Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

For a Socialist United Europe!

Socialist Organiser no. 429, 4 January 1990 · scan p. 5 · Eric Heffer · about 2,152 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Eric Heffer MP writes events in Eastern Europe and the USSR hat is happening in - Eastern Europe is not the end of Socialism or Communism. It is the polítical revolution long predicted by Trotsky and others.

It was clear that a political revolution was essential once Stalin had got in power through the transformation of the Bolshevik Party. Despite oppression and state terorism, it was only a matter of time before the revolution took place.

I must go back into history for us to understand what is happening today.

The October Russian Revolution of 1917 was the first and only successful workers' revolution in the world. The Paris Commune of 1871 was equally a workers' revolution, but unfortunately did not last. It was militarily destroyed and thousands-were killed by French Government troops. The 1905 Russian Revolution led by Leon Trotsky, when Soviets were first developed, was the forerunner of the 1917 Revolution.

During the First World War -an imperialist war, which was fought, not over democracy, but over the control of markets and for colonial possessions - the Bolsheviks were one of the few parties who kept to the resolution of the Second International, to oppose capitalist imperialist wars. That Is to oppose the imperialist war, and to fight against one's own imperialist government.

Most of the parties of the Second International betrayed the. principles of the International and supported their own government against the other governments involved. The Labour Party, as perhaps could be expected, did that n Britain.

Once it was understood that the war was murdering millions of people, creating great sorrow and destruction, the anti-war Socialist forces regrouped, and the Bolsheviks were in the lead.

German Socialists like Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg opposed the war and were imprisoned because of their attitude. In Britain william John Maclean, Paul, the Socialist Labour Party, and some in the Independent Labour Party like Ramsay MacDonald were against the war, some for pacifist reasons.

Once the workers (under Bolshevik leadership) overthrew the Tsar, and then the Kerensky Provisional Government, genuine Socialism throughout the world gave unqualified support to the soviets.

There was, however, serious criticism of the way the Bolsheviks operated. One of the greatest critics was Rosa Luxemburg, who had spent many years in jail. She helped to create the Spartacus League and the German Communist Party, but was murdered by a right-wing military group, with night-wing Social Democrats giving their blessinline widespread support amongst Socialists for the Russian Revolution led to the formation of the Communist International on the basis of the 21 conditions set down by Lenin.

Some of the parties of the Second International, like the Italian and French parties (ın a majorıty) Joined the CI, others split, and in other countries new Communist Parties were formed. In Britain a CP was created out of various groups like Sylvia Pankhurst's | Workers' Socialist Federation, the British Socialist Party, the shop stewards movement, the Socialist Labour Party, etc.

-In the 21 points was the acceprance of the concept of 'democratic centralism' — a concept which meant a great deal of centralism in the party but little democracy.

Over the years the CPs became; in the main, apologists of the Soviet Union. The process of so-called Bolshevisation took place and led to centralised control, both locally and internationally. After Stalin became secretary of the Soviet Party, the CI became the instrument of Soviet policy and power, and real debate was more or less eliminated from the CI and the CPs. Decisions were handed down from above.

The brief period of democracy in the Soviet Union under Lenin was destroyed under Stalin. Unfortunately the process had begun under Lenin, when all groups and tendencies in the Bolshevik Party were banned as a temporary measure.

That temporary measure became, as so often in society, permanent. Under Stalin more or less total control was put into the hands of the General Secretary:

"Trotsky was banished, his friends imprisoned and, in show trials, condemned and shot.

The Red Army leadership was prac tically destroyed, and the Gulags and prison camps set up"

Lenin was very worried about the too great centralisation of power, and the growth of the bureaucracy. He warned against it and against Stalin in his so-called "Testament' which was suppressed for years in the Soviet Union but is now published.

The truth is that Soviet society, as envisaged by Rosa Luxemburg, ie. lifeless and bureaucratic, became increasingly bureaucratic and power was centralised into the hands of the General Secretary. All democratic processes were destroyed. Stalin used the state apparatus, the secret service, the police and armed forces, to destroy the opposition.

Firstly, Stalin used the Right of the Party to destroy the Left Opposition, then he turned and destroyed the Right, people like Bukharin and Rykov. In the meantime, hundreds of thousands had joined the party, and now owed everything to the Stalinist bureaucracy -Trotsky was banished, his friends imprisoned and, in show trials, condemned and shot. The Red Army leadership was practically destroyed, and the Gulags and prison camps were set up.

That was the negative side, yet positive things were done also. Massive industrialisation took place, but in a bureaucratic fashion and at the expense of working people. A health service was created.. All got a good chance of education. Houses, but not enough, were built. Workers' conditions improved -however, not as they should have been.

Independent trade unions were destroyed, with the unions becomRomanian flag is waved on top of ing part of the state apparatus. The unions became the transmission belt for the Party, not the instrument for the workers.

The truth is that in place of the workers being the dictatorship over ultimately the leadership, became the capitalists, the dictatorship over the workers.

The socialist critics of the Soviet leaders argued about the nature of the Soviet Union. The Trotskyists said it was a deformed workers' state. Others, like the Socialist Party of Great Britain, and later the IS/SWP and CLR James, etc., said it was state capitalist. Some ex-US Trotskyist intellectuals like Burnham argued that it was a bureaucratic collectivist society. The only think that they agreed about was that the Soviet Union was not a genuine workers' socialist society, and that sooner or later a political revolution would take place.

Personally, I am not sure what type of society Stalin created, but the socialised base of society cannot be ignored It was clear the political revolution would demand that there be free and independent trade unions, that there should be free elections, freedom of speech and the press, and that more than one political party of the workers should be formed. -The hopes for that were dashed after the Second World War. The capitalist powers, together with the Soviet Union, agreed that the world, especially Europe and the Middle East, should be divided up into spheres of influence between them. That is what Potsdam was about. It was the division of the world into spheres of influence by the USA, France, Britain and the That is why Stalin did not lift a finger to help the Greek partisans on the one hand, and the West on the other let Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Poland go. It was a stand-off.

The truth is Yugoslavia would have gone to capitalism but in that country Tito and the partisans were too strong and there was little the West could do. The Yugoslav revolution was a genuine people's revolt. The same was true of Albania, and even in Czechoslovakia, in the early days, the workers were, through their factory committees, supporting the Communist Party. To that extent there was an element of genuine revolutionary upsurge.

Elsewhere the Communist Parties were installed on the points of the Soviet bayonets. They were put in power because it suited the Soviet Union to have buffer states around them which could be used as safeguards against future attacks.

We should not be too critical of that aspect of Soviet policy. After all, there had been the Allied intervention after the Revolution in 1917, and there had been the failure to agree an anti-Nazi pact before the war. That is why the Soviets attacked Finland, and after that the CP headquarters, l.uc: agreed to the Soviet/German non-aggression pact, which Stalin hoped would stop them being attacked by Hitler:

What was awful was that, as a result of the pact, German Communist Party members and antifasists were sent back to Germany, imprisoned, tortured and killed. Communists were betrayed by the Stalinist leaders. Equally, after the spanish troubles, spanish antıtascists ended up in Stalinist prison camps, as did many Austrian workers who fought against fascism in Austria in 1934.

Poland, Hungary, Bulgaria, Rumania, Czechoslovakia, East Germany, etc. could not have become so-called People's Democracies had not the Communist Parties been put in power by the Soviets. That is really the key to the present situation.

In Czechoslovakia the 1968 upsurge was overthrown by Soviet troops and tanks. In 1956 the Hungarian Revolution, led by Imre Nagy, was overthrown by Russian tanks, guns and troops. In Poland the Soviet Army had huge numbers of troops, and after the War a Russian General was put in charge of the army.

Stalin, immediately after the War, put certain people in control of the Communist Parties in Eastern Europe who were his creatures. That is why the trials of innocent people took place. That is why the purges took place. That is why any semblance of democracy was destroyed.

"There have been have demands for time in Eastern Europe. That demand is not a The fact is that in Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia - and in Yugoslavia, where Stalin's writ did not run - the democratic processes and upsurges began inside the Communist Party, and it was Communist Party people who were the first victims. Nagy and Dubcek were Communists. Even Husak was jailed in the '50s, and was released to do the job for the Soviets after the troops had shot down the peoples in 1968.

There have been demands for democracy and freedom for a long time in Eastern Europe. That demand is not a bourgeois concept. it is a workers' demand.

It began among the British workers in the 1830s, with the Chartists, and it is the demand everywhere where workers want their rights. The South African black workers demand the right to vote and independent trade unions. The Chilean workers demand the right to real democratic votes. The Spanish workers demanded it under Franco. It is the demand of workers throughout the world.

During the upsurge in Eastern Europe, the demands were for free elections, free trade unions, workers' control of industry, more thàn one political party, free publications, freedom of speech, freedom to meet and demonstrate, etc.

Clearly, the Haggle in these countries has taken on different forms. In Poland the Roman Catholic church, which remained a powerful force, played a significant role. Solidarity originally was a workers' organisation, very much influenced by Catholic social teaching. But, I stress, it was a workers' organisation, and the church members, mainly workers, adhered to it.

In Hungary the church played only a minor role. In the main the move for democracy and freedom came from within the Party, backed by working writers and intel intellectuals. In but led by Czechoslovakia again the intellectuals were involved but recently the workers have become involved. They have become decisive.

In East Germany the workers were involved from the early days, and it must be remembered that it was building workers who led the revolt in East Berlin in 1953.

To understand the situation thoroughly in East Germany one should read Heinz Brandt's The Third Way. He was a Communist put in jail by the Nazis - a Communist who sided with the government of East Germany but nevertheless was put in jail by the East German regime. It is a profound book and should be studied by all serious socialists.

The upsurge in Eastern Europe began not from below, but because the Soviet bureaucracy has split. One section, a section growing over the years from the time of! Khrushchev, accepts that the problems of production in the Soviet Union cannot be solved unless there are changes of a democratic nature. The old bureaucratic system is no longer adequate.

That does not mean that they wish to entirely get rid of the socialised basis of industry and the services, but that it is essential to initiate and that must mean some competition at least among publicly-owned industries. Bureaucratic and is a tota Planning has failed flop. It also means that money must be found by ending the enormous defence expenditure. That is why Gorbachev is keen to get rid of nuclear and other weapons.

Turn to page 11

----- pull-quotes -----

a stimulating analysis of the spectacular

democracy and freedom for a long

bourgeois concer is a workers' demand"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 429

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →