Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Lenin's last struggle

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan p. 6 · about 1,461 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

"Whatever party could offer of courage, revolutionary far-sightedness and consistency in a historic hour, Lenin, Trotsky and the other comrades have given in good measure. All the revolutionary honour and capacity which western social democracy lacked were represented by the Bolsheviks. Their October uprising was not only the actual salvation of the Russian revolution, it was also the salvation the honour of international socialisn The idea that Leninism leads directly to Stalinism is one the most popular myths around John O'Mahon! and Andrew Hornung confront that myth. They t the story of the dying Lenin's last struggle against in défence of national rights in the infant Soviet 1922 Lenin suffered a stroke!

which paralysed him almost totally for a period. After a brief recovery, he suffered another stroke on 7 March 1923. He never recovered, though there were periods in which he was able to dictate notes.

In this period he fought his last battle, against growing bureaucratism and in defence of working class democracy.

On his deathbed he became increasingly aware that things were not going well, and was alarmed by the growing power of the bureaucracy. He had, he said, the uncanny sensation of turning a steering wheel which no longer had any control over the vehicle.

Initiative from below was being stifled. The Workers' Inspectorate, far from being a genuine organ of working class supervision, had become merely one more source of bureaucratic power for Stalin.

On the national question, "great Russian chauvinism" was restoring itself to power within the new social structures. Stalin and Dzherzhinsky had conducted a savage campaign against the Georgian Bolsheviks, accusing them of nationalism. Lenin knew where the malignant nationalism lay - in the great Russian chauvinism of the central state apparatus.

He resolved to conduct a struggle against the bureaucracy, in favour of the maligned Georgian Bolsheviks and the rights of the Georgian people within the Soviet system. But Lenin the activist was reduced to Lenin the dictator of notes, unable even to write them himself. These notes became his testament.

On 4 January 1923 he wrote: "Stalin is too rude and this defect...becomes intolerable in a general secretary. That is why I suggest that the comrades think over a way of removing Stalin from that post and appointing somebody else differing in all respects from Comrade Stalin by one single advantage - that of being more tolerant, more loyal, more polite and considerate to the comrades, less officious, etc.

"I think that from the point of view of assuring against a split and from the point of view of what I wrote above of the mutual relations between Stalin and Trotsky, it is not a detail, or it is a detail which can acquire decisive importance."| Stalin was not removed and in any case he was not himself the new bureaucracy, merely its personificationNo political issue so clearly epitomises the profoundly revolutionary and democratic spirit of Lenin and the Bolsheviks as their policy on the national question. True, they had (rightly) not hesitated to subordinate the national rights of the Poles in 1920 and of the Georgians in 1921 to the needs, as they saw them, of the workers' revolution.

But for most of the longoppressed nationalities and peoples of the Tsarist empire, the workers" revolution meant liberation, a tearing-down of that Bastille of the nations. The revolutionary effects of Bolshevik policy on oppressed nationalities and peoples was felt as far away as among the Blacks in the USA.

The fate of the national minorities under the Stalinist Rosa Luxembur 1924: Stalin eyes the dead Leni the grave of Leninism. bureaucratic counter-revolution graphically summed up what that counter-revolution meant, and will do to illustrate what happened in every area of society.

It was one of the most savage ironies of history. While the Austrian prison house of nations had been shattered into fragments. the Bolshevik policy of self-determination had preserved the unity of most of the former Tsarist empire - unity on the basis of freedom of the component nations and peoples.

Now the Stalinist bureaucratic degeneration began systematically to convert the free association of Soviet peoples created in the fires of revolution and civil war back into a prison house for the non-Great Russians. Stalin rebuilt the walls and institutions of national oppression. The systematic bureaucratisation of the party and the state apparatus, bureaucratically centralised and unified throughout the "Soviet Union', inevitably meant that the constitutional rights of the nations and peoples became a fiction.

The political and ideological degeneration of the bureaucracy injected the poison of Russian chauvinism into the state structure. By the mid-'20s, the Stalinist faction was already using anti-semitism within the Party against the Trotskyist opposition which continued the anti-bureaucratic offensive of Lenin.

By the early 1930s the Stalinists were able to turn on its head the central teaching on the national question of the revolution and of Lenin.

They now proclaimed that the main national problem in the USSR was no longer the poison of Great Russian chauvinism, but 'nationalist deviations' among the peoples long oppressed by that chauvinism.

For over 50 years now a majority of the people of the USSR have had national oppression superimposed on the social oppression experienced by all the population!

Whole nations have been deported. The Ukraine, a nation of 50 million, the biggest oppressed nation in the world, has been subdemocratic spirit of Lenin and the Bolsheviks as policy on the national question ject to systematic national and cultural oppression, sometimes more savage, sometimes less. The last large-scale purge there began in the 1970s.

There were few states on earth more alien to Lenin's programme on the national question than the one where the production of pictures and statues of Lenin - stylised to fit a vulgar Stalinist caricature - was a major industry.

On 21 January 1924 Lenin died. Within a short time all that he stood for had become a dead letter in the Communist movement.

Stalin and his friends used the occasion of Lenin's death to organise the so-called "Lenin levy', , a swamping of the revolutionary core of the party by a mass of raw, often careerist, recruits.

At the end of 1923 the Left Opposition, led by Trotsky, had taken up the same struggle as Lenin. Within a year of Lenin's death, the bureaucracy had differentiated itself from his programme by proclaiming a programme that he would have mocked at, that there could be socialism in one country. Thus they started on the road to abandoning the struggle for international proletarian revolution.

Over years and decades they wen to redefine the very basis o socialism, the self-liberation of th working class, to comply with the own authortarian police-state rule The notions of liberty an democracy, and much else that th socialist working class takes ove from the great liberatio movements of the past, were exci ed from their state socialism, an an authoritarianism previous associated with the Right inserted their place. Lenin's properly bitte denunciations of the reformist parliamentary fetishism were con strued as absolute renunciation democracy and endorsement bureaucratic tyranny.

Trotsky and the Left Oppesitio were very soon the only forces sti standing on Lenin's programm The bureaucracy gained control d the young parties of the Cominten many of them still in the process d formation. In time they wel transformed into corrupt, lifeles bureaucratic machines.

Within little more than ten yea of Lenin's death, almost the enti generation of Bolshevik revoll tionaries were murdered by t totalitarian state with Stalin at head.

Lenin, safely dead, was mu mified and made into an icon by ti Stalinist state. As if foreseeing Lenin had written, with Karl Ma and Frederick Engels in mind:

"During the lifetime of grea revolutionaries, the oppressin classes constantly hounded them received their theories with the ma savage malice, the most furio hatred and the most unscrupulo campaigns of lies and slanden After their death, attempts a made to convert them into harmles icons, to canonise them, so to say and to hallow their names to a cer tain extent for the 'consolation' the oppressed classes and with the object of duping the latter, while a the same time robbing the revolu tionary theory of its substand blunting its revolutionary edge an vulgarising it."

The impossibility even for Stai of destroying Lenin's publishe works - which for us remain real Lenin - now led to s scholastic reinterpretations them, quite alien to the spiri Lenin and the spirit of Marxism The Russian Revolution led way of the Stalinist -revolution to the savagely nical rule of a vast burte caste which subjected the 11 class of the USSR and E Europe to unparalleled ni

----- pull-quotes -----

Stalin's bureaucratism,

'No political issue so clearly epitomises the profoundly revolutionary and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →