Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A trade union in the 'Red Army

Socialist Organiser no. 425, 23 November 1989 · scan p. 2 · Clive Bradley · about 1,137 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Sam • independent trade A union has been formed in the USSR's so-called Red Army, demanding an end to conscription and the abolition of political commissars.

Formed mainly by middleranking officers and reservists, the union held its inaugural meeting of 300 in a Moscow hall. The hall was rented by an MP representing the radical Moscow Popular Front.

Named Shield, the union also called for a reduction in the size of the armed forces and opposed the increasing use of force in ethnic unrest in the USSR.

Telman Gdlyn, a Moscow MP, according to the Guardian (October 23), told the meeting, to long applause: "However hard it is, and from wherever the order comes, do not shoot at your own people.

Discontent in the armed forces is very widespread, with other complaints including social conditions, such as low pay and bad housing.

Shield says it wants dialogue, not conflict. But its formation is extremely significant. It is being tolerated for now, it seems, but the union is sensible enough to be keeping the names of many of its members 'confidential'. If it grows, it could give the military hierarchy a lot of headaches.

There has been speculation inside and outside the USSR that one of the hard liners' options against Gorbachev would be a military coup; Shield's formation, indeed, is in part in response to this. Organised discontent in the army will certainly make any such attempts much harder.

The Red Army was originally organised by Trotsky to defend the troops marching out of Afghanistal new workers' state in the civil war that followed the 1917 revolution. As a result of the war with counter-revolutionary 'whites' the USSR was reduced to near economic ruin, and it was isolated by the defeat of revolutions elsewhere in Europe. A bureaucracy began to develop, fronted by Stalin, in the Red Army no less than elsewhere.

For a while, some people thought that Trotsky, the main opponent of Stalin, might use the Red Army, of which he was leader, to take power. But he did not, believing that to do so would condemn him to the logic of bureaucratic-military rule.

But Trotsky was ousted from the leadership of the Red Army, which soon changed its character. Originally extremely democratic, with rank and file control, already by the end of the civil war the Red Army was being organised along more traditional military lines.

As the bureaucracy consolidated its rule over society, the Red Army was purged of revolutionaries. In fact, so excessive was the purge that by the time war broke out between the USSR and Hitler, the Red Army lungary s combination o chea abour and little trade uni organisation with easy at ess 1 West European markets. lacked comnetent officers.

After the Second World War, the Red Army was the agency through which Stalin extended his control over Eastern Europe. The various 'people's republics' • except Yugoslavia, depended for their survival on "Red Army' back up.

In Hungary in 1956 and in Czechoslovakia in 1968, the Red Army was used to intervene and bloodily suppress popular uprisings.

The more recent war in Afghanistan has done much to alienate conscripted Soviet youth, and underlies the mood of opposition to military involvement in 'troublespot' republics, like Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Socialists in the USSR would seek to replace the 'Red' Army with a popular militia on the model of the original Red Army after 1917. A thoroughgoing revolution in the USSR will certainly mean the creation of such a force.

Discontent, and especially the formation of unions, political discussion, and public protest, will make a big contribution to bringing that revolution about. tional Front, has nothing to offer cept denunciations of Rajiv. Its policies, on paper, are almost iden tical with those of the Congress Party - indeed, its core is made up of win in Brazil?

The Brazilian presidential elections look set to produce a fight-out between Workers' Party (PT) candidate Luis Inacio 'Lula' da Silva and right-wing populist Fernando Collor de Mello.

All socialists must want Lula to win, but victory would pose huge problems for the PT.

The PT has fought this election as the dominant partner in a 'front' that inclúdes the PC do B, a proAlbanian party that split many years ago from the mainstream Communists, and a small social-democratic party. No doubt they would have preferred a wider unity, incorporating the PCB (ie, the pro-Moscow party, until recently very discredited for its right-wing policies, now making a bit of a comeback), and the Democratic Labour Party of Leonel Brizola.

According to left-wing critics in the PT, the Lula leadership has been making winning the election more and more of a priority as it has seemed more and more possible to do so. Lula has been trying to make himself appear a credible "presidential' candidate - that is, woo the "middle ground" , and reassure sections of the Brazilian ruling class.

The decision of the PT council led by Luiza Erendino in Sao Paolo to raise transport prices, rather than fight central government, has been linked by its critics to this 'presiden'So the objective is win the "executive branch", and use it much as possible ta stimulate struggles below which would gles from below.

Its authors recognise that the PT's strength has been in rank and file mobilisations, particularly within the ten million strong trade union federation, the CUT. Through these workers' struggles. they have defeated various attempts by the ruling class to impose its answer to the country's terrible problems of debt and inflation.

The document acknowledges that in any serious attempt to implement a programme of social reform — to system on the land, inequality, improve social reduce inequality, reform the and political rights for the masses the PT would meet with resistance from the ruling class.

It states: "our main adversaries are the international creditors, the latifundists, the bankers, the big oligopolies, besides the private groups associated with the civilian and military bureaucracy that control the Brazilian state.

It adds: "Neither the constitutional limitations...nor the nonconstitutional...(military tutelage, the political hegemony of the bourgeoisie, the monopoly control of the media) can determine our party programme and our historic objective of building a socialist society."

It notes the experience of the Allende government in Chile, where half-heartedness in confronting the ruling class led, in 1973, to tragic consequences.

But, the document's authors insist, "(it is not) possible to propose a socialist programme which would not be understood and would isolate us.

So the objective is to win the "executive branch" ("realising that the government and power are not the same thing"), and use it as much as possible to stimulate struggles from below which would move in socialist direction. "The PT does not believe in a stage of 'people's capitalism'."

Elements in this document sug-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 425

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →