Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Green's Goddess

Socialist Organiser no. 424, 16 November 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 832 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The concept of Gaia was much aired at the Green Party's conference recently.

The idea, developed by independent scientist James Lovelock, is that the Earth behaves as a self-regulating organism, rather like a living being. Lovelock gave this being the name Gaia, after the Roman Earth goddess.

It would be ludicrous to regard this hypothesis as literally true (though doubtless there are some who do) but, as a way of understanding the Earth's responses to various natural and artificial changes in the environment, the Gala hypothesis has its merits.

As part of the Earth, living things are part of Gaia and may mediate the "responses' of Gaia to changes in its environment. Thus, incrèases in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere cause a zreater rate or growth of green plants This uses up the extra CO2, tending to return things to their original state.

Inanimate parts of the Earth will also take part in Gaia's responses. Greater CO, levels will lead to warming of the Earth. Some of this warmth will be used in melting the polar ice. Some will go towards evaporating more water from the oceans. Thus the rise in temperature will be moderated, just as in living things.

The inconvenience this may cause to our species through altered sea levels and climate is of no concern to Gaia, which after, all has seen many other species become extinct in the past.

It is easy to see why Gaia should have struck a chord with green activists, but Lovelock himself is highly critical of the environmental movement. He believes, as he told Friends of the Earth a few weeks ago, they have got their priorities wrong.

And speaking at a Schumacher Lecture last year, Lovelock said that environmentalists had *become concerned with narrow human interests... rather than with a proper concern and empathy for the natural world". Groups such as FoE had become obsessed with "often imaginary human dangers" (e.g. radiation and PCB pesticides).

Lovelock disagrees with environmentalists over 'acid rain'. FoE described Britain as the dirty man of Europe for its acid pollution of Scandinavia. It campaigned for the CEGB to install pollution controls on coal-fired power stations. But Lovelock believes that pollution is not the main cause of acid rain.

He told New Scientist sulphur falling on Scandinavia_comes from natural marine sources, algae in the North Sea which excrete sulphurcontaining gases.

Lovelock teased Lord Walter Marshall, chairman of the CEGB, at Mrs Thatcher's 'Brains Trust' on the greenhouse effect last April for being "hoodwinked' into clearing up pollution which is not the main cause of acid rain.

Even more heretically, Lovelock describes the depletion of the ozone layer as a 'minor issue' as far as the survival of Gaia is concerned. And in any case, he doesn't believe that CFCs from fridges and spray cans are the cause of the hole in the ozone layer over the Antarctic.

He blames it instead on the eruption of the Mexican volcano, El Chichon in 1982. This hurled much dust into the stratosphere and the resulting chemical reactions destroyed lots of ozone over the next few years.

Lovelock claims to have evidence of a similar ozone hole in 1889, following the eruption of Krakatoa. He says the 'ozone establishment' (whatever that is) knows of this finding but are hiding it, though why they should do so is a mystery.

Lovelock has obligingly made a testable prediction of his theory. The ozone hole over the Antarctic which gaped in 1987 and partially filled in 1988 should not form this year. Antarctic scientist Joe Farman, discoverer of the ozone hole, predicted on the contrary a hole as big as ever.

Lovelock has been proved wrong for the latest data show a hole as big as, if not bigger thạn, 1987.

Lovelock's views on nuclear power are no more acceptable to the average green or indeed many on the left. He says "I hate the green movement's obsession with nuclear reaction. Nuclear power would be economic if it didn't have to meet these absurd safety standards". The rocks of Bodmin Moor where he lives, release far more radiation than is permitted from nuclear power stations.

What Lovelock is concerned about is damage of Gaia's fundamental life support systems, such as those that soak up pollution or which keep the planet's temperature within an acceptable range. One assault on the planetary thermostat is the largely human-caused increase in CO2 in the air. This is caused partly by burning fossil fuels and partly by deforestation.

Lovelock sees the latter as dangerous for another reason, though. The tropical forests cool the Earth by using the Sun's heat to evaporate water from leaves, rather as a sweating animal cools itself. Lovelock estimates the cooling power of the forests as 200 kilowatts per hectare. More graphically, he says "the 55 square feet of land said to be needed to produce enough meat for one burger was providing a cooling service of £380 per year"!

----- pull-quotes -----

SICJENICE COLUMN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 424

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →