Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unite for campaign

Socialist Organiser no. 430, 18 January 1990 · scan pp. 5–6 · Bruce Robinson · about 1,981 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Power still lies in the streets The rapidly changing course of events in East Germany is increasingly outside the control of both the government and the organised opposition.

Since the start of December the political mood has shifted a long way to the right. A recent West German opinion poll showed 67% in favour of immediate reunification, an increase of 8% since the start of November. The mass demonstrations in Leipzig and other cities have become increasingly dominated by nationalist slogans.

While there clearly is a base for nationalism in the GDR, this shift is neither a necessary consequence of democratisation, nor just a result of the intervention of West German politicians - though Kohl's Ten Point Plan for a Confederation of the two German states doubtless raised expectations of short-term reunification.

It reflects the deep-seated hatred felt by people for the old regime -particularly, following the revelations of corruption amongst the SED leadership, and the exposure of the extent of Stasi (secret police) activity. This hatred often expresses itself in an identification of all socialism with Stalinism. There is also a widespread feeling that reunification is a quick way to a higher standard of living.

In this vacuum, fascists, such as the West German Republican Party, have already begun to organise. Though they were thrown off the most recent Leipzig demo and their strength has been exaggerated by the East German government for its own purposes, in the longer term, frustration and the growth of nationalism could provide them with a breeding ground.

In short, the move to the right expresses the deep crisis of East German society and the fact that none of the major political forces, whether the SED (Communist Party) and its previously docile satellites or the main forces of the opposition, appear able to solve it.

The SED lacks any credibility, particularly since the revelations of the corruption of the Honecker leadership — which was not merely a question of them lining their own pockets, but also of selling arms to countries such as South Africa to do it. Nearly a million members have left the SED since October, some no doubt rats leaving the sinking ship, but other genuinely disgusted at what was done in their name. Many of the institutions which had semi-state functions, such as the official unions, are now shells, trying desperately to regain some credibility by trying to keep up with the mass movement through drastic reforms.

The state machine is also unreliable for the government. Though the normal police and the - largely conscript - army are still in place, the Stasi apparatus, which maintained massive surveillance of the whole population, has formally been disarmed and disbanded after the invasions of its buildings by demonstrators at the beginning of December.

Although only about one third of its members have been dismissed, it is unlikely that the government will be able to prevent the whole organisation going, at least if they are concerned to maintain a democratic face. The Prime Minister, Hans Modrow, this week abandoned his attempt to create a new secret police force because of threats of resignation by ministers from the other official parties (who now sit in a coalition government) and, more importantly, because of threats by New Forum to withdraw from Round Table talks with the government and call demonstrations and strikes.

A whole range of opposition groups, including both movements such as New Forum and Democracy Now and parties such as the Greens and Social Democrats, have been taking part in Round Table talks with the government since December. These talks have no formal status but supposedly give the opposition groups an input into what the government does without having seats in the Volkskammer (parliament).

Threats to withdraw nave, On several occasions, won concessions from the government, and, so far, attempts to coopt the opposition through the talks seems to have failed. This de facto veto exists, in the last analysis, because of the government's fear of the movement on the streets and also because the SED needs to appear serious about reform and power-sharing if it is to win a sizeable vote in the coming elections on 6 May.

Until then, the government is only able to rule with the agreement of the opposition groupings, which are in turn increasingly unable to lead the movement on the streets. However, when it comes to measures where it expects little organised opposition, the government is able to get its way. For example, the clause in the constitution forbidding foreign investment has been removed, state subsidies for basic goods are being dismantled and other steps towards a market economy introduced. This is taking advantage of the fact that the organisation of independent unions is still at a very early stage.

The opposition itself faces number of problems. The first is that of material resources, access to the media and political organisation generally.

New Forum, with 200,000 supporters, was only able to publish 5,000 copies of a duplicated newsletter containing its draft programme. The SED still has influence in the media and printing plants of its own, while the official ibloc' parties also have their own papers, offices, etc. The opposition has little chance of direct access to TV or the press and little money to develop its own press.

There is likely to be a lot of argument about a clause in the draft electoral law forbidding financial help from abroad, though it is no doubt intended to stop the domination of the elections by parties with rich sugar-daddies in West Germany. Although Modrow has said that he will make concessions on access to the media and funds, it remains to be seen whether the SED will use its advantages to try and rebuild its base in the elections. The smaller opposition organisations will probably have particular problems getting heard.

To counter this, six organisations including New Forum, Democracy Now, the Social Democrats and the United Left -set up a joint slate for the elections. The political basis for this must have been confused as the United Left (explicitly socialist and for workers' democracy pulled out after one day as a result of a dispute with the Social Democrats. The latter have since effectively merged with the West German SPD and are now calling for immediate reunification.

The coming elections have also caused an increasing split within New Forum about whether the movement should become a political party.

Several branches which declared themselves a party have been rapped over the knuckles by the leading committee and their delegate conference rejected becoming a party by 121 to 16. Despite this, New Forum has also stated that nobody who is a member of any political party can be a candidate of their organisation and are preparing detailed political platform. This seems to reflect a widespread suspicion of political parties as being less democrațic or representative than broader 'citizens' movements.

New Forum's programme is perhaps typical of the mainstream of the organised opposition. It is a programme for of the radical democratisation GDR, within the framework of a decentralised rank and file democracy is restricted conore it Thedamakes ne matter workplace or society-wide democracy or undermines the solidaristic or ecological foundations of our society. To prevent the dictatorship of the plan flipping over into the dictatorship of the market, we support strong non-party political unions and the real control of fundamental economic decisions of the management by democratically elected factory councils.

These councils are set up at factory level, where they have a veto, while at a national level Keynesianstyle policies should be used to control the market. The right to a job is to be maintained, and a 40-hour week with no loss of pay introduce*In reality the introduction of the market to the GDR is likely to take place under rather less pleasant circumstances and these rights will be opposed equally violently by the Stalinist bureaucrats and managers and by Western investors.

Increasingly it looks as if the parliament elected in May will already face a legal fait accompli about the conditions under which foreign investment will take place.

To win these demands will require a high level of workplace organisation and struggle, which has still to be built from the ground up. Both the United Left and the independent trade union organisations are focusing on organising in nee workplaces, emphasising the for independent representation of the workers' interests. But time is short and they face both legal and material difficulties.

The political vacuum in the GDR has meant a widening gap between the organised opposition and the mass of the population. As well as the political and organisational weakness of the left, this may also be because they often appear utopian and not to be proposing any immediate way out of the social If reunification is not to take place on a capitalist basis, the lett has to start from the immediate concerns of the workers that make it seem a real alternative to a discredited Stalinist system. The opportunities to do this still exist. The shift to the right is far from definitive.

But time running East Euro By Mark Osborn British students are mobili• sing in support of the ne independent studen unions and trade unions in British student unions and Area organisations are already "twinning" with Czech and East German independent students organisations.

All this is being done without any positive help from the National Union of Students. There has been nothing from NUS to encourage unions to help the independent student unions in Eastern Europe. NUS's national magazine does not even mention the upheavals in East Europe in its second term issue.

For years, NUS has maintained links with the 'official' student organisations, which were little more than police state fronts. These organisations are thoroughly discredited. But NUS has given assurances that it will break 'most' links with these 'unions' only after the revolutions of East Germany and Czechoslovakia.

Causescu's official Romanian student union is, for example, credited with official status in this year's NUS diary. NUS has broken links with these unions years too late.

Not only the Kinnock supporters who lead NUS are dragging their heels. One left-wing group, Socialist Outlook, has refused to support the Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc conference on 27 January.

The one Area NUS where this group has influence, NUS London, refused to support the conference because the conference appeal calls for freedom of speech and association in the Eastern Bloc.

The argument was that any support for freedom of association in the Eastern Bloc meant support for the fascist and nationalist organisations which are growing in some countries! That was what Alistair Chisholm said, anyway. He is general secretary of NUS London (and god help NUS London!)

It was a transparent excuse for sectarianism. Socialist Outlook seem to be unable to think objectively about anything Socialist Organiser is involved in.

At the Socialist Movement trade union conference last November, Alan Thornett of Socialist Outlook insisted that his colleagues vote against amendments proposed by Socialist Organiser. The amend. ments were uncontroversial but Thornett insisted: anything from Socialist Organiser must be opposed.

A number of trade unionists opposed this stupidity in the Socialist Outlook caucus, and at least one of them subsequently broke his links with Socialist Outlook in protest.

In the student movement Socialist Outlook supporters have split away from Left Unity - again because of irrational hatred for Socialist Organiser. And now we have this rubbish about supporting fascists as an excuse for Socialist Outlook to refuse to back a conference aimed at organising support for the renascent East European and Soviet workers' movements! Grow up, comrades!

• Left Unity broadsheet: 30l n Left Unity, c/o 56 Kevan ise, Wyndham Road, Londo

Scan page 6

Czechoslovakia 1989: workers demonstrate for democracy and freedom workers gua

----- pull-quotes -----

Solidarity with the East European REVOLUTION!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 430

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →