Come back Fred Kite!
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
By Sleeper I veryone agrees that the union Eras two the bailie relatons has won the public relations battle hands down.
The five unions involved spent a lot of time and effort preparing their media campaign, pooling all their specialist press officers and putting NUPE's Lyn Bryan (who once worked for the Engineering Employers' Federation press department) in overall charge of PR. It was agreed at the outset that there would be a single "public face" for the union side and a single, simple message. The face is, of course, that of Roger Poole and the message is "arbitration".
Mr Poole is almost an identikit modern union bureaucrat: well groomed, young (well, relatively young) and, above all, reseestle. Under Ms Bryan's tutelage he has mastered the art of speaking in easily-digestible "soundbites" , ready made for the TV news. He avoids Fred Kite-style trade union gobbledegook like the plague. He has run By a London busworker Eve are now involved in what could be the most important election campaign in the history of the Transport and General Workers Union.
The hard right-wing are on the offensive. Determined to win control of the union executive, they are waging a militant campaign against the Broad Left majority. Not surprisingly, the rightwing are being helped along by the gutter press. This week the Star printed the "moderate' slate in full.
Nobody should underestimate the significance of a right-wing victory in the ballot. It could mean a return to the days of Bevin and Deakin whe the union was run as a monolithic right-wing A victory for the right-wing in the union will further strengthen Kinnock and his allies in the Labour Party. For instance, the TGWU under its present leadership could be an important tocus for opposition to Kinnock's attempts to keep the Tory shackles on the unions.
While campaigning for the Broad Left slate, activists should not feel obliged to defend their record on the executive or their ways of organising.
Unlike the right, who are campaigning boldly, the Broad Left remains a secretive organisation. For instance, it has proved impossible to obtain a full national Broad Left slate despite requests to prominent BL activists.
In London, the Broad Left control the London Bus Committee and were able to transform a 6:1 vote for strike action into a 3:1 vote for acceptance of an only slightly modified pay deal. This feat was achieved in the middle of the tube and rail strikes which paralyred the capital!
On the National Executive, Broad Left supporters have even voted to massively hike up union dues rather than dispose of some of the union's less necessary assets such as a rather plush hotel in Eastbourne. In fact, the Broad Left majority, despite the advice of Ron Todd, even voted to spend extra money on refurbishing it!
Nevertheless, despite these failings it is vital to mobilise the biggest possible vote for the Broad Left and to stop the right in their tracks.
Important note All voting papers must get t the scrutineer by 9 February If you have not received a voting paper by 27 January then phone 100 and ask for Freefone TGWU. rings around the bumbling Duncan Nichol and the fatuously complacent Kenneth Clarke (who, one remembers with incredulity, was originally appointed largely on the strength of his alleged "communication skills"!)
The Nichol/Clarke act got the bird from the Great British Public carly on in the dispute and has wisely decided to steer well clear of TV cameras for the duration.
Sections of the left tend to be a bit sniffy about any sort of concern for Sustrike; as though a "proper" ind presentation, public opinion and dustrial dispute ought to be unpopular. In reality, the knowledge that your union officials are doing a good job of Pinic opinion is behind you, is thad for morale and can only strengthen the resolve of the rank and file. I, for one, have no criticism of Roger Poole's suits, haircut or his ability to come over as the Voice of Reason.
The problem is that the union side seems to be intoxicated by its media success and patently has no strategy for actually winning the dispute. Roger Poole has gone so far as to announce to rallies of ambulance workers that they have, in fact, already won the dispute. By which, presumably, he means that they have won the battle for hearts and minds - a moral victory. But moral victories don't put the ackers in the pay packets or red meat on the table.
One word that Mr Poole (no doubt on the advice of Ms Bryan) has studiously avoided using throughout the dispute is "solidarity". Instead, we hear talk of something called "People Power", novel concept in industrial relations, which is perhaps intended to conjure up some sort of identification between the ambulance dispute and recent events in Eastern Europe. If so, someone should remind Mr Poole that "People Power" in Poland, East German, Czechoslovakia, Romania, etc. took a rather more dramatic form than petitions and fifteen minutes of management-approved thoughtfulness.
It might also be pointed out that the unprecedented level of public support for the ambulance workers is not simply the result of Mr Poole's undoubted presentation skills: public attitudes towards trade unionism in general and industrial action in particular has been changing. Last summer's outbreak of strikes in local government, the London Underground and British Railways enjoyed considerable, though passive, popularity. When the workers in dispute are known to be poorly-paid and have a reservoir of public good-will to call upon; when the government itself is generally unpopular and particularly so on questions concerning the health service, it is hardly surprising that the ambulance workers are popular.
Poole's mistake is not that he has deliberately nurtured public opinion, but that he has not built upon it sufficiently. The day of action called by Hackney Council Joint Shop Stewards and North London ambulance workers on 6 December, won an impressive level of support in workplaces across London despite having no official backing from NUPE or any of the other unions involved.
There is little doubt that a clear call for solidarity action from the five unions and/or the TUC, would command massive support. In the absence of such a call, Poole's "People Power" approach is leading the dispute into an impasse. The result could very well be some ambulance workers becoming demoralised and throwing in the towel, while others (as has already happened in Crawley and nearly happened in Manchester) become desperate and withdraw emergency cover. Meanwhile, Kenneth Clarke (who seems to have a better grasp of the limits of "People's Power" than Roger Poole, even if he's not as good on telly) will sit tight, and wait for the dispute to crumble.
That needn't happen, but it will take more than slick presentation and passive public support to win this one. It will take something very old fashioned, called solidarity. Fred Kite would understand that, even if Ms Bryan and Mr Poole don't.
----- pull-quotes -----
TWGI TWGU: Vote Bro: