The workers A media, but also part
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-01-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
favourite theme of the Licularly of party and state functionaries and their managers, is once again the application of the principle of improving effort and performance - basically an old tune from the Department of Agitation and Propaganda.
Once again an attempt is being made to push responsibility for the economic crisis onto working people. If we're going downhill, if there are not enough goods in the shop, or if the GDR can offer less and less on the world market, then the workers haven't performed well enough.
At first this seems quite plausible, as it's a fact that one can only consume what has pre iously been produced. In brief, we live today according to how we worked yesterday, and if we live miserably, then we have only got ourselves to blame. It's true that most of us know that - apart from bad organisation of production, shortage of materials, etc. - we could achieve better results. Some people even have a bad conscience about it. Are we therefore also guilty if we're in a mess?
Seen from below, this, at first plausible argument contains a tew important snags: (1) Despite the much-vaunted "second pay packet" , ie. the subsidies for basic food, rent, etc., by comparison with others we are well on the way to becoming a low-wage country. This can be seen, amongst other things, by the fact that temporary workers from the GDR are welcome on the West German labour market - at least to the employers! For our colleagues there it means increased competition and pressure on their living standards.
If our workers get lower wages and are still supposed to make the same effort, this means that they are underpaid or, in other words, the rate of exploitation is higher for them than for other workers, regardless of whether they are employed here or abroad. If we are, therefore, less prepared to make an effort here, that only corresponds to the smaller amount we get paid for it.
If the inadequate total amount of money available for wages is just distributed differently it will only lead to envy and resentment between colleagues, particularly when - in new models = they are supposed to decide independently among themselves how to divide it up. It may be that some of them will be spurred on to greater efforts in this way. But those who lose out will have even less reason to do their best. These effects cancel each other out; on average the total effort will remain the same as before.
So anyone demanding our full efforts must also pay for them in full. Our measure cannot be what some Politburocrat thinks out at his desk or has seen in the Third World. It must be the world average for work of a comparable type.
(2) Higher wages are only one side of the coin. There's not much point in having money if there's little or nothing one can buy for it. However, the question of whether daily necessities are produced in sufficient quantities or not depends least of all on the keenness of the workers. The planners — in the last analysis, the Party and government - decide how much of the existing productive capacity should be used on consumer goods for their own population and how much is used on means of production, export, luxury goods, the armed forces, the secret police, etc. In deciding that, the needs of the rulers come right at the top of the list and those of the workers right at the bottom.
Thus if less is achieved than is possible here, this is not just because of inadequate payment but above all because of the miserable level of provision. Further, nobody should be surprised if part of working time is lost to reduce the enormous extra expenditure required by a GDR citizen — in comparison with other industrial countries - if s/he is to get hold of food, clothing, repairs, etc.
(3) The quantity of available consumer goods is not however decisive on its own. The quality is decisive - and leaves a lot to be desired. Nobody is prepared to perform exceptional work in order to be palmed off with shoddy goods and rubbish for their wages, because everything that is at all usable is exported or frittered away by the rulers themselves. One cannot therefore continuously demand of the workers that they produce according to the best standards in the world and consume according to the standards of pre-industrial yokels.
(4) There have now been attempts for years — particularly in important economic sectors — to improve inadequate willingness to work by so-called economic incentives. More money came into circulation through special payments and direct wage rises without a corresponding increase in quantity of consumer goods in the plan or on sale. When more money than goods are around, the money loses its value. For a long time we've been paying the bill, as prices have gradually risen. Yesterday's increased wages are "eaten up" by today's hidden inflation. What is even worse: prices gradually begin to rise more quickly than wages and that means that living standards fall.
Application of the principle of performance can thus only mean drastic improvement of the supply situations and matching the reward to the effort demanded by the state but correctly refused by the workers. In any case, this would only be a first step to ending the paralysis of the political and economic situation. On the contrary, these measures still having nothing to do with socialism, as long as working people have no alternative but to sell their labour power, regardless of whether the buyer is called a private capitalist or purely and simply the state.
The preparedness to put one's full abilities into social production could in any case be brought about in a different way; namely if we developed an interest of our own in long? our activity, ie. if our free initiative was given free play and the resulting changes were of direct benefit to the workers themselves (eg. in that growing labour productivity always led to falling working hours. But this is the big dilemma of this self-styled socialism, that every initiative which doesn't come from above is consistently strangled -that is the fundamental experience that everyone here repeats time and again from their mother's knee until they either lose the habit of showing initiative or leave this behind by "voting with their feet"
Without a fundamental change in this problem, ie. the position of working people in the process of production itself, the GDR doesn't have the slightest chance of weathering the storm, but will fall into the hands of international big capital like a developing country, to be squeezed like a lemon. however, it was successful in winning the necessary room for the complete unfolding of the initiative of every individual, it would be clear how superfluous the whole Politbureaucracy is even for today's, but still more for a future, mode of production and what fantastic growth in production would flower from an overcoming of the master-and-slave relationship. In this way workers could in reality take over responsibility for the further development of the country.
Scan page 5
EAST GERMAN