Saturday 27 January University of London Union, Malet St, London WC1
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
rickets, in advance, f8 (waged)/f4 (low wager From Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc (SWEB), 56 Kevan House, Wyndham Road, London SE5. Cheques to & students)/£2 (unwaged)
"Solidarity Conference"
• Stalls eveningFloor, ULU advance, f8 (waged)/£4 (low Leeds University), on the tradition of dissent in China • Lei Wei Ping (from Front for a Democratic China-UK) - an yemitne reportifton ananmerı Gunther tinnerye en German uniricatio tekün Sprietstudies tment, Gloegor Isis wen Poter Tatchell on the fight for lesbian and gay rights in Eastern Europe • Adam Novotny - workers and Yugoslavia • Bill Lomax on Hungarian workers in the 56 upt OTM why the our n HeTE workers md almost everyone sees as involving great contlict, they do not want to be continually patronised, especially from West Germany. They do not want to be always hearing from almost all the different forces how they see the political future of the GDR.
They say: if they want to criticise us and have an opinion, OK, that is their right, but please, not with this arrogance, and this inability to understand our own development, not with this penetrating repetition of their own concepts, when this is our affair. This attitude is very strong there.
The dynamic which has emerged in recent weeks and months has focused first on questions of participation and democracy. In what relation do you see these political demands to the economic problems?
It is very interesting that an economist who is very well respected in West Germany, Doris Cornelsen, emphasised one point again and again in a recent interneighbouring states at an economic level which makes possible a reform process in which the setting-free of popular participation, linked with structural economic reforms and decentralisation, can have an effect which makes possible a rise in productivity and perhaps also the maintenance of the independence of the GDR economy in a way that is not possible in other countries.
Of course there are a series of internal and external economic problems that are very difficult to solve. One is the problem of the GDR's shortage of foreign currency, and behind that stands the question of the possible or necessary convertibility of the GDR mark.!
Then there is the question: how far can or should be GDR move into the process of West European integration? Has it got a chance, if it wants to remain politically independent, of not visibly sumbitting to the logic of capitalism economics? In the West German press the views of the West German bourgeoisie are broadcast plainly: if a process of
Scan page 7
orm is introduced in the GDR, n it can only mean going back to ritalism and then, to a certain ex1, the GDR will fall to West Gern capital like a ripe fruit into its How do people in the GDR see o politically aware and consus people in the GDR, these nions are among the countless pidities about the GDR that you r in West Germany. n recent months we have heard even cruder description again I again: the GDR has had it, the ith are running away, the system eally on the brink of collapse. 'he latest line is this: yes, yes, the R oppositionists still talk about ialism. Either they know no betbecause they are so politically ve, or they really mean lething else, but tor the moment i can't say it.
wo models of argument work d in hand here. The exactly corjonding argument on the side of SED ideologists is Otto ahold's, who turned it upside vn: the GDR can only preserve dentity as a state if...and then he e a series of criteria, of what he erstands as socialism, but which criteria not of democratic alism but of the late Stalinistem.
I you pass that off as socialism, the only possible socialism, n it is clear that people will shun ke the plague. ¡ortunately there are enough ple in the GDR who can cut pugh these arguments. They say: te we want socialism, we must ke a serious break with this exng system. If this attitude apreads is on bith sits will be reduced to absurdity.
But it is no accident that these arguments mirror each other. There are direct interests working hand in hand here. However much the dominant political forces in West Germany polemicise verbally against the domination of the SED, in practice it is a much more convenient and acceptable evil for them than a social upheaval in the GDR.
The possibility that right-wing forces in West Germany would have to deal with a socialistically legitimated force in the GDR would mean a challenge for West Germany such as they are not ready to come to terms with.
You hope to go back to the GDR at the end of the year. What are your plans?
I was dumped here nearly two years ago through a series of very unusual and crazy circumstances. The moment of return - to which we now, of course, look forward impatiently - will throw us back into another crazy situation. We're coming on a GDR in upheaval.
Tremendous new experiences have been gained there. In the meantime we have tried to draw out the experiences of your society as critically as possible.
We will now try to set up the first minimal beginnings of independent educational and theoretical work, which are necessary for any further political development in the GDR. We will do it together with friends in Western and Eastern Europe with whom we have been able to develop very intensive contact over the last couple of years.
bar The opening of the border has accentuated the economic crisis in East Germany by emphasising the difference in the standard of living between East and West. A black economy is already beginning in which East German workers moonlight in the West and various rare commodities cross into the GDR, while various cheap commodities go the other way. To the extent that (West "German) Deutschmarks become a major means of payment in the GDR, there will be massive inflation in the East. Some services or goods will become available only for hard currency. There is also likely to be a massive outflow of savings from the GDR to get hard currency before there is a large devaluation of the East German mark.
On top of this, there are serious labour shortages as a result of emigration to the West. Though about 15,000 of the Stasi (secret police) have been sent down the mines and into the factories to do something useful by replacing those who left, many of them were highly trained workers such as doctors and nurses who cannot easily be replaced. There is a massive crisis in the health service and other sectors such as public transport which were badly affected.
The root cause of both the exodus and the economic collapse go back further into the past. One West German expert calculated that investment of 500,000 million Marks would be needed to bring the GDR economy up to the level of the West. Productivity is 45% below that in the West and, since Honecker came to power in 1971, capital investment has fallen from 16.1% to 9.9%. Whole sectors may have to shut entirely either for ecological reasons or because of their age. In reality, however, nobody knows the accurate figures as it has been admitted that Günter Mittag, who had run the economy since 1962, systematically falsified economic statistics and prevented independent economists from examining them. The information on the GDR in statistical yearbooks becomes thinner and thinner.
Mittag managed, through state takeovers of small. firms and mergers, to centralise production in 224 combines, monopolies that were under his direct control. By controlling trade, the currency and travel Mittag was able to exploit the captive market at home with highly priced, low quality goods. At the same time, the GDR became less capable of selling anything abroad. As one leading SED member remarked: "If we export goods worth one Mark, it is only worth 15 Pfennig on the world market"
This bureaucratic mismanagement was at the expense of the mass of the population. It explains why many of them are so keen to get their hands on Western goods.
The net result has been to make the economy now so weak that it offers rich pickings to West German capital - investment opportunities, a market and cheap labour. The immediate reaction to the end of the Berlin Wall was to send the Frankfurt Stock| Exchange up An opening of the GDR to the market forces the any aid from the West and Modrow, the reforming Prime Minister has already made concessions to this, saying "a real socialist planned economy needs the market" - The West German government is demanding even more in return for aid. The Finance Minister, Waigel, stated: "In no way will we finance the past or a new form of socialist planned economy in East Germany." (So much for letting the people choose!) He also called for the introduction of private ownership, the creation of real markets, and the abolition of price subsidies.
The only way East German workers will be able to stop these massive attacks on their living standards, which will doubtless eventually lead to an attack on their good helth and welfare provision, is by organisation in independent unions, which are now just beginning to emerge. They should press for parity with West German workers where their conditions are better, just as West German workers should press for better welfare state provisions of the G DR In West Germany there is also considerable discussion about how which direction low aid for the GDR should be financed, The DGB (equivalent of the TUC) has called for the end of planned tax cuts and of other tax plans that would benefit the rich, most other suggestions involve the increase in general taxation. The impact of events in the GDR on West Germany have been quite contradictory. While the East German emigrants were generally welcomed at first, the growing pressure on housing and jobs has caused resentment. The mayors of Bremen and Hannover have called for them to go elsewhere. The response to the surge across the border after restrictions were lifted was: "We're glad to see you, but we hope you return home" (most did). There have been some people who left the GDR a few months ago and are returning now that the right to travel has been conceded. Often the refugees are lodged in bad conditions and they face an unemployment rate of over 6%.
Politically the response has also been varied. There has been an upsurge of nationalist feeling, personified by the entire Bundestag singing the National Anthem when free travel was announced. On the other hand, Kohl was whistled at and shouted down when he raised the question of reunification and tried to sing the National Anthem again in West Berlin.
Much of the support for the GDR opposition among the conservatives in the west is hypocritical. As Die Zeit put it: *Democracy from below' is applauded by politicians here as long as it takes place in the GDR...Not only Helmut Kohl, but a large part of the political elite, fear wishes for consultation from below. Even now Kohl goes on again about 'rabble' (in West Berlin)". There is also a real fear that a successful renovation of socialism in the GDR would be attractive home and should therefore be stopped at all costs.
As the elections next year grow nearer, there will probably be increasing conflicts between the main political parties over their attitudes to events in the GDR. The Greens are the only party who are not formally arguing for reunification, instead saying that events in the GDR may allow the people there to develop a new identity, different both from what exists in West Germany and what existed in the GDR before.
Beyond the immediate events, the question of reunification is clearly the key to which direction Germany develops in. It is not clear how popular the demand is in the GDR, a least on the terms currently on offer. A recent opinion poll among East Germans showed 73% in favour of maintaining the two states. Many who oppose it will be people who see East Germany's identification with socialism as a positive alternative to the market economy of the West. Others may see it as not important Or attainable for now, when the GDR has still not become democratic. However, the peoples of both states want it, their right to self-determination should not be opposed.
However the two German states have different social systems and before reunification could come about two questions would have to be resolved: military alliances and the economy. Gorbachev has said that he has no objection to what is happening in the GDR as long as it remains a member of the Warsaw Pact. Virtually every Western politician has said that West Germany must not leave NATO at any cost. Some people have tried to square this with reunification by calling for a loose confederation of the two states in which they maintain their existing alliances. Neither of the alliances serve the interests of independent socialist politics in Germany. Socialists should call for German reunification on the basis of independence from both NATO and the Warsaw Pact.
In the same way, reunification should not be on the basis of either the Western free market free-for-all or the East's bureaucratic command economy. There would be little to look forward to for most people in the GDR in privatisation, or buy-outs by West German capital.
Our perspective must be for a democratically planned economy with workers' control and management of industry. This alone will enable the economy to develop free of the arbitrary diktats of the bureaucrats and the anarchy of the Reunification, whether on socialist or capitalist basis, is still some way in the future. The system under which it takes place (if at all) will depend on the degree to which socialist and independent workers' organisations develop in the GDR now. Thee will not be much time before the economy of the GDR is resolved one way or the other.
There is considerable support for "renewed socialism" a "third way" between Stalinism and capitalism. The crying need is for the political organisation of these forces before it is too late.
----- pull-quotes -----
'Beyond immediate events the question of reunification is clearly the key to
Germany develops in*