Capitalism's human face
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The central force in the Federation is taken by supporters of Militant. It must be said, in all fairness, that these comrades have done an enormous amount of good work both within the Federation and in the mass non-payment campaign.
However, Militant is always Militant, and they are making serious, and characteristic mistakes in the campaign so far, and these mistakes must not be repeated by the newly-formed campaign in England and They have over-emphasised propaganda for mass non-payment. Although mass non-payment is absolutely central, it cannot be seen as a be-all-and-end-all for the campaign against the poll tax. The fight within the labour movement is no less important: for example the campaign within unions such as NALGO, CPSA, etc, for industrial action against the poll tax; for the fight within local Labour Parties to commit Labour councils not to implement the poll tax and not to penalise those who refuse to register or pay.
It IS 1 very odd, considering Militant's history of decades of immersion in the structures of the official labour movement, but it is nevertheless true that Militant is displaying something like an ultraleft attitude to the official labour The UN has just passed a comprehensive resolution on the rights of children. The procedure now is that member countries sign and ratify the document, and by so doing, promise to implement it.
As part of the propaganda surrounding the UN proposals, TV programmes have highlighted children's lack of rights in various countries around the world. One programme I saw focused, with chilling footage and stories, on undernourishment in Peru, homelessness in London and racism in Italy. The programmes seemed to promise that these problems would now be tackled.
I'm not convinced!
Idealistic schoolchildren (for whom, I suspect, programmes like the one I saw are made) may be convinced by the UN resolution, and the public relations hype now surrounding it, that the UN is a "good thing" . But most thinking adults surely will not believe that anything much will really be done.
Why? Because the real cause of the lack of children's rights is -poverty. For the UN's fine words to have any effect the UN would have to get rid of poverty.
Poverty is the cause of the Peruvian families' diet of "bread and herb tea" , which produces in their children a monthly bout of flu.
Poverty is the cause of Peru's endemic TB, and high infant mortality rate.
many yoy i people sion on Lon don's streets each night.
Poverty engenders fear of having to share limited homes and work — one of the major causes of racism in countries where immigration from even poorer countries is common:
Poverty — and exploitation - 1s the cause of child labour.
Poverty is the reason millions of children don't go to school or get anything resembling what we think of as a childhood.
Listening to UN propaganda you would think that poverty is just something which happens to afflict half the world, and that "concerted international action" will solve it. But poverty is not inevitable or necessary.
TB, homelessness, infant mortality, lack of childhood, undernourishment, are all capable of being dealt with - right now.
Poverty is a crime against children. It is a crime beyond all comprehension not that poverty exists, but that the system under which we live depends upon it, encourages it and makes money out of it.
For every penny made by a child labourer, someone else takes another penny home and calls it "job creation" or "providing work", and gets government thanks for it.
People in Peru cannot eat meat. because other people will not sell it to them at prices they can afford, or lose profits in order to pay a living wage.
Young people cannot find homes in London because they haven't enough money for private housing, Janine Booth and the Tories have stopped sector building to finance tax cuts to benefit the already rich.
The truth is that capitalism is a crime against the whole of humanity and UN declarations won't stop it for the very simple reason that the UN is an organisation set up to give capitalism a "human face"
However, the UN is right about one thing. "Concerted international action" is needed to stop poverty. The concerted international action of the. working class will get rid of capitalism, and with it poverty and the other crimes against children.
Scan page 6
Wolfgang Templin is one of East Germany' best-known socialist dissidents. At present is living in West Germany, after being deported by the East German government in 1988. This interview, translated from the West German socialist newspaper Sozialistische Zeitung, shows how East German radicals, unlike most radicals in Poland or Hungary, see their aim as a "better socialism"
For decades every opposition movement in the GDR has been beaten down so quickly that it had no chance to develop. Now, all at once, we have a movement so massive as to force changes at the top and gain, for the first time, toleration in practice of the fundamental democratic rights of freedom of opinion and of assembly. There is even talk of the legalisation of the opposition, the New Forum. How is such a turnabout possible?
Much of what were previously supposed to be the disadvantages and deficiencies of the GDR are now turning into the opposite. Many observers in the West, and even people in the GDR, had fixed images and stereotypes.
The thought that the Party had managed, especially in the '70s and '80s, under Honecker, to buy oft the people with social security and increased individual consumption, in a sort of consumer and social contract. The Party had bought acceptance of the idea that political freedoms would continue to be denied.
So many people became convinced that nothing would change in this GDR for a long time. For many people it was an almost crippling certainty, which even drove them out of the country, because they suffered under this petrification.
What nevertheless escaped observation or immediate experience was the processes underneath that level of political manipulation. I mean the attempts at organisation in the independent movement of the '80s, beginning with the circles and groups of the peace movement, then the ecology and human rights groups. Right from the start, with all their political naivete and churchiness, they staked a claim that touched the system more deeply than any worked-out programme: namely, the claim to be taken seriously as adult citizens.
It was that strugle that did it -not any formed opposition, but the Conference attempt by more and more people to take this self-assertion out of the small chruch groups and circles.
People who had been arrested once, twice or five times did not give up. They survived being detained on remand. They carried on. They put up with social repression, job discrimination and discrimination in day-to-day life, without becoming embittered. And still they insisted: we need a different way of life in this country.
That was an anticipation of what is now being manifested on a mass scale. It is no accident that all the initiatives in the broad opposition have as initiators people who have been through those experiences in the last ten years and can now come forward Alone and in itself, of course, the activity of the small groups would not have been enough. It was also necessary that the driving force and the opportunities of Honecker's consumer society be exhausted. The GDR is stagnating economically.
Neither a continuing rapid rise in living standards nor a further opening of the political safety-valves, was available.
Every attempt to mollify people with more liberal travel regulations failed because people wanted the travel concessions that they were granted given to them as guaranteed rights.
Is there a positive common denominator for the numerous opposition groups now emerging, beyond rejection of the existing system? A common goal or objec-Speakerstromi the hran J speakmm about free trade unionism tive?
I think sO. If you read the documents of these groups, follow their discussions, or get to know the indivduals, then something like a common set of values emerges.
Obviously there are all sorts of differences, but you also see common directions. They see a lot of value to be preserved in GDR - I deliberately say GDR society, not the SED [ruling party] system and a lot of potential for change, which requires radical reforms and democratisation on its own basis. The democratisation of GDR society should not necessarily be oriented to western parliamentarydemocratic norms and models.
This consciousness can be found in all the groups of the GDR opposition. We want the rule of law, they say, we want political freedoms, we want the opportunity to participate in politics, we challenge the political monopoly of the SED, we want political Be heard by the Party as cit ens in a dialogue, we also want to break up the Party's monopoly of power by actual participation.
Obviously different groups give different weight to these ideas. Certainly a lot of those involved have a strong tendency to favour economic reforms in the direction of bringing in market elements, or even, as in the programme of the Social Democratic Party [newly revived in East Germany], to talk about a social market economy.
But in the thinking of that party this means something different from what any sort of social marke economy means here, so probably using this concept is a mistake. They mean an attempt to combine overall social planning, private initiatives, different forms of property and the introduction of market elements in such a way as to establish an ecologically acceptable, view with the magazine Der Spiegel.
As regards the question of economic reform, there is great potential of creativity and com-
----- pull-quotes -----
Speakers includer