Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Fellow Traveller" might have been called "The Singing…]

Socialist Organiser no. 430, 18 January 1990 · scan p. 11 · about 1,418 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Fellow Traveller" might have been called "The Singing Blacklisted Screenwriter", so close in type and pattern is it to Dennis Potter's "The Singand memories of mummy copulating, and so on, and so on. Except that nobody sings!

It is the latest British-made movie to be given exaggerated, and not entirely deserved, praise by a British press doing its bit in the praiseworthy cause of reviving the British film industry.

Though it is quite good and well worth seeing, "Fellow Traveller" doesn't deserve its rave reviews. It is that contradiction in terms, the political novie without politics - almost without politics anyway. -It is 1954, and Joseph McCarthy's *anti-Communist witch-hunt has cut down some of Hollywood's most talented writers, directors and actors. "Fellow Traveller" deals with a refugee from McCarthyism (acted by Ron Foreman did - and works without a permit, scriptwriting for a kids' TV show about Robin Hood.

Meanwhile, back in Hollywood, his best friend, pressure from the witch-hunters, shoots himself. The writer does not quite get involved with the dead friend's one-time girlfriend (Imogen Stubbs), now a school teacher Britain and a CP "activist for peace". He breaks up a lecture on "Marx and Freud" given by his old Hollywood sychoanalys (Daniel ravanti), a CP supporter, whom he ar cuses of being an informer.

Finally, he brings his wife and children over.

We see the threadbare, dowdy early post-war Britain, just as rationing is ending and prosperity is rearing its multifaceted head. Britain too has its political police. They "visit" the writer to ask what he's doing there. They obviously know all about him. But they are not very threatening, or even intrusive.

The "Communists' we see in Britain are nothing but peace activists. This is true, as anyone who mistakenly went looking for revolutionary politics to the CP in the '50s soon found out. But it is very one-sided. The CP was a real power in industry, and there, though it was a long way from revolutionary ideas, its working-class militants did not and helps distract attention from what is going on in Eastern Europe and the True enough! But the idea that the witch-hunt was fomented or fed by Stalinists to discredit the US resemble: nothing so much as some of the McCarthyite movies produced in the early '50s. 'Trial" , for example, a powertul courtroom drama of 1954, showed a Mexican boy wrongly accused of murder, a big radical campaign to save him, and his chief defence attorney deliberately trying to get him martyred so as to discredit American justice.

Part of the problem with any drama dealing with the US witch-hunts is tha nature of the hard-core victims, the Stalinists and their fellow-travellers. It is not just that they were American supporters (though usually unwitting, ignorant, starry-eyed supporters) of a regime overseas compared to which the American system was the unsullied liberal ideal. Nor that they had themselves been among the most unscrupulous pioneering witch-hunters, though they had.

Fundamentally, the problem lies in the way they behaved under pressure and at bay. James P Cannon, Farrell Dobbs, Felix Morrow and the other American working-class socialists hauled into court during the repression of the early 1940s, were proud and valiant militants in their own cause. They stood their ground and eagerly explained what they were and what they stood for.

They used the courtroom to indict the ruling class, and as a forum for propaganda and agitation against it. They behaved as self-respecting revolutionaries of varying hues have behaved in many ages and countries.

The Stalinists didn't. After the first jailings - the "Hollywood Ten" -they uniformly followed a Party line of "taking the Fifth. They pleaded the Fifth Amendment to the American Constitution, which allowed them to choose "incriminate" themselves. They hid, lied, and evaded.

The CP USA was a very powerful organisation, with 100,000 members in 1945. It had built its influence in the labour movements on corrupt and bureaucratic backscratching, using even gangsters as allies. Under the pressure of the government offensive after 1947, its power and influence collapsed spectacularly. The US Stalinists slunk into their political graves and boltholes.

Hard-core members like John Williamson, Gus Hall, and Alex Bittelman willingly faced jail and deportation. The periphery built in the days of bootlicking for President Roosevelt suffered an immense moral collapse. The rats trampled each other to death in their stampede from Stalin's stricken US merchantman.

SICIENICE The wanton slaughter of the Daniel J Travanti To make good, satisfying drama out of that, drama dealing with the substance of the matter — the politics - you would have to deal with the absurdities and grotesqueries which destroyed a generation of would-be socialists and, more importantly, were a major factor in politically derailing the US labour movement for (so far) half a century.

In fact, surviving participants in that awful experience have shown that they cannot come to terms with it. They either lie or fantasise about it.

Thus Lilian Hellman, who apparently died an unrepentant Stalinist, wrote best-selling memoirs in the "70s ("Scoundrel Time"), showing herself in a good light - and has since been shown to be an outright liar. She also ducked out, "taking the Fifth".

Symptomatic is perhaps the 1977 so far met with limited success. One method, translocation, involves sedating the animals and transporting them to areas where they can be more easily protected. Unfortunately, translocation has an associated death rate of 15%, mainly due to Woody Allen movie, "The Front", dealing with the witch-hunt and made mainly by victims of it. It has the Allen character telling the witch-hunters in court to "go fuck yourselves" . But none of them did that, or anything like it. It's the fantasy about his youth of the old man who ran away from the war he should have fought.

Artistically, the witch-hunt sterilised Hollywood, silencing immensely talented people, like director Abraham Polonsky, who didn't make a movie for 20 years. Politically, however, there as never any very noticeable socialist content in the work of the Stalinists and their fellow travellers. The moguls saw to that.

On TV you'll maybe catch Barbara Stanwyck in an old movie saying that someone is "as angry as the Daily Worker" — but that's sneak advertising, not politics. What politics there was in "30s and '40s Hollywood films was mainly glorifications of bourgeois democratic liberalism - about Thomas Jefferson, or Benito Juarez, or Abraham Lincoln.

Though such things were targeted in the early '50s, they were not just the work of Stalinists. And, paradoxically, some of the very best of Hollywood radical movies were made by selfprostrating turncoats who sang their heads off for the McCarthyites - for example, the fine movie about the Mexican Revolution, "Viva Zapata" • was made by Elia Kazan in 1952 or '53 just after he had been a "friendly witness" for the witch-hunters.

It's a messy story from any point of view, with all the colours and lines blurand smudged and unsatisfying. "Fellow Traveller" is worth seeing, but it doesn't even begin to get to grips with its proper political subject.

Throughout the operation, buckets of water are thrown over the rhino to keep its temperature down in the baking sun. The horn is cut off about 2½ inches above the skin, just above the quick. The stump is filed smooth with the rhino equivalent of a nail file and painted with antiseptic.

Then the antidote is given and the team beat a hasty retreat. After a minute the rhino is up and after someone's blood.

The question conservationists will want answered is "Will this save the rhino?" It is no use rendering the animal unattractive to poachers if it is thereby unable to defend itself against its predators or against other rhinos. Neither it is any use if the de-horned rhino is unattractive to potential mates and can no longer breed.

Happily, no ill effects have been observed with the pioneer rhinos and poachers have left the area.

The question is now "Could this technique be adapted to saving the elephant?" Undoubtedly, the problems are greater: for one, elephants live in herds, not in ones and twos. But it seems at present as though desperate measures may have to be considered to defeat those driven by prospects of extraordinary financial gain.

----- pull-quotes -----

reviews "Fellow Traveller"

ing Detective"- fantasies that take on a life of their own, dreams

Silver) who holes up in Britain - as in fact men like Joseph Losey and Carl

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 430

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →