Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The dangers of exaggeration

Socialist Organiser no. 426, 30 November 1989 · scan pp. 4–6 · about 1,510 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

As the action started to fray at the edges in some areas, the exaggerated arguments that certain people used to motivate the com-. pletely correct call for all-out action - that the current strikes were too limited, weak, inefficien! even pointless — tended to play into the hands of hardened opponents of the strike who were organising to break the action. Workers who were by no means hardened scabs would say things like I would come out if it was all-out, crossed lines.

This underlines how careful socialists in the unions need to be in assessing how what they are saying interacts with what other forces, who may have very different interests, are saying. Sadly, in some instances in "79, the well intentioned posturings of the ultra left provided some sort of justification for those who to give up. ed claim and their own supplementary demands.

The two day strikes start to bite as September goes on. The fight gets more bitter. Flying pickets are used to great effect in Scotland and West Yorkshire. Other groups come out in all-out action as strikers refuse to work alongside scabs or touch scab work.

At one Rolls plant a single picket A Tory voter) prevents the entire workforce from breaking the strike.

Sensing the gap opening up between the rank and file and right wine national officials and with one back hard. manage compar Nego employ Frank threate Confed ballot ‹ ing thei Duffy himself But! too. TI the FT "Fi

Scan page 5

embryo research, the pornography debate, quotas for women, We must also try to broadcast Monday 4 December comber Women's rights to choose when to bear children is under attack again. The anti-abortion lobby, is to have another go at the 1967 Act which gives women the right to have a legal abortion up to 28 weeks of pregnancy, with the permission of two doctors.

It is likely that when the Embryo Research Bill comes up in Parliament later this year 3 amendments will be tabled to reduce the upper time limit for abortions to 24, 22 and 20 weeks respectively.

That in the words of leading antiabortionist Anne Widdecombe (quoted in this week's Observer) is only the beginning: "If we bring the limit down to 22 weeks... then we will have broken the Act, and I will consider myself very well satisfied. Then I can get on with the rest of the business.

The 'business' is to chip away at the 1967 Act, at first using apparently reasonable 'medical' evidence, then moving on to the moral bludgeon. Organisations like SPUC which support all attacks on the '67 Act are anti-all abortion, even in the case of rape, or severe foetal abnormality.

They believe a full-frontal attack would fail, so choose instead, the bit-by-bit approach, figuring that the Act is 'broken' other once "breaks' will follow.

The most likely reduction in the time limit is to 24 weeks. This is because late abortions are an easy target for the anti-abortion lobby!

The foetus is in some exceptional cases capable of independent life at 24 weeks, 4 weeks earlier than when the limit was set in 1967. Consequently only a very few abortions are carried out after 20 weeks. The 'date of conception' is always just an estimate and it is only accurate to 4 weeks anyway so a 28 week limit, as now, means a 24 week limit in reality. Only 22 late abortions were carried out last year and 18 of those were for severe foetal abnormality.

1o reduce the time limit to 24 weeks would effectively outlaw those abortions, and condemn those women to months if not years of misery, bearing babies incapable of life, in the full knowledge of what will happen. Yet, anti-abortionists talk of late each year, all for 'social' reasons. The truth would win far fewer converts to their reactionary cause.

If the abortion amendments reach the House of Commons, MPs will be given a 'free vote' ', ie one not bound by party policy. This is isually invoked for matters ol "conscience' like hanging.

In fact the Labour Party comprehensive policy on abortion. Labour Party conference voted for the defence and extension of the 1967 Act. It should not be a matter of 'conscience' at all when what is at stake is the overwhelming needs of the millions of women who will need abortions in the future, and who will either get them legally or at the hands of backstreet abortionsists.

Nor is it a matter of one person's consience' when the Labour Party has democratically decided on a pro-choice policy. The idea of 'conscience' makes a mockery of Labour Party democracy All Labour MPs should be voting in line with Party policy - we did not put them into parliament to vote with their 'conscience' in questions like housing or unemployment and abortion should be no different. All three are issues affecting the lives of working class people.

The anti-abortionists' campaign will be well-funded and professional. SPUC estimates it will have to spend £200,000, £50,000 of which will come from one manproperty 'developer' Geoffrey Bradman.

SPUC's money will be spent on emotive propaganda and glossy advertisements in the national press. They will concentrate on guilt and generalities rather than facts, with the sort of (untrue) stories which make every woman seeking abortion seem like a feckless, convenience-seeker and every doctor who helps her a money grabbing accomplice to murder.

The pro-choice campaign will be somewhat different. It will be made up of thousands of ordinary women who know the real facts about abortion.

Like the recent FAB campaign, we will have to get all those people who agree with a woman's right to choose to come out and say so.

But unlike the FAB campaign, we won't be able to use parliamentary tactics to defeat the Widdecombe amendment. As an amendment to a government bill, will be guaranteed debating time. The only way we will be able to defeat this latest attack is by building a mass, broad campaign, involving trade union support.

However, while it is vital that we mobilise to prevent the lowering of time limits, we musn't forget that the Embryo Research Bills has other implications for our We must campaign for the right of lesbians and single women to have AID; for the right of black women not to have abortions, or forced sterilisations or be used as guinea pigs for drugs such as Depo Provera. must ensure that Inside: m nsid ore on otas for wome for plus lots more lots CHURCH and SA E ould not research on life-threatening diseases support for a woman's right t*includes those that affect abortion, and to encourage them fo * predominantly black people - like join the campaign. sickle cell anaemia. • Pressure on Labour MPs toL And we should be fighting to en- vote in line with Party Pollus. sure that women who do want abor- • Lots of petitions, demonstra-- ip the Amendment tions have access to adequate itions and letter writing to 'undecid- Campaign facilities. ed' MPs to show that just because We will need to build a big, we don't have huge donatins from meeting broad, militant campaign involving industrialists we dal Tate minive 7.0pm trade unions, students, tenants' support from "womeh associations and every group where women are organised. Organising meetings have already campaign so that it rentert for extending the 157 chattan mails LSE, Heughton St begun, initiated by the National current attack is deterict Abortion Campaign. Get involved! • We mus use grape Our campaign should include: Women for Sacial er which have • A campaign amongst trade developed recently to k.. savene in unions to win them to a position of the labour mg mise LAT

Scan page 6

YESIYES!. VES Sigrid That was the title of a successful called in response to the latest attack on women's right to abortion that 'pro-life' MPs are waging in connection with the Embryo Research Bill that is being presented in Parliament.

With the debate raging yet again around the legal time limit for abortion - and the anti-abortionists' aim of cutting it from 28 to 24 - or even 18 weeks - women are yet again having to fight for the right to control our own bodies and our own fertility.

The speaker, Claire Standring, emphasised that the fight is not just about the right to have safe, legal and free abortions, but about the right to choose. And that means real choice, including the right to choose to go ahead with a pregnancy, knowing their are adequate facilities.

Faced with the prospect of isolation, . poverty, lack of childcare facilities, and many forms of discrimination, women can find that abortion is the only option. It is not a decision made easily.

Lesbian women who want NO I NOT Di YES.

O CH yesli our br TI NOI INO sale early ortions ABORTION YES AS POSSIBLE AS LATE TO ALTO:

----- pull-quotes -----

Women for Socialism meeting held in Newcastle last week,

S EARLY 1S POSSIBLE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 426

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →