[Bond's empire will lose out; but they were…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Bond's empire will lose out; but they were unlucky rather than slothful or inefficient. Banks who lent Bond money will take losses; but no top banker will suffer personally. The losses will be spread out among bank customers in fractionally higher charges and interest rates.
Most of all, workers in the companies Bond owned will be punished, as those companies are carved up and asset-stripped in order to repay at least part of Bond's debts. But the collapse has not come before workers in Bond's breweries are lazy or incompetent, or even because those breweries are ill managed or Australians' thirst for booze has slackened. Not at all: the workers are being punished by the free market because Bond gambled too riskily in the debt-financed takeover circus.
Another example of "market discipline" is the fiasco of America's savings and loans companies ("thrifts"), summarised in a recent article in the New York Review of Books by JK Galbraith.
The "thrifts" were a sort of American equivalent of building societies. They were mostly small businesses, taking in small savings and making small loans for mortgages.
In the 1980s the free-market Reagan adminstration deregulated them, allowing them to move into hectic property speculation. Since the "thrifts" still took money from small savers, the US government continued to underwrite them.
While the going was good, the bosses of the "thrifts" siphoned off millions and billions of dollars into their pockets. *There were huge salaries and bonuses...loans to shadow figures identical in interest with those authorising the loans... Much money went for entertainment and lavish personal expenditure, including obviously obscene and extravagant local celebrations, parties in Las Vegas...company jets, Rolls Royce cars, and appalling personal dwellings."
Then the protect We bosses escaped scot free. They remain prosperous and powerful people. The federal government bailed out the small savers. The taxpayer foots the bill - an almost unbelievable bill, "upward of $200 billion, or several thousand dollars for every taxpaying American family"
The "hidden hand" of the market does not work impartially. It is a fist beating down the poor and the working class, and an open hand for the rich and powerful. Sheffield and Chesterfield NUR District Council)
Thought crime is now a sackable offence at East Midlands Motor Services!
Dave Edinboro, a workshop representative at Chesterfield Bus Garage and an NUR member, was accused of stealing some antifreeze. Of course he hadn't, and of course there was no evidence. But management decided that he had intended to, and he was sacked.
The real reason is that Dave Edinboro is a union activist and the union had successfully resisted a second batch of redundancies after Stagecoach Holdings took over the company less than a year ago.
The first batch of redundancies had been done through voluntary redundancy and natural wastage, but Stagecoach Holdings wanted more, by whatever means. A ballot of the 750 members in the various East Midlands depots produced a majority for an overtime ban to resist further cuts. The ban never happened - the company backed off. But they obviously backed off only to gain time to work out a new strategy.
thout warni Dave Edino was accused. The accusat fell apart but management went ahead and pronounced the sentence anyway. He was sacked. That had been decided long before the accusation was made!
Dave was sacked in November 1989. His first appeal upheld the sacking. He was refused permission to make a second appeal to a higher level of management - the agree procedure.
Reluctantly, and after much pressure, NUR full-time officer for buses, Brian Arundel, agreed to allow a ballot for action. The result announced on 6 December failed to get a majority for 24 hour strikes (it got 43%), but there was a majority for an overtime ban (70%).
This began on Sunday 17 December, after a needless two weeks' delay while the result was reported, the NEC met, the NEC decided, permission to begin was given and a date set.
Unlike the union, Stagecoach Holdings had not been wasting their time. Scabs had been bussed in from Scotland, billeted in bed and breakfast, and shown the routes. (Other drivers from Devon who had been asked to come and cover for "a bout of influenza" went home when told the real reason.
When the ban began, it was obvious that it would not succeed unless the scabs were physically restrained. The branches met in the Bus Central Committee and decided that the only response was to step up the action, to ask members to refuse to work with scabs and walk out.
Preparations were made. A personal letter to each driver was to be handed out from 4.30am Monday morning. The big mistake was to tell the Divisional Officer of this! He reported it to Arundel, who told him to instruct the branches that they could not call a strike.
At 12.45am, less than four hours before the letters were to go out, Dave McCann, Chair of the Central Committee, was fetched from his bed to the phone and asked to ring round the branches. He refused.
Nonetheless, the branches were instructed by the Divisional Office and they obeyed.
By the time Dave McCann reported for work at 7.30am on the Monday morning, the overtime ban was showing its cracks. At Mansfield depot they felt that, since they couldn't act against the scabs, then the only way to keep them out was to work as normal.
Management knew this when they decided to go for Dave McCann.
As soon as he clocked on they told him that he should take a bus out instead of doing his job of 'cash witness' - this is checking money brought in by drivers as their protection. It is an agreed duty. McCann was told that he had to take the bus to cover for another driver refusing to work overtime. Of course he refused. He was suspended.
Later that day they sacked him.
The Divisional Officer then told them to call the whole ban off on Tuesday. The next day, Wednesday 20th, management put up notices at all depots.
Henceforth, the notices said, • there will be no more time off for trade union duties without management's express permission;
• the regular surgery days for union secretaries to find out about, and deal with, members' problems are ended;
• the joint negotiating machinery is finished - management will announce a new procedure of some sort at some time in the future;
• and from January Sth the company will no longer collect NUR dues.
And that is how things stand now. Two union activists victimisfrightened toes derect, and the union effectively derecognised.
It was a terrible mistake to call off the overtime ban at any of the depots without a joint decision of all depts to go back to normal working together, The price of this mistake is the sacking of Dave McCann.
But the real responsibility rests with the full-time officers who blocked escalation of the action. They didn't even respond to the provocation of the scabs. Instead, they kicked the feet from under the union activists.
No doubt they would protest. That they could do nothing else as the union could be sued for any action not specifically sanctioned by a ballot. And no-one wants the union to be sued, do they?
But what is the result of this extremely cautious attitude? No union! And in any case, with a proper lead from the officials a majority for effective action could have been won in a new ballot.
Now the management are going all out to smash up the union, and they won't stop until they have succeeded. Much of their success so far can be laid squarely at the door of these full-time bureaucrats.
But they will blame the rank and file. "In the ballot on 6 December they didn't want a strike, but on 17 December they did!" This has already been said as if to show how unreliable and untrustworthy the rank and file is.
But circumstances, and therefore moods, change. And the activists are far better at judging what to do and when, because they are in touch with the rank and file. The full-time bureaucrats aren't — they are out of touch and living comfortably somewhere else.
The decision to step up the action in response to the scabs was absolutely correct. The instruction from the full-time officers to call it off was treacherous, unnecessary and helped management.
We should turn the situation around and remind these bureaucrats just who are the union and who pays their wages.
We need a rank and file movement that can respond flexibly and immediately where the need arises. And we need a rank and file that holds these bureaucrats to account rather than taking orders from them.
We know the situation best, we know which tactics will work and when to use them; we have the strength to win.
Even without the anti-union laws the trade union bureaucrats sold out many a dispute. Ironically, Brian Arundel himselt, in his militant days, wrote with justified bitterness about how full-timers couldn't be trusted and would not look after the members' interests. And article he wrote when he was a Trotskyist, back in 1960, arguing for the rank and file to take control themselves is now circulating among East Midlands Motor Services busworkers.
In East Midlands Motor Services we have to turn the situation around. The local branches have set themselves the following aims:
1) Full reinstatement of the two sacked union activists with no loss of pay or service.
2) Reinstatement of the negotiating machinery and all union facilities.
3) Agreement by the company to continue collecting union subs.
These aims will only be achieved if the rank and file run the dispute themselves, rather than leaving it to sweet-talking, do-nothing NUR
Scan page 13
UST