Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why Not

Socialist Organiser no. 426, 30 November 1989 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 2,009 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Lessons for today So what are the lessons are Firstly, it's important to remember that even badly conceived and bureaucratically executed campaigns can generate a momentum and level of activity of their own which can quite quickly take events out the complete control of national officials. Bill Jordan take note.

Secondly, a good push from the stewards with regular report backs and mass meetings can build up a momentum behind the campaign. This is what the Sheffield stewards did. And in 1979, the first stages of the campaign were less hopeful than this year, for instance, the turn out on the lobby of the EEF in April this year was double that in '79.

So the current campaign needs to be taken back to the districts and the workplaces. Regular LELASS meetings need to start now while the campaign is in the upswing. A national Confed stewards conference would give a great boost to this.

Thirdly, national action, even designed in the way it was in '79 can quickly generate a level of solidarity much greater than the localised guerilla tactics adopted today and in '72 (see last week's SO). That's why a one day national Confed strike would give such a boost to today's campaign.

Finally we saw in "79 glimpses of what a well organised rank and file movement can do to take control of events. Many of the Sheffield stewards and others who got some rank and file co-ordination off the ground and who organised the flying pickets were often members of the Broad Left, and sometimes the smaller more left wing, Engineer's Charter. But at no point did the rank and file have a powerful enough unofficial movement.

The National Shop Stewards Movement the Sheffield stewards tried to launch after the strike didn't flourish. The Communist Party, which was the biggest single political force on the left in engineering at the time, was too tied into the union bureaucracy and didn't have the politics necessary to build such a movement in time of recession and ruling class offensive. Their only answer to the threat of iob losses was reactionary talk of import controls' policy that could only set engineering workers from different countries against each other at a time when the employers were organising and centralising themselves across national boundaries.

In the 1980s Jimmy Airlie, the leading AEU official closely associated with the CP, has moved so far to the right that he was the architect of the AU's proposal for a single-union, no-strike deal with Ford at Dundee.

The much smaller Socialist Workers Party could not fill the gap left by the CP. Not least because they were in the process of giving up serious trade union work and transforming themselves into a single issue Leave the Labour Party' campaign.

Within two years they closed down 'Engineer's Charter' and pushed the line that nothing much could be done in engineering until there was an economic 'upturn' The left in engineering never really linked up with the left in the Labour Party which in 1979 was on the rise. Duffy, Boyd and Chapple were not so one-sided, they mobilised and organised to defeat the Bennite Left'.

If the left had linked up the political and industrial struggles then we might have been able to put up a co-ordinated challenge to the Thatcher government.

The engineers' demand for a 35 hour week, with no loss of pay, could have been taken up across the movement as a whole and put forward as part of our answer to the economic crisis. But this never happened.

The Thatcherites triumphed and whole areas of the basic manufacturing were destroyed forever. Millions were put onto the dole.

Now ten years later, with Thatcher looking weak, a co-ordinated push across industry for a 35 hour week could give a real cutting edge to the reviving industrial militancy.

At least it would make Duffy and Boyd turn in their graves.

Invite strikers meeting All districts are urged to invite striking members to local meetings and rallies. They will inspire members in your area and help boost funds. Contact the appropriate district secretary: Alwyn Rowlands (for Chester) - 0248 362098; Len Brindle (for Preston) -0772 57765; Tony Berry (for Cheltenham) - 0242 517488; Les Elliott (for Kingston) - 01 587 1831; and John Carty (for Glasgow Hillington) - 041 248 7131. (From the CSEU information bulletin) unions] in East Germany? Is it just an instrument of the party? Or does it defend the interests of the working class, if only partially?

The FDGB plays a role, certainly: that of a big welfare service.

It runs the whole social security system, pensions, sick pay, family benefit... administers the building and management of public housing for workers, and organises summer holiday trips.

It is known for these functions, and that is why workers look to it.

But as regards our interests, our wages, and our working conditions, in general and in each workplace, i would say without hesitation that this 'trade union' is nothing of the sort.

Our wages are fixed by agreements at national level for the general framework, and for each workplace in detail. They are, if I can dare to use the word, negotiated between the State, i.e. the party, and the FDGB.

! have never, ever heard of the union applying pressure on our behalf. It takes note of what the State feels like giving us, that's all.

In my workplace the working conditions are particularly bad. There is a lot of noise, emissions of noxious substances, and high temperatures. The union couldn't care less.

As regards the demand for a bonus for dirty work, I heard a trade union official complaining that we always wanted to earn more. It was a foreman, and not the union, who discovered that the management were not paying us the legal wage.

How is the FDGB organised? Don't you have the possibility of electing seople you trust to union positions!

The shop stewards are elected by their units and work brigades. Theoretically it is possible to elect people whom we trust and who will dare to open their mouths. But, in practice, few people want to stand in the elections. People have to be pushed into it. It's not surprising possibilities open to these shop when reckon that the stewards amount to the right to grumble.

The trade union full-timers in the workplace are appointed from above, and the trade union committee is elected on the basis of an imposed list. The last trade union fullstraight out of the party schoca timers workplace came But despite everything, it seems that the rate of unionisation is very high in East Germany.

True. It's about 98 per cent, l think. People don't join the union to fight for their interests, but for the reasons I've mentioned before.

You can't avoid the union. And besides, you can get into trouble if you don't join. Very often, you join the union compulsorily when you start at a workplace. With your left hand you sign your labour contract, and with your right hand the union membership form.

Apart from the pension and sickpay funds, how are the welfare services financed which the _union runs?

By State subsidies on the one hand, and union dues on the other. In your appeal, you say that the FDGB has never demanded a reduction in working time. What is the vorking week in East Germany!

As I've already said, the FDGE has never mobilised on any problem, The normal working week in ani forty yoars,- whet hen ni tha working week esı a perenent : demand• tp tackor nagmeni Wal ma no mobi sed with up. orshe fort nour week?

Has it acted to got our wagos inexec Lto ihladen il Prop ton nor, Bermetss hegotleherdi ald tho oGe ofle hen howispeedrups ero тровес che tackoryi Aro khoy ph ou sider Do they stop now MOP! norms being Imposed before there ailaraee of corresponding wage rises?

How can the FDGB tolerate the Tao ner on everare we naveer days leas paid hollday than our col leagues in the West?

FDGB demanded • eduction ofthe retirement agor Heme we over soon thi vorkplace union leadership acting have we over seen the union win mihing or un nt he se nå against themperty?

Fokt yonre yithoyt apy meg!

tencopt pur interestaln enongh Ne shpulfi got ilet purserven! P organiseni envlonapr. nemen byı tipcent amen- Wei ishpuid- domit ourselves.

The next fow years will not be Gas. Tno want to saueeze us. Prices will rise, but not wages hen subs irlies on cur, it hre con Becuences The State demands more productivity. Soon it will threaten us with sackings.

We need representatives nour ou istendard lof livingı wifl decline.

Organise genoralie spemblies and demand khac newvorkblace ureen leadership gives an aCCOUnT O itself.

Elect colleagues from your ranks as spokespeopie. * Demende hong collimpr ernee hey i take • your ı demende. costhe Protect those colleagues If they have problems!

Publish the results. That is a means of protection aginst TooriBaIS Seok contact with colleagues in other workplaces.

Form independent trade unionsl For information, and SubDon nuawve u ungonane Gewerkschaften Klub, ConradBlanke Straße 1, 1055 Berlin proposed and adopted a law to haven't heard a word.

years ago, When it fixed the length cancelled all supplementary from the union.

fion to West Germany, the new litie is "You don't think that we can"cut of labour"

It is true, though, thitthe for a mobilisation for a cut in he working week. A recent . stdy minutes of the working day there are only five hours of ritual Tankcessible.

Today the whole system is massively challenged. How FDGB standing up?

We don't have a network of information connecting different workplaces, so my picture is incomplete. But I do know that there are collective resignations from the union, and workers refusing to pay their union dues if the union continues to tag along with the government.

The leadership has dropped Tisch, the former general secretary, and trade unions in different industries have sacked their leaders and replaced them by new faces. The FDGB has not postponed its conference as it was intending to. All that is not an accident. It is due to the pressure from inside the union and from the streets. Your appeal is not the first initiative towards creating independent trade unions. What do you know about the others? Do you have the impression that a significant section of workers understand the need for independent trade unions.

Through the bulletin Telegraph, published by the Umweltsbibliothek [Environment Library, and by word of mouth, we have heard of several initiatives. Unfortunately, the party's absolute monopoly on the means of information prevents us from getting a clear picture.

I tried to go and see the contact who was given in the Telegraph. The worker in question had been transferred to Bulgaria at top speed. That shows clearly that we are hitting the system at a sensitive point.

In any case, we'll see. We see our group as an initiating group which anus the independence necessing for a trade union and which seeks contact with other groups of workers who want to break with the present policy of the FDGB. The organisation of a challenge to the system in the workplaces has lagged. behind the political mobilisationx We need to catch upy Do you think you have at least small groups of worter inde can count on?

Absolutely. Low|s it toeror making contact, betaus MainEve no horizonial structure between workplaces that enable us to find each other.

Until now our wit been dominated. tear -1a te stren th you could lose your job. A lot of sidered any precautions as a step inissary awarmesake thus. Hister izst. We are g theigh a - must be ve myself for losing it slip. It's mothere been waiting for Owed from the French ist weekly Rouge.

Scan page 10

Indictir

----- pull-quotes -----

she bGBl donenes us Hes It pat the demend form cuk

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 426

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →