Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The despair of a drop

Socialist Organiser no. 424, 16 November 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 585 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Weaver

'Melancholia ver the years, revolu• tionary socialism has attracted its fair share of middle class intellectuals, but the drop out rate is high. Far from viewing socialism as a lifetime commitment, the political equivalent of a marathon, many see the struggle as a relay race (something to give your best to for a short time, before passing on the baton to someone else).

Most go on to careers that offer rewards and recognition, things they expect as their middle class birthright. The youthful folly' of socialist rebellion is left behind.

It's natural. The middle class socialist has the option of a better life now; he doesn't have to wait for the revolution. For many, the early thrill of understanding the world and doing one's bit to change it isn't enough; they want more personal rewards. Middle class children are raised to compete for individual success and approval. Small wonder they feel 'unappreciated' in the collective workings of the left.

Those who give up usually suffer worrying twinges of conscience, but these lessen over time. For a small number, the guilt of leaving lasts as long as life. Their self-hatred is the spiritual hair-shirt they adopt as penance for their crime.

'Melancholia' captures perfectly this rare but recognisable variety of middle class angst. David Keller (Jeroen Krabbe) is a moderately successful art critic, living in comfortable circumstances in 1980s London. Initially caught up in the political stirrings of 1968, he turned his back on the revolutionary struggle, and now despises himself for it. His excuse is that he had nothing to The guilt-wracked drop-out (Jeroen offer, but this is false, and he knows it to be raise. He s too nonest to deceive himself, but the meaningless years since his defection have sapped his strength. Alienated from people, he tries to drown his malaise in drink.

He is shocked from his apathy by a voice from his political past, demanding that he assassinate Adolfo Vargas, a Chilean torturer. At first horrified, he is later drawn to the assignment, to the grand gesture that will wipe out the aimless, pointless years.

When the kill is cancelled he feels cheated. Briefly, he had felt alive, purposeful.

Then he meets Sarah Yelin, the victim of Vargas's tortures, and he decides to go ahead with the assassination. Sarah's calm but chilling recitation of her sufferings breaks through the crust of his selfishness and apathy, and he begins to see the killing in a new light. To him, it is no longer the grand gesture he had imagined, but a smaller act, an act of Krebbe, left) rith the torture victi humanity and spassion, the relieving ol anotner person s intolerable pain.

But this is self delusion; the killing of Vargas, however Justitied, solves nothing. It might give Sarah revenge, but it won't bring back the husband she has lost, nor does it provide answers for the countless others undergoing imprisonment and torture in Latin America.

Torturers are not born, but are created by political systems that aim to crush dissent, whatever the cost. Keller's act won't stop other torturers taking Vargas's place, so his act is doubly pointless, since it doesn't save him either.

He's too far gone for that. The killing instead of drawing him back to people, only alienates him further.

*Melancholia' is a chronicle of waste, the waste of David's life and energy in deliberate, self-inflicted, and ultimately futile misery. It doesn't romanticise these woes, and it doesn't make his 35.

HOURS NOW!

AEU

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 424

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →