Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The querrilla line isn't fine guerrilla

Socialist Organiser no. 425, 23 November 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 1,833 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Paul Adams discusses there believed that our Hughie" the lessons of the would back them to the hilt.

The Confed leaders had broken 1972 engineering off their negotiations with the EEF dispute on December 15 1971, after the employers had only offered £1.50 in T the AEU by the right-wing he present domination of reply to the unions demand for a "substantial increase" with more might tempt some people for women as a step towards equal to look back on the ten years of pay, a 35-hour week (yes, 1/ years ago!), and extra (fourth) week's Hugh Scanion's leadership of holiday and other lesser items. the engineering union as days of It soon became clear that there a glory now gone. would be no call for a strike from In reality, however, the problems the national leaders. Scanlon's call faced by the engineers then were for plant bargaining on the basis of very much the same as the ones they district-organised action covered up face now. their refusal to fight the employers.

In 1968, the year the left took Other leftists covered up in turn for control of the leadership of the Scanlon. Executive Committee union, tens of thousands of militant member and leading Maoist Keg engineers expected to be led into Birch praised Scanion'S strategy battle against their employers in a and the Maoist paper The Worker great national strike. A date was carried the idiotic headline, 'Our set...but there was no strike. At the Guerilla Line Suits Us Fine' last moment there was an agree- In Manchester the Confed ment between the Confederation ef stewards held their first meeting at Shipbuilding and Engineering the end of February 1972. They Unions (the Confed), represents decided unanimously to go onto the workers and the • Engineering Lay-work. (The Manchester Employers" Federation. picrework agreement allowed The agreement was a full-blown engineers to go onto day-work [as productivity deal tied up in a three- distinct from piecework] by request year package deal: a total disaster. and still receive the basic rate of For three years, rank and file pay. In practice that meant taking militants in engineering fought a the basic rate in exchange for no guerilla strategy against the imposi- work at all): tion of the productivity elements The district braced itself for a which had been agreed in principle fight against lock-outs, as it was at national level. When negotiations clear that employers would shut started for a new national deal in down factories where the workers 1971, many were eager for a fight. insisted on their right to go onto The timing was not exactly day-work. Lock-outs were to be perfect: during the first three mon- fought by sitting in. ths of 1971 there was a 21% fall in The Manchester area workers overseas engineering orders and a were so eager that the first occupa6% fall in home orders. It was tion started a full fortnight before estimated that the industry in the scheduled beginning of daygeneral was working at 15 to 20% work. The workers at Bredbury below capacity. But that was all less steel works started their sit-in on important than the will of many March 16. As soon as news of the militants to force the bosses to pay sit-in got around, other firms' up substantial increases now that stewards turned up with messages there was a left-wing leadership. of support and went back to their There was no leadership from factories to urge bringing the action Scanlon. Instead there was the forward. In fact, the Stockport pseudo-democratic cover-story: District Committee brought its *We are waiting for the rank and sanctions forward by a week. file to show the way! Manchester Within a week, 5,000 of the was an obvious place for the attack 15,000 engineers in Stockport were on the employers to start. It was a at least working to rule. key engineering area pretty solidly While workers throughout the dominated by the Communist Par- district were organising sit-ins in ty. More important still, it was response to lock-outs imposed by the bosses, the trickle of settlements Scanlon country. The militants started. The local union leadership refused to make them public, but it soon became clear that some of them were absurdly low. The apparent militancy of the actions was nt matched by the level of the claims.

The sit-ins continued to be triggered by lock-outs throughout early April. On 1 April, for instance, there were sit-ins at 11 factories; on 12 April, at 23. On that day Scanlon visited Manchester, but the most important news was that there was a sit-in in Sheffield, the other traditional centre of engineering militancy in England, and a decision in Aberdeen to emulate Manchester. The sit-in movement continued.

But, with no national lead, Sheffield and Aberdeen did not follow suit, nor did the shipbuilding centres, the Midlands, or anywhere else.

By mid-May, the AUEW leadership had clearly decided the struggles should stop. Scanlon obviously felt he had done enough to keep his leftist credentials, while the rightwing got what it wanted: the isolation of Scanlon's stronghold.

On 15 May the Confed called a big stewards' meeting in Manchester. For the first time the rightwing were represented: the GECAEI-EE stewards were there courtesy of the company, an army in dark blue donkey jackets with the firm's name stamped on the back.

The central feature of this meeting was the reading out of a circular from the union leadership which in effect said "drop the struggle for shorter hours and accept money-only deals". Even the Morning Star, usually a fan magazine for Scanlon and the AUEW leaders, managed to admit: "They [the workers] have not been greatly assisted by the circular."

With the right-wing there and with many of the left whipped into line by the Communist Party -almost all the AUEW officials were CP members - the acceptance of the circular was ensured. Still, a third of the meeting voted againsi it. Everyone knew now that the signal had been given to wind down the action.

By 25 May there were only 13 firms sitting in and settlements were generally low: £2.50 plus 50p productivity bonus at Mirrlees, f2 plus some minor elements at Ferranti.

Meanwhile, nowever, the strike wave threatened to spread to London, where there was a sit-in at Stanmore Engineering. So far the Manchester struggle had been isolated as well as internally fragmented. Now, however, the chance was at hand to spread the strike to the vital North and West London districts.

At a big stewards' meeting in London Scanlon praised the courage of the Manchester strikers and recommended their example. When he was attacked for not leading a national action, Scanion again claimed that in a democratic union it was up to the rank and file to lead. The left backed Scanlon, covering up the truth of the isolation in Manchester and the sell-out on the hours question.

Worst of all, the Stanmore men, when they demanded that they get full backing and that the strike be spread to London were told that they had "jumped the gun" . The isolation of Manchester was now complete; it was clear there would only be isolated actions in London.

The result was clear: at a time of unprecedented militancy in the engineering industry, the leadership had refused to call for national action and allowed the most militant area to be battered by a very determined and well-organised section of employers in the Manchester area. Before long the Communist Party suffered defections among its leading lights, the officials in the Manchester area.

The lessons for today are clear. So long as the negotiations were on a factory by factory basis, the superficial look of unity suggested by the mass of similar actions was shot through with divisions that the employers could play on.

And secondly, given the strength of the engineering employers — and despite skill shortages and full order books, like "72 - they are no pushover today; even very militant action like the sit-ins of "72 will not lead to full-scale victory if the action is not properly co-ordinated nationally.

With the EEF saying that they are no longer prepared to accept national negotiations the Confed should be preparing for all-out action to force the employers back to national negotiations and to concede the full claim. World end to reject and redo petite Progesterone, produced ovaries and placenta, seems to suppress this tendency by binding to the cells and inhibiting them. the womb but it binds so tighty that RU486 has a similar shape to the womb but it binds so tightly that progesterone cannot get look in. Jnlike progesterone, RU486 does.not inhibit the cells which then get on with the business of rejecting the newly implanted embryo. The drug is taken by mouth and is followed.two days later by a dose of a prostaglandin capable of inducing contractions of the womb. In a few hours, the womb expels the embryo and placenta.

As in a normal menstruation, there can be cramps, nausea and diarrhoea. Rarely, with some spontaneous miscarriages, there Call be severe bleeding, necessitating a blood transfusion.

Several trials of RU486 have taken place in Britain and France, mostly with women who were less than 9 weeks pregnant. The success rate in terms of complete abortions (ie. requiring. surgical follow-up) were 95%.

The advantages of RU486 are manifold. In Britain, it would allow women requiring NHS abortions to have them that much sooner as they would not have to wait for a bed to become available. It would probably not be any safer as abortions in Britain are already about as safe as they can be. In fact, it is more dangerous to have a baby.

On a world scale, though, RU486 could play a major role in reducing the estimated toll of 200,000 deaths women from illegal or unsafe abortions. Of course, it could also make money for Roussel-Uclaf./ It might seem strange, therefore, for the company to withdraw the drug from sale just one month after launching it in France last year. In explanation, thecompany cited threats of boycott from anti-abortionists, fear of litigation and pressure from Hoechst. The minister of health instructed Roussel-Uclat to resume sales, saying that RU486 had become the "moral property of It might also seem strange that the company is being less than speedy in applying for licences in other countries such as Britam but the key is the statement by Hoechst's president that RU486 does not conform to Hoechst's "ethics""

Hilger's opposition to abortion appears likely to deny West German women access to RU486. Elsewhere, Roussel-Uclaf say they want individual governments to invite them to apply for licences. This unusual procedure is. said to be because Roussel-Uclaf "does not want to interfere with this debate on abortion".

But, as New Scientist said in an editorial recently, any debate on abortion in this country is about whether to allow abortion at all and not over which methods to allow.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 425

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →