Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Quotas for women - or quotas for the media? roted in support of

Socialist Organiser no. 426, 30 November 1989 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,830 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

miners' strike, that its voice was in- impress Typindits, to merely distinguishable from that of the alienate the vor wore maLing da Tory establishment. If we do not on benefit or struggling in their demand a representative voice for union, whose concerns should be women, this could well happen in the co cernbet-ail in the Labour relation of the next attack on our art, lamen and men.

in order to market them to the trade WOMEN'S union and labour leadership, they FIGHTBACK there as a tokenistic gesture to fool 2.

rightful place, reflecting the D political contribution they make to DON:

Crazy. Logically, it is built upon the guilt-tripping idea that a second old foetus (which may be ejected 3 days later from the womb) is a baby. It isn't. Like every sperm and ovum it carries the potential for human life.

Such research as has already been carried out has brought joy to women who thought they were infertile. If the research is carried on it may be possible to detect conditions which necessitate late abortions such as severe foetul abnormality It may also be possible to detect diseases like sickle cell anaemia which cause tremendous pain and suffering and even eradicate them altogether. Such things would be major steps forward — who would ask for the return of TB?

The point is not that the research should be stopped by that it should be controlled. Any such research is open to abuse in more ways than one, We know for example, that in some societies female foetuses are. aborted. We know that money may be spent on trying to eradicate ing spent on improving the lives of disabled people here and e We know that much research will Se on the production of profit-making drugs at the expense of set but profitless discoveries.

We also have cause to fear medical science as we discover more about vivisection.

The problem with the Embryo Research Bill is that it will not place the discoveries within the reach of everyone. The legislation should ensure that only socially necessary research is carried out, and that its results are not abused for profit but used for art humanity This year's Labour Party conference quotas' for women - but who gets to decide which wome Nadine Finch of the Socialist Movement looks behind the feminist gloss To read the reaction of some erstwhile luminaries of the Left, whose views grace the pages of Tribune most weeks, you would think that the Left had won solid support for a range of issues around defence, equality for women and recognition of the black and lesbian and gay communities? rights. They must surely have been at another conference from the rest of us.

Defending policy to acknowledge that lesbians and gay men had the same legal rights as others in the community or that a socialist party should spend resources on welfare not nuclear arms is scarcely progressive. Similarly, allowing the NEC to formulate a quota system to increase women's representation is a very far cry from an acknowledgement of women's autonomous voice within party.

As socialists we should be can paigning to ensure that all sectior of the community - women, blac people, the Irish, people wit disabilities and lesbians and ga men - have a representative voic But representation has to be ti operative word.

Somehow over the last few veal the clarity and militancy of women's demands within the part for the right to elect their ow representatives to the NEC, to t able to submit five resolution representing the key issues fc women in the party to annual col ference, and for a recognition of th wide range of political work in th party by women, has bee dissipated.

demand have become unrecognisable to the wards and GCs for them.

Yes, we want women on the the liberal media. We want them there, firstly because that is their the party. But, perhaps more significantly, we want them there to represent the unheard voice of women in the party.

Women's reproductive rights, their views on unilateralism and Ireland and their experience of the welfare state and employment are not accurately reflected by the present leadersmip. une danger is tnat if we accept this status quo with the addition of a small quota of women (which is undoubtedly what we will be offered) it will continue to be unrepresented.

We should remember that the Labour Party, created to represent the views of working people, was so far removed at a leadership level from those same people during the reproducuve nguise wage or immigration tomato We need to renewas come for a Labour Women Raisation that reflects the concerns...of working class and localizesen and insist that the abor /storship gives that. are katie dress sense and goad lonte micht SCRIBE Nawa's Bahtback delivered to your Most. Hates: 22.50 for 12 i £1.50 for eix.

MaSS.

Fease send me 6/12 months' subscrip tica. I enclose E...

Rend to Wemen's Fightback, PO Box 823, Londor: SE15 4NA

Scan page 8

The call amongst feminists for the banning of pornography would not actually lead to its disappearance, and would not achieve the desired effects of liberating women from the oppression which they face in our society.

Ruth Cockroft is right to argue against such a ban, but the only reason which feminists and socialists should do so is on the grounds that such censorship would give tremendous power to the state. This power would inevitably be abused so that instead of having a liberating effect on women, the capitalist state would censor feminist, lesbian and gay literature, sex education material, etc.

