Socialists and
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
marom Berlin to the Baltic, and east to th e borders of the USSR, the peoples have risen in revolt against the Stalinist police state tyrannies.
Everywhere the rallying cry of the revolution has been democracy — undifferentiated, classless democracy. It is as if we are watching an enlarged reenactment of the 1830 revolutions in France and Belgium, or of the democratic revolutions which spread through France, Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Czechoslovakia in 1848.
It is a magnificent and inspiring movement, but it is also a naive and politically underdeveloped movement, a movement for which the long West European experience of democracy does not seem to exist.
Yet, the history of democracy is nothing but the history of more or less open class struggle. And whatever the people of East Germany or Czechoslovakia may want, the future history of the mass popular movements in Eastern Europe of "society" against "the state" will also be a history of class struggle.
The consequences of market economics and foreign capital will inevitably be social differentiation and the fomenting of class struggle.
The all-inclusive mass movements -typified perhaps by the East German New Forum, which stubbornly refuses to become a political party because it wants to be a broad popular movement — will break and divide, and their class components will make war on each other. Nothing could be more certain.
It would be better if the workers who are enmeshed in the great would-be supra-class movements understood that now, and began to fight for their own class interests. Instead, they are locked into movements which are dominated by pro-capitalist intellectuals, priests, and liberalising bureaucrats.
Working-class differentiation does exist, but it is at an early stage. Nowhere yet has the working class created its own class organs of struggle, such as were the Hungarian workers' councils of 1956, and the great workers' parliament centred around the Lenin shipyard at Gdansk during the strikes of August 1980.
Caught up in the great "classless" movements, the working class masses look now to the old Stalinist fake parliaments, which have taken on a life autonomous from the old ruling bureaucrats, and for the future they look to the creation of genuine parliaments on the model of Western Europe.
Whereas socialists in a country like Britain have had long decades of painful experience to help us understand the crippling limitations of the existing parliamentary system, and to learn that normally it is little more than a glove puppet within which works the grasping, stifling hand of the bourgeoisie, the East Europeans approach it from a different angle, almost from a different side of history.
For them, even the flawed bourgeois democracy we have in Western Europe would be a tremendous advance.
Absent are powerful working-class socialist organisations able to act as educators and as the historical memory of the working class, custodians of the lessons of our long world-wide class experience. This means that for the masses of workers newly awakened to political life in Eastern Europe, only experience with bourgeois democracy - experience from which earlier generations of socialists formulated a programme of working-class democracy, and counterposed it to bourgeois parliamentarism — will suffice to convince them that the democracy we have in the West, and to which they aspire in the East, is not enough, nor anything like enough.
In the East, Stalinism has dirtied and distorted the words, symbols and ideas of socialism and genuine communism, covering them in filth and blood. Decades of blood and terror perpetrated by privileged Stalinist bureaucrats who said they were socialists, and who used the old socialist criticism of bourgeois democracy to try to justify something far worse, now stand between the mass of East European and Soviet workers and an understanding of the ideas and aspirations of unfalsified socialism and genuinc democracy. Experience will teach them - and perhaps quickly.
The following article, by John O'Mahony, first appeared in Socialist Organiser early in 1982 as part of a series debating democracy with Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock.
There are two distinct but interwoven strands in the attitudes the labour movement has taken to parliamentary democracy.
The first was and is ardent champion of parliamentary democracy and democratic liberties. In varying alliances with sections of the middle class, workers and early labour movements fought to extend the suffrage and enlarge the power of Parliament — often by revolutionary means.
The first mass political labour movement, Chartism, took shape around demands for the reshaping of the existing parliamentary system so as to admit the working class to the suffrage and make it possible for workers to be MPs.
In Britain, as late as 1917, the Workers' Socialist Federation, led of the Workers' Suffrage Federation, which in turn came out of the left wing of the suffragette movement in the East End), based themselves on an extremely radical programme of democratic reform attempting to graft on to the British parliament features of the workers' council system that had just emerged in Russia.
In 1934 Trotsky suggested a united front with reformist workers in France for a similar progiamme. The second strand has been the drive to create new, different, specifically working class organs of democracy - either by converting old forms for the purpose, or by establishing completely new ones.
The Paris Commune in 1871 was an example of the taking over and transformation of old forms. The creation of new forms began in Petrograd, Russia, in 1905, when striking workers who did not have political rights elected their own local parliament or council of workers' deputies — the soviet"
After the overthrow of Tsarism in February 1917, a vast network of soviets developed, with pyramids of city, district, and all-Russian gatherings.
In their own way, from the ground up, the soviets realised such old working class demands as direct control of the legislature -delegates could be recalled and replaced.
The soviet network showed itself to be a uniquely flexible and responsive system of democratic self-organisation and increasingly, of self-rule by the Russian masses. Whereas even the most democratic parliamentary system was tied to the bourgeois military/bureaucratic structure, the soviets were counterposed in toto to the surviving Tsarist military/bureaucratic state structure.
"..the drive to reform and develop the existing parliaments gave place...to a commitment to soviets as the highest form of democracy..
In 1917 the Congress of Soviets (with the Bolshevik Party majority as its driving force) seized state Thereafter the drive to reform and develop the existing parliaments gave place, for millions of revolutionary workers throughout the world, to a commitment to soviets as the highest form of democracy, as the specifically working class form of democracy.
This commitment became a central part of the programme of revolutionary socialism. workers.
In foreign uncritical munism cries, by than struggle. the hands of the right win ternational labour movem ommitment to perfecting cratic institutions of capit y became a commitme ourgeoisie against the re ry workers. In Germany revolution created a bour cratic regime, with the socialists in alliance with against the revolutio the mid-'30s the Stali soviets from their me and pursued alliances ght of the labour movem vith Liberals to serve Rus policy neress. bed tical worshippers of the parliaments. At the same pushed the debilitating lie ist totalitarianism was a irkers' democracy. : result was to banish con democracy and to falsif anguage and concepts. e basic idea that socialists r nue the struggle for hui y and freedom was expu the programme of sm' Democracy' lism', became cynical c shot through with dou about the spurious democ e society where the Stal ucrats ruled. stsky noted the corruptin f this on the labour mover when he commented on egian Labour Party: "I iccasion to become convin xperience, that the ¡eois functionaries somet a broader viewpoint an profound sense of dis Messrs *Socia ters.
1917, soviets WOl sils elected from factories its - have been thrown u e number of countries in s of large-scale working șle.
Austria, Germany
Scan page 8
ith WORKERS in tr EASIERN BL Speakers from Eastern Europe, Chi na and th British labour movement Saturday 27 January 11.00 5.00 University of London Uni Malet St, London WCI Tickets: £8 (waged), £4 (low waged/students), £2 (unwaged) ir tickets write to Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bl (CSWEB), 56 Kevan House, Wyndham Road, London SE5
Scan page 9
democracy g of ent, the alist to oluthe eois ight the mary nists pr WI ith ents sian me exim le at irm Hungary in 1918, and Hungary again in 1956, through to Gdansk in 1980, soviets have emerged as flexible l forms of working class democratic self-organisation — factory committees generalised to the whole of society.
'The has been ut debased by association totalitarian bureaucrac The historical experience of soviets as a form of social rule is of course limited. As early as the end of 1918 the soviets in the USSR were being undermined as freely functioning democratic organs by the exigencies of civil war, and they were shortly to be gutted of all real life. This process culminated in the ban on every party but the Bolsheviks in March 1921. Intended as a temporary measure, it became fixed as the norm of the Stalinist political counterrevolution.
Nevertheless, it is clear:
• That these soviets, which have emerged in vastly different conditions and countries, are not accidental forms. At the very least, they are valuable organs of working class self-organisation in struggle.
• In Russia before they were blasted by civil war, they were a form of democracy more flexible, adjustable and responsive than any parliamentary system.
• Being independent of the existing bureaucratic military system to which capitalist rule is tied, they word 'soviet' are — to go by experience so far -the best form of organisation for a workers' movement that is seriously setting about transforming society against the will of the ruling class • That they are more appropriate than any other known form of democracy to the socialist rule of the working class, in so tar as it involves a qualitative expansion of the direct exercise of democracy.
• That they can and will re-emerge at intense levels of mass working class action, when the struggle overflows the channels of the existing system. We probably came close to it in Britain in 1972.
That is why workers' councils are a central part of the programme of revolutionary Marxism.
The word 'soviet' has been utterly debased by association with the totalitarian bureaucracy of the USSR — which as the sour old joke has it, contains four lies in its name: it is not a union, there are no soviets, it is not socialist, and it is not a republic.
But Marxists remain committed to soviet democracy. We continue the old socialist commitment to expanding democracy in a qualitative way. We explain the limits of existing democracy and the possibilities of a different democracy.
Is this Marxist commitment counterposed to the basic labour movement commitment to parliamentary democracy? Not at all.
Socialism is not possible until the mass of workers want it and are prepared to realise it — neither is an extension of democracy beyond the level already attained.
It is in the direct interests of the working class to defend the existing system against anti-democratic attacks. It is in our interest to extend it and better it (for example by making the next Labour prime minister subject to election by the labour movement, outside of Parliament; by freeing the existing system from the dead grip of the parliamentary oligarchy of the PLP: and by ensuring that there is some relationship between what aspirant MPs and aspirant majority parties say they will do and what they actually do). All this is the difference between good and bad circulation in the exIsting body politic.
Thus Marxists have much in common with people in the labour movement whose best notion of democracy is parliamentary democracy. We can agree to fight to rejuvenate the existing system; we could agree to defend it with guns against, for example, a military coup.
Marxists can and do form such alliances with honest 'non-soviet' democrats. The reason why we cannot and do not form such relations with the right wing and the soft left is not because we are not democrats, but because they are very bad democrats.
They worship the miserably inadquate system that exists.
They have done more than any Marxist to educate sections of the labour movement about the limits of parliamentary democracy: they have even exaggerated those limits and made them far more narrow than they would be for a fighting 45 303 labour movement intent on defending the working class interest. They have, in successive Labour governments and especially since 1964, done more than anyone else to discredit parliamentary democracy and render cynical large sections of the labour movement.
The cynicism has corroded not only democracy but the political consciousness of the labour movement. Marxists, while we tell the workers who listen to us that they should rely only on their own strength, see no advantage or gain for our politics in cynicism.
While small groups can advance to a higher understanding by way of such disillusionment, the great mass of the labour movement is thrown back by it.
The mass of the labour movement will advance to a better understanding of the limits of parliamentary democracy, not by pure disgust with the Labour right - politically, that is a passive response, and politically limited even when it helps generate industrial direct action - but most likely by struggle, and by attempting to use to the maximum the existing institutions of the labour movement and of British bourgeois democracy.
Eastern Towards capitalism or 60p plus 15p posta from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA arliamenta emocracy!
Leon As long as the majority of th working class continues on the basis of bourgeois democracy, we are ready to defend it with all our forces against violent attacks from the Bonapartist and fascist bourgeoisie.
However, we demand from our class brothers who adher to 'democratic' socialism tha they be faithful to their ideas, that they draw inspiration from the ideas and methods not of the Third Republic but of the Convention of 1793.
Down with the Senate, which is elected by limited suffrage and which renders the power of universal suffrage a mere illusion!
Down with the presidency of the republic, which serve: as a hidden point of concentration for the forces of militarism and reaction!
A single assembly must combine the legislative and executive powers. Members would be elected for two years, by universal suffrage eighteen years of age, with! discrimination of sex or nationality. Deputies would be elected on the basis of local assemblies, constantly revocable by their constituents, and would receive th salary of a skilled worker.
This is the only measure that would lead the masses forward instead of pushing them backward. A more generous democracy would facilitate the struggle for workers' power.
We want to attain our objective not by armed conflic between the various groups toilers but by real workers" democracy, by propaganda and loyal criticism, by the voluntary regrouping of the great majority of the proletariat under the flag of tru communism.
Workers adhering to democratic socialism must. further understand that it is not enough to defend democracy; democracy must be regained.
The moving of the political centre of gravity from parliament towards the cabinet, from the cabinet towards the oligarchy of finance capital, generals, police, is an accomplished fact. Neither the present parliament nor the new elections can change this.
We can defend the sorry mains of democracy, and especially we can enlarge the democratic arena for the activity of the masses, only by annihilating the armed fascist forces that, on February 6 1934, started moving the axis of the state and are still doing SO.
From the Action Programme, 1934
----- pull-quotes -----
EASTERN EUROPE
Defend deepen parliam