Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[From page 1 to flex their muscles. The…]

Socialist Organiser no. 431, 25 January 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 1,516 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

From page 1 to flex their muscles. The mass has deepened the Kremlin's cris authority, not contributed resolving it.

But the Kremlin's Army, des the senseless massacre in Bakı the force standing between the embittered Soviet Republics Armenia and Azerbaijan, pre ting war and even bigger massac The Azeris, with aggres: chauvinism, claim sovereignty mainly Armenian-inhabited ritory in Nagorno-Karabakh. I it not follow that socialists wanting a bloody communal should back the Kremlin and it my, albeit critically? No, it i not. It cannot.

The Great Russian empire ca the USSR is untenable. For m decades the Stalinists have ru regime of Great Russian nation: oppression of the many minc nations who make up about half Any lesser democracy, any ignite and revive inevitably demands of the long oppressed tionalities. deliberately to embitter and int If the Stalinists had relations between the different tionalities in the USSR, then t would have behaved not much ferently from the way they h behaved for over half a cent More Kremlin repression — e when it justifies repression peacekeeping - cannot be a si tion.

In conditions of compara openness, it can only spur and I voke the minority nationalities. only solution for the national ci in the Soviet Union is the realisal of the democratic programme the Bolshevik Party:

• Recognition of the right of s determination for all peoples : fragments of peoples.

• Recognition of the right secession from the Soviet Union Within those principles. Bolsheviks argued that Great R sian socialists should fight agai all types of Great Russian tionalism, and socialists in smaller nationalities should opp their chauvinism too, advocat working-class unity and fede links between the peoples. Thus, example. in 1919 and 1920 Bolsheviks fought for the dependence of the Ukraine, ally with honest Ukrainian nationali and then fought successfully for voluntary federation of the Ukra with the Russian Soviet Republi No-one in their senses want to see the USSR explode a dissolve into the maelstrom of tional and communal confli which now threatens it. In cert areas, moreover, it is impossible all the nationalities involved to ercise the sovereign right of se acre is of to spite 1, is two of vencres. sive Dver terDoes not war, s arJoes illed lany alist vity I the ning t of the naout ame nathey diflave ury. ven as oluThe risis tien the tusinst nathe ose ing eral for the sts, the Line uld ind naicts things that East European and Russian socialists long ago advocated not only self-determination but also such ideas as a Balkan Federation, a Transcaucasian Federation, local autonomy for smaller communities embedded in an alien population, equal rights for all languages and all individuals. Those are the principles on which the looming catastrophe of national conflict which threatens to engulf the peoples of the USSR can be averted.

The Kremlin does not promote such principles. The massacre in Baku — calculated, Stalinist reflex, or panic action, whatever it was — shows how far the Kremlin is from such principles. Only a socialist working-class movement could adequately fight for the old Bolshevik programme so monstrously perverted and trampled on by Stalinism.

To back the Kremlin as the "lesser evil" in Azerbaijan and Armenia would imply backing it indefinitely - that is, maintaining the status quo. The parallel with British troops in Ireland is apt and instructive.

British troops out without a political settlement would mean civil war and bloody repartition. But socialists cannot give support to the British Army for that reason. We advocate a programme of working-class unity across the communal divide, and CatholicProtestant conciliation on the basis of mutual recognition of rights. - Still less can socialists give support to, or advocate trust for, the Kremlin. Not for 200 years, since 1798, has the British state done any single act against the people of Ireland comparable to the Baku massacre. No, no confidence in the Kremlin!

Some commentators speculate that the new deepening of the crisis brought about by the massacre will force Gorbachev to respond to his critics by embracing a tull programme for the immediate reorganisation of the Soviet Union on a genuinely federal basis. We The sudden dropping of fraud charges against Kevin Taylor, sixteen weeks into his trial, is the latest solid evidence for John Stalker's claim that there has been a conspiracy against him.

It was Stalker's connections with Taylor, alleged to be a shady businessman, that were used to justify attempts to discredit Stalker, who was suspended from the Manchester police force in 1986.

Stalker had been leading an investigation into the Royal Ulster Constabulary's 'shoot to kill' policy in Northern Ireland. In 1982, the RUC shot dead six IRA suspects, five of them unarmed. Stalker was concerned to see the rule of law' upheld, and was set to produce a don't know and can't know. Right now the Kremlin has just acted with typical Stalinist brutality, killing innocent Azeris, inflaming and embittering Azeri nationalism, and maybe preparing the way for a new clampdown before the demonstrating women who opposed the drafting of their reservist sons and husbands for an "Afghan" war in the south made Gorbachev reconsider.

Now as before: no confidence in the Kremlin!

It was to take account of such report that would be sharply critical of the RUC He had discovered the existence of MIS recordings of two men being shot dead by RUC men, and was recommending the suspension of eleven RUC officers.

Then came the allegations that Stalker was personally connected with criminal elements, via his friend Kevin Taylor, against whom fraud proceedings were begun. In light of this 'connection' ', Stalker was suspended from duty. The RUC was subsequently whitewashed.

Many MPs, and of course Stalker and Taylor themselves, telt that this was the result of a 'dirty tricks' campaign aginst them by the "security services' . That the charges against Taylor should now be dropped after a cost to him of two million pounds - leaving him Towards the end of last year I began to feel that this column had run its course.

Perhaps Press Gang should be allowed to slip peacefully into oblivion, mourned only by an editorial team in London who have spent years trying to convince me that my weekly (well, almost) pontifications on the Fourth Estate were what gave their sad lives real meaning.

This was not merely the result of boredom, indifference, or the dreaded "block" that afflicts most scribblers from time to time. No, it went deeper.

There were worrying signs that the very lifeblood of this column -the lying, bigoted, prurient loathsomeness of most of the British press — was drying up. The Sun had appointed an ombudsman to look into complaints, and he immediately pre-empted my scorn by finding in favour of the first couple of complainants.

The saintly Andreas Whittam Smith persuaded all but one of his fellow editors to sign a 'national newspaper code of practice' that promised a new age of responsible, accurate, and squeaky-clean journalism. (The exception, by the way: was Sir Geoffrey Owen of the Financial Times, but then the pink "un is not noted for either sleaze or downright lying).

Perhaps the most significant of all those straws in the wind was the sacking of Ms Wendy Henry from editorship of The People. I even felt a twinge of sympathy for Ms Henry, who, having built her reputation on making up interviews with war widows and publishing photos of people with extreme physical deformities, was given the push by Cap'n Bob for publishing a harmless pic of a junior Royal having a slash. —The cause of all this high-minded zeal was not difficult to fathom. 1989 saw two private members Bills aimed at curbing the excesses of the tabloids. Both Bills failed, but attraced enough support inside and outside Parliament to put the wind up the press. A stern Home Secretary warned the newspaper industry that it was "on probation" and set up a committee to look into things.

Meanwhile, sales of the tabloids were falling, with the Sun and the News of the World suffering the biggest drops (though it has been mischievously suggested that this might be precisely because they began to tone down the material).

So it was that the British Press entered the new decade on its best behaviour. Lurid revelations of bizarre and/or illicit sexual goingsstuff ave ut the likes of Jason and about the likes of Jason and Kylie; blatant racism was OUT as Frank Bruno became the tabloids' favourite affable buffoon and events in Eastern Europe cast at least some Foreigners in the unaccustomed role of Heroes; even good old fashioned union-bashing eased off as the Sun and the Star threw their support behind the ambulance workers.

It couldn't last, of course. The exciting adventures of Ron Brown MP enticed most of the tabloids back to their old ways, and the Gay Scottish Judges Scandal has predictably resulted in a more or less full return to form. couldn"t have taken much more of that Jason and Kylie stuff.

----- pull-quotes -----

PRESS GANIG

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 431

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →