[According to Lord A Denning, judges should not…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
According to Lord A Denning, judges should not be homosexual. Or is it that homosexuals should not be judges? This is because, he says, a gay judge might get a crush on a barrister.
And then what? He'd come over all dizzy and hot, having to wear that wig and everything, and have simply no idea what decision he ought to make.
It is, of course, hard to credit that a man who presumably is possessed of at least average intelligence, being a top judge, can make a statement that is so transparently, unqualifiably idiotic. Or is Lord Denning admitting that he thinks that neither judges nor barristers should be women either? Or is a male judge less likely to have a crush on a woman barrister, or vice versa? Is there something exclusively NORTH AND By Patrick Murphy The founding father of T Ulster Unionism, Edward Carson, once declared that the only real threat to the Union would come from the disunity of the Unionists.
The Thatcher government's fits of any kind for children whose parents are not wealthy is abysmal.
"Cuts" has been Thatcher's watchword, and the value of child benefits has fallen dramatically in recent years. Thatcher intends benefits to diminish even further.
Any government committed to child welfare would have raised child beneit, and income support. It would have allowed recipients of income support to supplement that income by way of employment without loss of benefit.
A government committed to the welfare of children would have ensured that educational changes were adequately funded, that the health service was adequately funded -and that there was plenty of cheap, decent housing available with access to parks, shops, transport and nurseries.
If the standard for judging this government is commitment to child welfare, then Thatcher stands condemned. The Tories fail every single test.
Yet Thatcher still talks about the rights of the child! And in so doing she, is being perfectly consistent, and not only consistently hyp critical.
When the Tories talk about foreing fathers to accept their respondebilitating about mosexual crushes, maybe?
Lord Denning's other argument was the more traditional one, that homosexual judges are open to blackmail.
In the early 1960s, a film was made, starring Dirk Bogarde, called 'Victim' , which was precisely about a successful barrister who was blackmailed following a brief and apparently unconsumated homosexual affair. It was an excellent propaganda movie, aiming to expose the pre-1967 law on sexual offences as a "blackmailers' charter'. One of the arguments behind the passing of the 1967 Act was that it would remove the threat of blackmail against high-ranking people who were homosexual by making it legal to be so.
Twenty three years on, and the legal establishment doesn't seem to have noticed.
It is of course true that a homosexual judge can be blackmailed - if his sexuality is a secret, and if the establishment conpolitic Ever since, this fearful prophecy has been the spur to keep Unionists formidably unified, and nationalists and their sympathisers consistently frustrated. Protestant solidarity has been maintained since 1921 largely because of its dogmatic portrayal of the Irish Republic as an alien and hostile state.
These articles of Unionist faith have appeared more vulnerable in recent months than at any time since Brian Faulkner agreed to power-sharing in 1973. Ulster sibilities' to their children and promise new legislation to harass nonmaintenance payers their purpose is not to see that children get a better deal but to save the state money! Thatcher is perfectly consistent -consistently piggish.
Thatcher spouts the ideology about paternal responsibility, but the Minister of State, Tony Newton, has unashamedly told the truth. According to Newton, the main purpose of the planned legislation is to save money in income support to single mothers!
In the hands of a government we could trust to do the best for the nation's children, Thatcher's proposals would perhaps make sense and maybe deserve support. But this government's overriding drive and purpose with this legislation is to stop paying income support!
This proposal will not help poor single parents - it will make their lives more fraught, more difficult, more insecure and, most likely.
much poorer.
Any change which takes away the basic income now available from the state, as a matter of right, and replaces it with reliance on payments from a reluctant and unreliable biological father is not likely to make life easier or more prosperous for either mother or child.
Thatcher's attitude is essentially one of apportioning blame. Analyse what she says. She blames poor people for having children at all!
She blames young women for getting pregnant; she blames the father for leaving; she blames the mother for letting him go; and she blames her again for not being able to care sider it in some way discreditable. It is Lord Denning, and those who believe as he does, who put his colleagues in danger of blackmail. If nobody gave tuppence whether judges were gay or not, and if therefore all gay judges could be open and relaxed about it, no one would be able to blackmail them.
So the scandal about Lord Dervaird, who resigned last week, is not that he is gay, but that he has had to resign for this reason and that he had to lie about himsel beforehand.
And Lord Dervaird is by no means the first. A couple of years ago, revelations about a 'spanking judge' led not only to his resignation, but to the psychological torture of his lover, who was hounded by the press and came close to committing suicide as a result.
The Dervaird affair tells you a lot about the narrow-minded, and indeed childish mentality of the judicial profession. It is terrifying to think that these people are trusted with making important deciUnionists are rethinking their entire strategy, and edging towards the idea of doing a deal with the hated Irish Republic, led, what's more, by the old Fenian Charles Haughey. Anyone who doubts the seriousness of the shift in Irish politics today should consider this sequence of events. In November, Haughey invited Unionists to talks on Northern Ireland. Such an invitation would normally be considered an insult or affront.
Paisley treated it just so, but the Official Unionist MP John Taylor for her children financi ally. Mrs Thatcher's government has done more in the last decade te ) generate poverty than any other sin gle cause: but Mrs Thatcher blames 1 people for being poor! It is the diseas ie carrying germ denouncing those who fall Thatcher justly pointed 1 out that children lose out when th leir father leaves. She thinks "fami. ly life" is good for children. I think she's probably right. Although he т conception of family life is prot pably very different from mine; and I different too from the reality of far nily life as most people experience it But she is wrong simpl y to blame the "permissive society" or the individuals concerned. Sh le cannot Is he or isn't he? Why should we sions, formulating as well as interpreting law. Someone who can stand up in public and suggest that gay judges might have cloudy welcomed it and suggested that talks with the Republic could be useful.
Ian Paisley then attacked Taylor for treachery and at the DUP conference announced that a four-year pact between his party and the Official Unionists was over. There would be open conflict in every seat at the next election.
The two main Unionist parties have had a pact to demonstrate their joint opposition to the Anglo-Irish Agreement since 1985.
Shortly after Paisley's outburst, however, his deputy leader, Peter Robinson, revived the idea of talks between Northern Irish parties to find a settlement. The usual condition was imposed: that the Agreement be suspended. A new element was introduced, however: that the talks be set a time limit after which, if no agreement had been reached, the Anglo-Irish Accord would be reimposed.
At the end of November, the inter-governmental conference up by the Accord met, and decided that there would be no further meeting for two months. It was heavily suggested that this time should be viewed constructively by the 'constitutional' parties.
In early December, Peter Robinson declared that two months should be well enough to test the possibility of agreements between Northern Irish parties.
All these shifts provide the background to last week's mating ritual between prominent Unionists and Irish prime minister Haughey. This time, Unionist party leaders offered talks with Dublin if replacement of the Anglo-Irish deal could judger barris truster park.
Its because there's a hunky around shouldn't be rith looking after a car demonstration in which 300,000 people would form a human chain around Northern Ireland.
In the event there were a few hundred. The demonstration was a remarkable flop compared to the huge anti-Accord demonstrations of 1985-6, and indeed by any stan dards.
The next day the Ulster Conservative Party came second to the DUP in a council by-election at Castlereagh. The Tories outpolled both other Unionist parties combined. They are threatening to stand in every seat, despite appeals from some British Tories to protect certain Unionist seats.
They will seriously worry the Official Unionists, and possibly destroy the Alliance Party.
The Protestant community, above all its middle class, are tired of being without power or influence. They were used to having both as of right, and expected to be excluded only temporarily. Now they are turning to politics which offer a return to influence, even if shared, and an end to posturing.
It is not clear where the Protestant working class will stand in all this. They could become the raw material of a Paisleyite reaction, or they could strike out on their own again.
Certainly the one thing they have to gain from any constitutional settlement is the opportunity to forge links with the Catholic working class against their rulers, both nationalist and Unionist, British and Irish. The
----- pull-quotes -----
WOMENTS By Liz Millward