Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Even mor essential for one party

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 1,621 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Loyalty to the party is absolutely essential."

What said that? Some Stalinist hack?

No, it was Mr Ray Formstone one of the local opponents of Anthony Meyer, the Tory MP who had challenged Margaret Thatcher for leader of the party and was deselected last week.

Party loyalty was essential, said this Tory freedom-lover, "i you are going to run a two-part system.' The South African Communist Party has recently reaffirmed its commitment to pluralism. Thi as you would expect, is the li coming very strongly out of Moscow these days.

Exactly what pluralism will mean for the South African Stalinists, who are not well-known for their glasnostic attitudes to other tendencies on the South African left, is not entirely clear.

At a meeting in Dakka a couple of years ago between the African National Congress (within which the Communist Party is dominant) and Afrikaner businessmen and intellectuals, the ANC were asked whether or not they favoured pluralism.

They had to leave the meeting and have a caucus, after which they announced that yes, certainly, they favoured pluralism.

Living standards have been steadily falling since 1988, according to Shadow Social Services secretary Michael Meacher, writing in the Guardian (22 January).

After rising through 1987 and the beginning of 1988 at an annual rate of 6.7%, workers' real take home pay has declined every month, and is now declining quickly because of inflation and mortgage rates.

Meacher goes on to argue that this could translate into very bad news for the government in the opinion polls. Historically, falling living standards take about six months to be reflected in the polls. According to most recent Observer/Harris polls, Labour is already 11 points ahead of the Tories. Jaruzelski A ha ahe Polish Communist Party has denounced a Bill put forward by Solidarnosc MPs as "Bolshevik in spirit and method"

The Bill aims to confiscate the property of the so-called Polish United Workers' Party, which is what the Communist Party calls itself. The Stalinists have expressed their outrage at the "brutal act of nationalisation" which meant "using state powe and authority for smothering the left."

The PUWP, like the Church in the past, is the largest private owner of property in Poland. O British Rail, Sir Robert utgoing chairman of Reid, said the other day that without massive investment in the rail infrastructure, Britain would be transformed into nothing more than an outpost of continental Europe.

Cecil Parkinson stated that Sir Robert's comments could not be taken as criticism of government "We were not supposed to say that Dracula was here. We were supposed to deny that he had ever been here.

A Romanian guide, on the old regime's official policy on whether the historical Dracula had lived in a castle in Bran.

"This is a poor country. We'll iust have to invite people over and cook for them.

Ambassador designate from Czechoslovakia to the USA, on plans for entertainment. London SE1 all-out!

n the ambulance workers article in SO 429, and the ambulance workers bulletin, there seems to be, at best, confusion over the question of all-out strike and emergency cover.

SO 429 baldly asserted: "We all know the ambulance workers will not, should not and cannot take all-out strike action. They have to provide an emergency service."

The ambulance workers bulletin distributed at the 13 January march and rally counterposes the correct and important need for solidarity action on the 30th to an all-out strike. Thus, "...the alternative [to solidarity action "to pile up the political pressure"] of going for an all-out strike has too many dangers.

Such a position logically means that the ambulance workers (and indeed other groups of workers) can only ever take forms of selective action which the Tories can and have sat out. Meanwhile, the strike has gone on for months and appears to be in stalemate.

The ambulance workers must take the initiative. The dispute must be escalated. Ambulance workers should go for an all-out national strike but, with emergency cover provided under their control.

Given management's obstruction to workers' attempts to provide emergency cover so far, ambulance workers will need to occupy their stations and lock management out. So much the better!

This would give the initiative in the strike to the rank and file ambulance workers and that is by far the greatest pressure that can be put on the Tories.

SO was wrong. Ambulance workers can, should and (hopefully) will take all-out strike action - with emergency cover.

• Occupy the ambulance stations!

• National all-out action - with emergency cover under workers"

Break the stalematel a recent issues of SO, articles on the ambulance dispute have falsely counterposed strike action by other trade unionists to strike action by ambulance workers.

I agree it is vital that we mobilise other trade unionists to take action alongside the ambulance workers but i disagree with the analysis in last week's paper that "the alternative of going for an all-out strike has too many dangers"

I am yet to hear of many ambulance workers taking a lightminded attitude to the question of Ambula Ward set in a themsel not loo near fu We sho out acti we she Poole!

Rance workers demonstrate on 13 Janı Amongst ambulance workers ves, who after 19 weeks are king to seal a victory in the ture, not in two years' time! uld not oppose calls for alloldy ambulance workers -"leave that to Roger Steve Battlemuch Nottingham Reply: cover is vital The letters from Steve Battlemuch and the DSS worker both raise important Issues in relation to the current ambulance dispute.

In substance, the conclusions drawn "DSS worker' are correct: that Socialist Organiser should advocate an indefinite strike with emergency cover, and occupation of the stations to ensure that cover is provided under trade union However, some of the arguments used in both letters don't really stand up to investigation.

Steve, for instance, claims that: calls for all-out action have always been linked to a willingness to operate emergency cover - even if that is conducted from picket lines.

This is quite simply not true. In Manchester in the middle of December, the local stewards did make a call for a one-day strike - without cover. At at least one station in the South East, ambulance workers have walked out completely without adopting the approach of the Crawley strikers who say they will help anyone who comes down to the picket line and asks.

It would be wrong to pretend, as Steve does, that such a situation as exists at Crawley represents the kind of emergency cover we would want to impose under workers' control, which would surely involve some kind of telephone contact with the crews.

"DSS worker' takes his argument too far. He quotes from SO 429 giving the impression that the article in question is arguing against strike action as such -with or without emergency cover - but the context makes it clear that the target of the argument is complete walk outs. Here's the passage in full, written when the idea of an all-out strike without emergency cover was first floated by a member of the national NUPE strike committee.

"This week's meeting of ambulance under trade union control?

1. We recognise that the calls are a product of the fact that large numbers of rank and file ambulance workers are becoming aware of the impasse the dispute is in. They are tired of the lack of result from the strategy pursued so far, and are sceptical about the possibilities of solidarity action to help them win. Walking off the job seems the only option left.

2. Positively, we are for the maximum possible escalation the dispute amongst ambulance workers. An indefinite national strike with emergency cover under trade union control would be the best way of unifying the ambulance workers and escalating the action. It would break down the divisions between those on strike, those locked out or suspended in some form and those still on full pay. A national strike ultimatum would also increase the pressure on management to concede some elements of trade union control over emergency cover.

It is vital to separate out this option from that of no cover. We advocate occupations to prevent lock-outs, and appeals to the army and police to stop scabbing (not just by walking off the job, but arranging a transfer of emergency duties under workers' control). We are for rank and file control of the dispute and solidarity action as the key to victory.

3. Why not no cover? Tactically, it could backfire in the propaganda war, but not necessarily. Steve is right about this. However, major walk-outs would almost inevitably split the ambulance workers' ranks, as many people who are by no means strike-breakers would work to maintain some sort of emergency service.

Positively, emergency cover potentially extends workers' control in ways that a walk-out cannot. There is nothing about an all-out strike as such which makes it a higher form of working class struggle than maintaining emergency cover.

Strikes in the NHS are generally weaker, than those in say engineering, because they don't hit profits. The way to deal with this problem is not to pretend that it doesn't exist, but to look for other - very often more openly political - forms of economic leverage such as solidarity strike action to put political pressures on management. There is no point making a fetish of a particular form of action which has limited effectiveness and leverage The only other grounds for opting for walk-outs are "The law is so powerful that solidarity action is impossible, and all we can do is escalate the ambulance

----- pull-quotes -----

Idbook for plus 32p po SO, PO Box

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →