How to fight the poll PAI POLL TAI
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
for the demonstration was, to say the least, disappointing.
As the poll tax in Scotland approaches its ninth month in operation it is time to draw some of the lessons of the anti poll-tax struggle so far, and of the various campaigns.
It was the STUC campaign which was responsible for last Saturday's demo — which was an event typical of their campaign. There was little publicity, no campaign of mobilisa. tion, and lacklustre organisation. Since the inception of the STUC campaign it has been a shadow of a real campaign, tightly controlled by the STUC appointees and forever wary of embarrassing the leadership of the Scottish Labour Party - at Regional Council, Scottish Executive or any other level.
It has been associated with 'Committees of 100', groups of 100 peo ple organised throughout Scotland churchmen, trade union officials, professionals — who can afford to pay the poll tax, but who refuse to pay.
Besides being a very elitist idea, it was an attempt by the bureaucrats to get themselves seen to be doing something positive, whilst at the same time undermining and excluding any real campaign for mass non-payment and for labour movement action against the poll tax.
Or take the campaign of the Scottish Anti-Poll Tax Federation. The basic strength of the SAPT lies in the hundreds of anti-poll tax unions organised throughout the whole of Scotland who are affiliated to it. The Federation represents the genuine anti-poll tax campaign in Scotland and has been actively excluded by the STUC from doing any joint work with the campaign of the Committees of 100.
The Federation's basic slogan is 'Don't Pay, Don't Collect, an excellent slogan, though the emphasis has been placed on the 'Don't Pay'. heavily overshadowing 'Don't Col lect'. movement in the poll tax campaign.
One inevitable consequence of this ultra-leftism is that it reduces the seemingly "left' and revolutionary' focus on 'Don't Pay, Direct Action' to empty phrasemongering, good, maybe, for recruiting people out of the campaign to the Militant's organisation, but having little consequence in terms of promoting a real movement which refuses to pay, and can go on to beat the Tories.
Such a movement demands the mobilisation of the official labour movement at all levels. Without that, even a powerful estates-based non-payment movement can be contained, worn down, and will tinally be dissipated.
Militant's one-sidedness, the "revolutionary' concentration On *Direct Action now' is, therefore, not quite what it seems. In real life it translates into the irresponsible politics of phrase-mongering combined with Militant sect-building, at the expense of developing a movement which can win. Militant is always...Militant!
Thus too we reach the explanation of another paradox: that Militant should now be presenting itself as ultra-revolutionary, as almost a brand of syndicalists, with their focus on tenants' direct action and one-sided neglect of the official structures of the labour movement, when for decades past Militant has been marked above all by an ultrastaid and cautious approach to every question, and by its obsession with the structures of the official movement.
The explanation is to be found in the fact that Militant feels that it can safely indulge in revolutionary' and 'extreme' posturing, because they will never be called upon to live up to it, so long as the labour movement is not involved enough to make it a serious challenge to the Tories.
Should the labour movement mount a serious challenge to the poll tax, Militant would most likely revert to the role of cautious and timid right-wing commentator, the role it stubbornly played through all the years of mass working class struggle in the '60s and '70s - to sheke in played winen he met ts.
Liverpool Council, which it led, be bought off by the Tories instead of leading the labour movement in Liverpool into confrontation there and then in combination with the striking miners. Militant let the miners fight on in isolation, and next year the Tories came and settled their account with Militant in Liverpool.
Militant is not concerned primarily with an effective fight against the poll tax, but with adopting the best safe posture on which to maximise the recruits to and the income of Militant.
One immediately disruptive conAl 4\S0N anine