But I feel the fundamental mistake which Ruth makes is to go from a position of being against the banning of pornography to one which justifies its existence and even looks at it in a positive light.

Ruth argues that many women have "not had the courage to speak up for a more liberal attitude to pornography, and a more sophisticated understanding of what it represents" . Since when have we, as socialists, wanted a more liberal attitude to anything?

Most feminists are not afraid to speak out on the issue of pornography, but a liberal attitude towards it is really just the dominant male attitude to it.

Nor do we need a more sophisticated understanding of pornography. We certainly do have to examine what pornography is and what it represents in our society, but this does not call for sophistication, merely an ordinary, everyday way of looking at the world.

My definition of pornography certainly does not include such literature as Mills and Boon, and even if there were any evidence for the switch from sentimental porn to less romanticised porn for women, I would not view this as progressive.

A feminist campaign against pornography would mean a certain shared ground with right-wing bigots like Victoria Gillick and Mary Whitehouse, but there is a big difference between sharing a hatred of pornography, and sharing a campaign of activity against it.

We must never let our politics be dictated by those of our enemy; Thatcher supported Solidarnosc in their struggle for trade union rights, and supported the democracy movement among students and workers in China, but that does not mean that we have to plan joint activities with the Tories around such The comparison which Ruth makes between pornography and fascism is not a valid one. She uses the term "fascism' as interchangeable with 'racism' - but fascism entails much more than the oppression of black people, it is the destruction of all workers' organisations in a different form of society. The fact that people do not see pornography as as bad as racist literature is a reflection of the dominant ideology in our society, not proof that pornography is in some way progressive.

Pornography is about power; power used to degrade and humiliate women. It is a retlection of the wide oppression of women under capitalism, and reinforces that oppression.

It is certainly a fact that some women are consumers of porIAID "Normal', everyday images of women nography, but the appeal that it holds for them is not about positively exploring their sexuality; it is a reflection of the dominant male values about what their sexuality should be.

Some feminists have started to explore the relationship of women to pornography, such : Marion Bower in 'Feminist Review' (1986). Bower discusses women's responses to pornography as in some way an expression of their own sexuality, and by using psychoanalysis, she examines what porn really means to women. She does not conclude, with Ruth, that changing the present porn market would lead to pornography of an equal sexuality, but argues that:

*Rather than providing some ultimate form of equality with men, [pornography for women] is simply a shared form of personal alienasexist and offensive tion. I suspect that it will increase, but let us not delude ourselves that it is liberating or 'different'"

We must not deny that women are sexual beings, we must not feel guilty about our own sexuality. But, as socialists, we should not want anyone to have power over anyone else. That is ultimately what pornography is all about; power - not sex.

We must not confuse the issue of banning pornography with the issue of being against it. It is perfectly consistent to be against the censorship of pornography, and to think it is a totally bad thing. This is not to label women who enjoy pornography as 'collaborators' but to undertand what pornography represents in our society, and whose interests it really serves.

Julia Coulton, Manchester Manchester Area NEIS convenor The first major event of ow academic year for the Nut nai Union of Students Women's Campaign was helc on November 10.

Women's Officers Day posit opportunity for student Union Women's Officers, and iot: women involved in student unions, to get together, discuss the issie, plan the campaigns and learn the skills. Disappointingly, was another opportunity wasted:

Much of the pitch of the eupt was entirely on the wrong intel 'How to set up a Women's Groug advised women to book a meeting room in their student. union building, invite a big nametspeaker and claim a sizeable slice of the union's societies budget. Not inch use for the majority of women students those in Furtser Education colleges, whose student unions manage on limited funding and facilities, and certainly: coit inhabit their own buildings Strong, active, women's groups can be built in these colleges, built on campaigns for basic rights and facilities for women. Campaigning issues can range from parsery provision and women's sainty to soft toilet paper ant machines.

Off I went to the dirtien ou

----- pull-quotes -----

very women who had fought in the NE WON'T PAY NEC, but we don't want them to be THE POLL TEN

disabling diseases, which is good but that should not stop money be-

space to speak from Macad of hand-picking women whose

Another opportunity wasted

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 426

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →