Women are not to blame!
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
can quite understand the point of an article which tries to be controversial and provoke discussion, but Liz Millward's 'Children and divorce' (Women's Eye, SO 420) is at best wide of the mark, and at worst utterly reactionary.
It is true that we live in an antichild society, but my own experience of being a mother does not fit the reality which Liz describes.
When most people see a mother lashing out at her wailing child in a supermarket, they do not sympathise with her as the article claims; in fact they utterly condemn her, either publicly, or just under their breath.
And when people see women struggling on the bus with buggy and shopping, they do not leap to her aid. Bitter experience has shown that more often than not people ignore her plight, bus drivers don't wait, other passengers get cross... the artile was is implications of women in relationships they don't really want to stay in.
It is not true that divorce necessarily leads to children having "an inability to form happy and long-standing relationships" in later life. Divorce certainly can be emotionally disturbing for the children involved, but so can incest, domestic violence, poverty, etc.
To conclude that women ought to make more of an effort to make their relationships last is to put the burden of guilt squarely on the shoulders of the mother. Women do not take a decision to leave the father of their children lightly -they do not overlook their children to suit themselves. Tragically the reality is more like women suffering in unfulfilling relationships for the sake of the children.
An unhappy parent is not as good a parent as a happy one.
Little children are indeed innocent, but moralising to women does nothing to help kids at all. I honestly cannot imagine anything worse than separated parents having by law to spend time with their children, when they really want nothing to do with them. Apart from the obvious implications of allowing the state to intervene in. this way, forcing parents to be with their children would not make for a positive relationship.
The article starts from a view= point which sees the nuclear family as the norm and anything else as second best.
I do not that because I no longer have a personal relationship with his father. I thought it was the Tories who always went on about children from so-called "broken homes"
And talking of the Tories, let's put the blame for all this where it really lies — on poverty, homelessness, low pay, long working hours, lack of communal childcare tacilities, the capitalist system itself which puts profits before people and oppresses women particularly.
The answer to the problems of children and divorce is not, as Liz suggests, for individual women to put up with things as they are or to make changes to their lives on their own.
The socialist answer is for women to collectively fight back, to make the labour and trade union movement take up their demands for a shorter working week, for flexible working hours, for adequate childcare facilities, etc.
And socialists should certainly not fall into the trap of thinking that a child should be with its father an mother in perfect harmony. That harmony is mostly a lot less than perfect in the big bad world out there.
Julia Coulton Manchester