Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tories go off the rails

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan p. 5 · about 905 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

from Prague The revolutionary situation continues in very contradictory ways. the last few days an army council has been formed of professional soldiers, with seven hundred delegates from all parts of the coun try, and a youth organisation has been formed in the army's many boarding schools and youth training centres.

At the same time there is growing distrust of the Coordination Centre and Civic Forum, the group which is in a government coalition with the Communist Party. It has been turning itself more and more into a political party, and even many of those dissidents who agree with the ideological positions of the Civic Forum have found this distasteful. -When challenged on television, leading members of Civic Forum said that if they weren't going to found an independent party, they would support the Christian Democrats anyway.

There are, however, areas where leftists are grouping themselves. The first of these is the "Association of Strike Committees to Renew the Trade Unions"

This initiative was started last December, with the aim of calling new trade union congresses and evicting the old Communist Party bureaucrats. However, it has run into predictable difficulties. Although individual Stalinists have are General strike 27th November 1989 been removed, the power of the bureaucracy remains.

The old unions' congress has now been put to the beginning of March, and there is clearly a much longer process ahead of winning democracy in the different trade unions. There is, however, unity among left-wing activists to stay within the official (formerly government-controlled) trade unions and to change them.

Of the 42 political parties that have now formed, six or seven claim to be on the left, although all but one are different variants of the Communist Party. There is one genuine anti-bureaucratic and antifree-market group called "Leva Alternativa" (Left Alternative).

This group, centred apparently round Petr Uhl and other people sympathetic to the neo-Trotskyist current led by Ernest Mandel, seems to be regrouping all those who oppose both the old Stalinist system and the free market policies increasingly promoted by Havel's "expert advisers"

It is still quite small, and is facing difficulties. Despite the generally tolerant political atmosphere, it is already noticeable that Civic Forum is unwilling to distribute the material of the Left Alternative. Posters for the Peasants' Party and the Christian Democrats predominate in Civic Forum offices.

Material from both the Association of Strike Committees and the Left Alternative will be available at the CSWEB conference on 27 January.

Colin Last week British Rail chief Robert Reid embarrassed the Tory government by criticising their drive to push the railways into free market economics.

For transport, as for housing, health care, education, food, indeed all the essentials of life, the free market is a very poor regulator of production and distribution. It is so poor that even the governments most committed ideologically to the free market feel a need to intervene.

No-one argues that the construction of roads should be regulated by the free market. If it were, then few roads would be built - because any one person owning a house or plot of land on the route could stubbornly refuse to sell or demand an impossible price.

Those roads that were built would be very expensive. Tolls would be high, and vast armies of staff would be needed to collect them. You would have to pay a toll to go to the corner shop.

So every free-marketeer demands state planning and intervention. Indeed, on the whole, the more people favour the free market in general, the more they want the state to order compulsory purchases of land to build roads. Look at the big cities of the USA!

However, in big modern cities, road-building can never keep pace with the number of cars. Traffic jams are inevitable. So are road accidents.

The "free market solution", I suppose, would be to have different roads with different tolls so that the rich could travel speedily on expensive roads while the poor crawl along on cheap roads. But it is rarely practicable.| And so even free market governments go further. They recognise the need for public transport, and for subsidising public transport. Britain's Tory government is trying to buck the rule by reducing subsidies on rail and public transport to zero. If they do this, then the free market will no doubt produce an equilibrium - at the point where the high fares, unreliability, seediness, overcrowding and general nience of public transport are just not quite so bad as to make most people walk, cycle or take a car into the traffic jams instead. To have better or cheaper public transport than that is "inefficient" by free market criteria.

In the meantime, of course, the roads will have become more crowded, more stressful. more dangerous and more polluting.

Even the rich suffer from this "free market solution". Their Rolls Royces may be comfortable, and their chauffeurs may take the stress of driving through busy traffic, but they are still delayed. Yet here as so often the free market produces a "solution" which no-one wants but no-one can change.

Almost everyone would prefer a cheap, reliable system public transport and less crowded roads; but no-one can get it by paying individually.

It takes more than the fumblings of a "hidden hand" to produce decent conditions for millions of people to live together in an environment they must all share.

----- pull-quotes -----

THE HIDDEN HAND

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →