Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Should socialists object to drag?

Socialist Organiser no. 429, 4 January 1990 · scan pp. 6–7 · Edward Ellis · about 749 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Same Edna Everage is not Da Ra queen, mording.

to Barry Humphries, answering Melvyn Bragg's questions on Sunday night.

Drag acts, he said, are self-conscious imitations of women. Dame Edna, by contast, is a complete, real person, if an invented one. We might marvel at how perfectly a drag act imitates Shirley Bassey; but Edna exists.

Barry Humphries has a point, which makes me think socialist attitudes to drag.

The Day of Days By William Morris Each eve earth falleth down the dark, As though its hope were o'er; Yet lurks the sun when day is done Behind to-morrow's door.

Grey grows the dawn while men-fol sleep, Unseen spreads on the light, Till the thrush sings to the coloured things, earth forgets There are essentially two types of drag act. Most common are those that mime to female singers. But there are also drag acts who themselves sing (and here you can see Barry Humphries' case: not in falsetto), and a lot of drag acts have a comedy routine. Typical of drag queen humour are off-the-cuff abusive put-downs: the more apparently improvised, the better.

In this, I would suggest, Dame Edna is a very classical drag act. Apparently, live she is more obscene, which would also put her firmly in the classical drag category.

Yet in a much more profound sense than Barry Humphries'. Edna is very different. Because what No otherwise wends on our Hope: E'en as a tale that's told Are fair lives lost, and all the cost Of wise and true and bold./ We've toiled and failed; we spake the word; None hearkened; dumb we lie; Our Hope is dead, the seed we spread Fell o'er the earth to die.

What's this? For joy our hearts stand still, And life is loved and dear, The lost and found the Cause crowned, Day of Days unites the numerous kinds of drag queen is that their humour is gay. There is nothing much gay about Edna Everage.

A lot of feminists object to drag, and to transvestism (which is not necessarily the same thing: a transvestite is a man who dresses as a woman for some reason of sexual or other personal satisfaction; a drag queen does it as an act on stage).

They say that the image of women portrayed by drag queens is a stereotypical, misogynistic one. The 'women' are absurdly made up, foul-mouthed harpies, constructions of male hatred for women's bodies. Moreover, this image of women is one born of a sexist society; if such images of women die out, as they will, so will drag. Drag is the product of reactionary attitudes towards women, and so both feminists and socialists should be hostile to it.

Thus on Lesbian and Gay Pride marches, you sometimes find leaflets distributed calling for the drag queens and TVs to be ejected on the grounds that they are reactionary and anti-women.

Of course, a lot of drag queen humour is misogynist (and racist, etc). So is most humour you will hear in working class pubs and clubs. But it is not true that drag per se is sexist.

Drag queens dress up as women, and employ a stereotypical image of women. But it is not women who are being parodied; it is men. Barry Humphries is quite right, that never for a moment does anyone doubt that the drag queen is a man; but it is a man ridiculing conventional images of masculinity. It is a man celebrating the denial of those images, saying: "Look at me, I'm a nelly queen, I don't conform to all the stupid stereotypes, and sod you. And I'm funny."

Indeed, a lot of drag queens deliberately find a straight man in the audience to persecute mercilessly for their entire act: that's part of the point of the whole thing.

So drag queens are an enormously important part of gay culture. In general I'm not happy with the concept of gay culture, but in so far as such a thing exists, drag is part of it.

Obviously more so for gay men than for lesbians, but it is by no means true that drag queens have no lesbian audiences. Drag is an entire world of entertainment that has been created within the gay community, sub-culture, or whatever it might best be called.

And so it's an important aspect of creating a sense ol identity, a way of laughing at straight society, maybe.

If you doubt what I'm catch a performance

Scan page 7

regain initiative

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 429

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →