Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Police arrest victim of racist attack

Socialist Organiser no. 425, 23 November 1989 · scan pp. 8–9 · Vicki Morris · about 1,891 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

crutches for about six months due to a knee injury 'fell ill' during a conversation with a police surgeon.

A Chief Sperintendant Humber said that Edwin Carr was been attended to by a doctor and became unwell and later became unconscious. One report gave the cause of death from the (police) post-mortem as pneumonia due to respiratory failure.

Yet the same report, apparently seen by a black community worker, revealed that Edwin had suffered an epileptic fit followed by a heart atworkers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.

We stand:

For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class-based women's movement.

Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.

For equality for gays.

For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.

For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.

For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.

We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.

When a nine-months pregnant woman is savagely beaten in her own home and her brother is the victim of an attempted racist murder, we expect the police to act. So what do the police do? They arrest an innocent man and let his attackers go free.

For years the Khan family in Manor Park, Newham were harassed by racist neighbours living opposite and next door. On 3 August at 8pm these neighbours attacked Mrs Khan and her niece with bicycle chains and dustbin lids. Mrs Khan was repeatedly punched and kicked in the stomach - she was nine months pregnant at the time.

Mrs Khan and her niece managed to scramble back into their home but the attackers then smashed the windows with rocks and chanted "Paki bastards, go back to where you came from!"

The Khans rang the police and the attackers responded by cutting the telephone wire. The police did not arrive. When Mrs Khan's brother, Mr Altaf, happened to come by, he was immediately atttacked by six of the men wielding iron bars and wooden clubs.

When he staggered into the house, the men broke down the door and one of them grabbed Mr Altaf from behind and then tried to stab him.

Mr Altaf avoided the knife and the racist thug accidentally stabbed one of his fellow attackers instead. Many of the neighbours were watching and did nothing.

At this point the police arrived. When Mr Altaf explained what had happened, they told him 'shut your bloody mouth' and arrested him, leaving the racist attackers free to go home. Mr Altaf has been charg ed with Malicious Wounding and the Khan family has been forced to leave ther council house and move into bed and breakfast accomodation.

Unfortunately this case is not unique in Newham, which has the highest reported number of racist attacks in the country. In a climate where racist attacks are on the increase, local campaigners demand to know:

* why is Mr Altaf facing a serious charge while his attackers remain free?

* how can the Khan family be driven out of their home while their attackers are left free to stay?

* what is the use of a police publicity campaign against racial harassment when the police let racist thugs go free and treat innocent black people under attack like criminals?

We demand that the charge against Mr Altaf is dropped and that his attackers are brought to justice and are evicted by the council.

You can help the campaign by:

* publicising the case of the Mr Altaf and the Khans.

* getting as many people as possi ble to sign the petition and sending them to the campaign.

* writing to the Chief Prosecutor Crown Prosecution Service, Solar House, 1-9 Romford Road, London Els, demanding that the charge against Mr Altaf be dropped.

* writing to the Director of Housing, 91 The Grove, London E15 demanding that the council evict the racists who attacked Mr Altaf and the Khans.

'Defend the ALon/oh family PO Box 273, 8151).

Scan page 9

an Hamill. Copyright MCMLXXXIX Touchstone Pictures. All rights reserved.

It's slight, but amusing and well done. The Three famous directors were asked to make enough of sickly-sentimental Jewish mother/ short films about New York - a city full of poverty, homelessness, despair, crime, drug: slums, collapsing public services and gross downright disgusting. It's about a smart-arse 13 year old rich girl, living in a luxury hotel and looked after by cheerily servile hotel staf circles of the well-off top ten percent or so. while her separated (but perhaps about to be under the joint title 'New York Stories' is Mar tin Scorsese's 'Life Lessons', about how a New York is when she gives some candy to a successful painter (played by Nick Nolte, pic- man living in a cardboard box outside her tured above) exploits his assistant/girlfriend hotel. And Coppola makes the film without Belinda Weaver 'Talk Radio' Talk Radio' is largely about one man. He's Barry Champlain, a late night radio talk show host in Dallas.

Made by Oliver Stone, who directed 'Wall Street' and "Salvador', , the film is based on the real life stroy of Allan Berg, a radio host who was murdered by antisemitic neo-nazis.

Watching, we know that Champlain will die, and this skews the story. Instead of a radio story about a rampant egotist plying his trade, we know instead that we're watching a doomed man dice with death. This gives the film a febrile, hyped-up quality.

All Stone's films have characters living on a knife edge, but "Talk Radio' goes further and deeper. It had a claustrophobic, panicky teel.

Champlain is not a nice person; there is no attempt to win our sympathy. His ego is well out of control, and so are his emotions. When something doesn't please him, he yells, and if he wants something, he pulls out every manipulative stop to get it.

He's not an ideologue. His responses to his callers come from the heart, not the head, and he's the same with the station bosses, his coworkers and his ex-wife. He's a kneejerk reactor, and a highly competitive one. If they say stop, he says go, and he has to win the contest. He needs constant reassurance that he's on top.

He has arrived at his position by way of his smart mouth; his put downs are famous. Some are clever, but most are just insult; he reviles his listeners as scumbags and Nazis and no-hopers. (Of course many of them are, but he denounces them instead of arguing).

Champlain stays on top because he's quicker witted than they are. He keeps things moving!

Most of his callers are right wing, anti-semitic, racist. Champlain abuses them, then cuts them off. He "New York Stories' inequality.

None of them have stepped, out of the The best of the three films being shown (played by Rosanna Arquette).

has one long rave about Jew haters, in which he spells out the reasons behind what they do: "When things go wrong, you all look for someone to blame" . That's the limit of his political analysis.

This is a very dark toned movie.

Champlain is a very tormented soul, self-destructiye, incapable of love or empatny, thrust into a public position he is ill-equipped to handle. His tame goes to his head, and he comes to see himself as invulnerable. His ego can never admit to fear or weakness.

I couldn't decide whether it was a sick-soul-of-America film, implying that freedom of speech will ultimately be punished by death, or a statement that minority groups will always have to live in fear.

trace of irony or detachment.

I'm still not sure about it all. I think Stone was probably drawn to the material by the character on a knife edge angle, and that it goes no deeper than one long, desparing look at the state of the nation. In one scene, Champlain lambasts his callers: 'The whole nation is listening, but you have nothing to say"

What the film has done is confirm my view of "No platform for fascists". Champlain, in allowing these scum on the airwaves, allowed them to parrot their poisonous views, and gave them a hearing same could be said for Woody Allen's "Oedipus Wrecks' - unless you've had Jewish boy comedies from this director.

Francis Coppola's 'Life Without Zoe' is reconciled) parents jet around the world.

Her only contact with the seamy side of which they shouid have been denied. Far from being grateful, they murdered him for it.

It's a shame we don't feel sorrier for Champlain. My strongest feeling was relief that it was all over and I could go home. It's not a bad movie, but a hopeless, tense, black one that leaves you feeling grim.

The performances are excellent, the atmosphere well done, but the feeling of hopelessness lingers. The tearing down of the Berlin Wall was a good antidote to that.

n the final episode of the latest series of 'Black Adder', our hero failed to dodge an appointment with the Grim Reaper.

He died on a battlefield of the First World War, most likely closing the final chapter in his jaunt through the history books.

This last series, charting Black Adder's experiences in the trenches, has been tragic, as well as comic, in a way that none of the others has been.

Of course 1 agreed with Rowan Atkinson that World War One was tragic. But he and I come at the subject from rather different directions, and draw different messages from it.

On the comedy side. the programmes had less word-play and absurd caricature of people from ages we hardly know about. As much as ever, we had the usual asinine grim humour poked upper-class twits, but for once they were twits from a generation we can relate to. gramme made a lot of the effect tragic side, that the stupidities of this class had in the war, fighting for years over a few yards of turf which rapidly became a hellish quagmire, and, sometimes, in the confusion, ordering their troops to fire on each other.!

This, however, seems to me to have been the least of their faults. The problem with the 'officer class' was that they caused the war, and made the working class fight it for them, to promote or defend their selfish nationalist and imperialist class interests.

Well you might think I'm being a bit po-faced about all of this. Most of "Black Adder' has consisted, after all, mainly of farce. It has offered little in the way of biting social comment. But if you saw the last poignant scenes of this final episode, it will have been obvious to you that Black Adder was, for once, probably Making A Point. I claim, therefore, the right to examine what it was, whether he made

----- pull-quotes -----

and V TV

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 425

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →