Where is Briefing going?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Many delegates were the arguments advanced by Alan Thornett who moved the conference policy document.
It wasn't that the policy statement itself was poor. It contained many strong points. No, what delegates were unhappy with was the statement's fuzziness on the question of trade union democracy and lack of attention on the central problems of democratising the Broad Lefts and co-ordinating the left across the unions.
But, the process of democratic debate in the various workshops did much to sharpen the focus of the more fuzzy sections. Many amendments put forward Mean hornet, Speaking for phe dra: ting committee majority, opposed such democratic demands as:
• The frequent re-election of trade union officials, preferably annually, but for a maximum of two years.
Instead, Thornett put forward a vague formula: elected "for a short defined term" . This was taken to mean for five years. Thornett said he didn't mean five years, but he fought tooth and nail against defining it as for two years, and took his defeat by conference with a very bad grace.
• Union executives, appeals courts and disciplinary committees to be made up of elected lay members only.
And in the sections on Broad Lefts and rank and file organisation Alan opposed:
• Campaigning inside the BLs democratise them and win them policies against discrimination and the interests of the working class.
• Approaching BLOC and the LCDTU to organise an open, democratic conference of the Broad Lefts to create a democratic national framework to co-ordinate the left in the unions.
In the event all but one clause of one of the amendments opposed by Alan on these questions were accepted by the majority of the conference. It seems that the great bulk of the active trade unionists present had a much clearer view of the problems facing the left in the unions than the person so eager to put himself forward as summing up the mood of the conference.
This alone should not really be any cause for concern. In any democratic movement there will be disagreements between "leaders' and the 'led . Debate to resolve such differences can only have a positive and beneficial effect.
The problems that worried some delegates were the methods' Alan employed in attempting to make his case.
At one point the chair had to stop Alan speaking after a point of order from a building worker. The comrade pointed out that Alan was using his 15 minute speech intended to introduce the document as an opportunity to reply to amendments that had not yet been put. The chair received warm applause when she upheld the point of order. Many of the delegates must have thought how good it would be to have such an effective chair at their own union conferences.
When this didn't work, Alan resorted to claiming from the platform that amendments he didn't agree with implied a 'secret agenda'. For instance, he insisted that the phrase "Call a meeting to discuss the way forward" really meant launch a new rank and file movement based only on the affiliates to the Socialist Movement trade union conference. This caused the required degree of confusion but hardly raised the level of informed, democratic debate.
What was most surprising about Alan's arguments was that as a prominent contributor to Briefing Alan appeared to act throughout without any consultation with other members of Briefing's editorial board, as if they didn't count for anything.
In fact, most Briefing supporters couldn't bring themselves to vote for his arguments against a clear unambiguous commitment to trade union democracy. For instance, when Alan's evasive formula of "election of officials for a short defined term" was put up for the vote only two Brieting supporters (Patrick Sikorski and Tony Richardson) could be seen to reluctantly and shamefacedly vote for it. A large number of Briefing supporters voted against.
But a mystery remains. Alan Thornett is Briefing and Socialist Outlook's most prominent trade unionist and best-known supporter. He even wrote an article in the latest Outlook heaping praise on the conference document he helped draw up. Yet time and time again at the conference he argued against what appear to be the views of the majority of Briefing supporters who couldn't bring themselves to support him. What is going on?
Is Alan Thornett so overcome with factional venom towards anything proposed by a trade unionist associated with Socialist Organiser that he opposes it on principle? Or is he just out of touch with the unions? Briefing's supporters in the unions should call Alan Thornett to account.
The left in the unions is not so strong they can afford such excesses. We need to work together not needlessly against each other. The policies adopted by the Socialist Movement trade union conference can begin to lay the basis for such common action.
An important first step has been taken towards drawing together the left in the unions.
By Stan Crooke Only six months into the City Council rushed through 'economy measures' last week in order to avoid a £20 million 'overspend', which would have left individual members of the controlling Labour Group personally liable for the interest.
Council leader Keva Coombes has denied that any cuts are involved. It is merely a matter, he claims, of value for money and more efficient services.
In reality, cuts are involved on old people's homes, adaptations for the handicapped, improvement grants, street lighting, and school stationery.
Money for the Gifford inquiry, which has highlighted racial discrimination against Liverpool s substantial black community, has been cut completely. Although the amount "saved' is negligible (some E11,000) the cuts says a lot about the Council's priorities.