a totalitarian police state in the Soviet Union and a terrorist apparatus in the labour movement the capitalist countries. But it is not only that. Stalinism has its social base in the nationalised property of the Su. + Union - the product of the great revolution. It is not the continuator and legitimate heir of Bolshevism, but its antithesis. The Stalinists, a privileged bureaucracy which fastened itself on the Soviet state in a period of its degeneration and decline, had to liquidate in blood virtually the whole generation of the original Bolsheviks, before they could consolidate their But despite all the crimes and betrayals of the Stalinists, great masses of radical workers in Western Europe still identify them with the Soviet Union and, in turn, identify the latter with the revolution which gains attractiveness in their eyes the more that capitalism reveals its irremediable bankruptcy.
Herein is the main secret of the malevolent influence of Stalinism in the European labour movement.
Stalinism derives from the illusion greatest power in the minds the European workers that Stalinism means communism as represented by the great Russian Revolution. They want the same kind of revolution, and they will not be freed from Stalinism until they are freed from the illusion that Stalinism can help them to get it. Most anti-Stalinists, especially the professionals, identify Stalinism with communism. This only serves to embellish Stalinism in the eyes of the radical workers, to reinforce their illusions, and to strengthen the position of Stalinism in their midst...
The illusions of the masses as to the real nature of Stalinism are continually nourished and kept alive by the Stalinist propaganda machines with their perfected technique of demagogy and mass deception. Stalinism is, first of all, a political influence in the labour movement in the capitalist countries. And it exerts this influence, primarily, not as a police force or a terrorist gang, but as a political party. The fight against Stalinism is first of all, and above all, a political tight. political fight will never make any serious headway with the radicalised workers - and they are the ones who are decisive - unless it is clearly and unambiguously anticapitalist from beginning to end. No propaganda that bears, or even appears to bear, the slightest taint of Trumanism will get a hearing from the anti-capitalist workers of Europe. That kind of "antiStalinism" which is currently popular in the United States is absolutely no good for export.
We have no reason to minimise the terrorist apparatus of Stalinism, uncramcled in its magnitude and monstrousness in all history. It is a bloody and fearsome thing; we have paid enough in blood to know it. This terrorism must be exposed and fought. We must keep the pitiless light of publicity shining on it. But the exposure of the terrorist activities of the GPU is only one part, important to be sure, but not the most important part of the struggle against Stalinism.
Leaving out of consideration altogether the capitalist demagogues who exploit the fraudulent slogan "democracy versus totalitarianism" for their own imperialistic purposes, there are a Roosevelt Stalin and James P Cannon great number of people who sincerely hate Stalinism for its violence and terror, its bloody and awful tyranny, its utter disregard for human life and human dignity. But in their revulsion against this horror — which does them credit, no doubt - they fall into the same basic error as that of the Stalinists themselves. They overestimate the power of naked force. The Stalinists think that violence can accomplish anything, and this fallacy will eventually facilitate their downfall. Many of their opponents likewise imagine that violence and terror are omnipotent, able to repeal the historical laws explained by Marx.
It is wrong to make a fetish of violence and terror, to see only the GPU and not the tens of millions of Communist and Socialist workers 'in Europe. It is fatally wrong to lose faith in the ability of these workers to overcome their illusions and take their destiny into their own hands. And it is criminal to proceed from these errors - as so many antiStalinists are doing in this country - to the dreadful and monstrous conclusion: the destruction of hateful Stalinism must be entrusted Turn to page 8
----- pull-quotes -----
to seize power, to base themselves on the perspective of