Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[This week Parliament is T being televised. In…]

Socialist Organiser no. 425, 23 November 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 1,196 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

This week Parliament is T being televised. In a timid and limited way modern technology is being used to bring the doings of Parliament into every home with a TV set.

For the first time the people will be able to see a little of what goes on behind the venerable facade of the Palace of Westminster.

The Establishment is taking a big risk, and they know it. There is still a very large body of Westminster opinion strongly opposed to televising Parliament.

If it goes well for them, then the credibility of Parliament will receive a much-needed boost. But if it goes wrong, then Parliament will be discredited, perhaps not instantly, but over time, in an accelerated erosion of its credibility.

Socialists can only welcome this opening up of Parliament. Every advance, however marginal and small, in democracy will ultimately prove to be to the advantage of socialists.

Right now the general idea of parliamentary democracy is being buoyed up by the tangible bellet off tens of millions in Eastern Europe, in the USSR, and in China, that a system of government like Westminster's is better than any other available. And for sure Westminster is better than any of the alternatives offered by Stalinist and other police states.

Yet how much credibility does the British Parliament really deserve as a democratic institution truly controlling the governance of the country? How much, or how little, do we in Britain really have democracy as defined, for example, by Abraham Lincoln - 'government of the people by the people for the people'?

This is what a Westminster insider has to say about it.

"Parliament exercises little control over ministers in any field. Their accountability is a thin and painless phenomenon. Ministers and backbenchers have an identical interest in denying that this is so. But they enter a conspiracy of deception.

Parliament may sometimes be a nuisance, but to a government with a strong majority it is never a threat. The recent occasions when it has stopped a measure or embarrassed a minister are so rare as to be the stuff of wondrous selfcongratulation.

Nor is there any refined or reliable thread running between Parliament and the people's wishes. Mandate and manifesto are important words in the vocabulary of illusion.

Current examples abound. The poll tax has become law without a debate of any kind during the last election. Child Benefit is being cut on the basis of a studiously constructed double entendre in the Tory manifesto.

Upheaval beckons in the National Health Service, but not a trace of it was anticipated in 1987. All these matters have the sketchiest of parliamentary legitimacy...

Party discipline, buttressed by ambition and venality of the mind, ensures that Parliament, far from making government accountable, is its faithful accomplice... Between the Conservative Party of Great Britain and the Communist Party of Poland, anyone seeking discipline these days could make only one choice"* Demonstrators in Prague The writer, to complete the picture, could add that the Kinnockites in the Parliamentary Labour Party are doing their best to make the Labour Party as "Stalinist" in its discipline as the Tory Party.

Who have we been quoting? Eric Heffer? Tony Benn? Dennis Skinner? Some other leftist?

No, Hugo Young, writing in the Guardian on 21 November. Young is probably no further left than the SDP. He is merely an honest observer of Westminster and the realities of how Britain is really governed.

He is concerned, in the article we have been quoting, to pour justified scorn on Mrs Thatcher's claim that she is defending the sovereignty of Parliament against the encroachments of the European Community. That same idea • the defence of parliamentary democracy against the bureaucrats ation; and election of top State officials. Consider the economic side of democracy, too, and it's clear that Westminster is a very shrivelled democracy indeed.

Westminster and similar parliaments are glove puppets controlled by the hidden hands of entrenched bureaucrats representing the interests of the rich. They have a great deal less to offer the risen people in the Stalinist states than those people imagine.

The British labour movement has much to learn from those now thronging the streets of Prague and Berlin and Warsaw. We have much more to learn than you would think from the commentaries of those -in the labour movement and outside it - who smugly interpret the movements for democracy in the Eastern Bloc as votes of confidence in our sclerosed democratic institutions. Published 823, Londe Press Li Registered Office.

themselve as plainspeaking, no-nonsense types. People like Woodrow Wyatt, Paul Johnson and Bruce Anderson aren't afraid to tell it like it is, even if that means treading on a few toes. Not for these bluff fellows the euphemisms and evasions of the liberals and lefties with their craven concern for so-called 'minority groups? like black people, gays and However, plain speaking has its limits. When the Independent accused Mrs Thatcher of "lying to save her own skin" in the aftermath. of the Lawson resignation, a shrill chorus of outrage erupted from stage right.

Paul Johnson (in the Spectator) explained that if a senior minister goes into the Prime Minister's room at Number 10 to discuss his personal future, then there is bound to be tension on both sides and it is in precisely such an atmosphere that misunderstandings arise" Therefore, Johnson concludes, "words like 'lying' and expressions like 'saving her own skin' are crude inaccurate and childish. I hope we will have no more of this vulgarity from the Independent"

Over at the Sunday Telegraph new recruit Geoffrey Wheatcroft upbraided the Independent along similar lines. "Is the editor of the Independent, Mr Andreas Whittam-Smith's, experience of either public or private life really so limited that he has never known anything to compare with this sorry episode? He should try asking those concerned in a failed marriage or love affair to see just how differently two people - in good faith and by their own lights honestly - can recollect the same events"

Ah! Isn't that rather touching? and doesn't it help explain everything with a nice down-toearth analogy that simple folk like you and me can relate to.

So, having established that calling Mrs Thatcher a liar is crude, vulgar and a sure sign of never having been in love, the question renains why did Whittam-Smith tell it? Once more the Sunday Telegraph comes into its own. Peregrine Worsthorne explains everything: "German re-unification brings the threat of a federal Europe ever-closer. The same sinister forces that encouraged *coloured immigration' are now 'trying to take steps' again without consulting the British people leading inevitably to Britain becoming a part of a federal Europe. Only one person stands in the way of this rush into federalism - the Prime Minister"

So now all is revealed: the Independent is fronting a huge conspiracy to undermine Mrs Thatcher and establish German hegenomy in a federal Europe. The German influence, of course, explains the crudeness and vulgarity of Mr Whittam-Smith's language....or should it be Herr WhittamSchmidt?

J.O'Mahon

115 4NA, an Internatio newspaper Box d by Post

----- pull-quotes -----

plain talk -PRESS GIANIG ight-wing journali its tend

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 425

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →