Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Further Reading Treform Revolution in Eastern Europe?

Socialist Organiser no. 424, 16 November 1989 · scan p. 5 · about 500 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

From the floor, Be told Phil Hearse Organiser is not in capitalism! We c capitalism in the Sovi want a socialist revolut in every country.

But East German know about conditic Germany prefer the W a worker in the Easts bureaucrats can put psychiatric hospital camp, you can't have union, you don't hav speech, you can't newspaper.

If we tell Eastern E *At least you're ha you've got nationalise they'll tell us it's bu "rhythms of work"? A is the rhythm of peo their feet in the food to keep warm.

Maybe China has economically than Ind system in China what isn't. The workers d they protest they get : linda Weaver hat Socialist 1 tavour of lon't want et Union; we tion there and workers who ons in West 'est. If you're ern Bloc, the you into a or a labour : a free trade e freedom of put out a Bloc workers: ufway there, d property" illshit. Better All you've got ple stamping queues trying done better lia. But is the we want? It on't rule. if shot down in they have developed the productive forces and culture.

Martin Thomas said that the Eastern Bloc states are not just nationalised economies. They are nationalised economies plus totalitarian or semi-totalitarian states and huge privileges for the bureaucracies.

To say that these systems are much better than capitalism - so much better that their replacement by capitalism would be "a historic catastrophe" - is to say that the nationalised property is much more important than workers' rights. It is to say that what the bureaucracies have done in the way of nationalising property is much more important than workers' rights. It is to give undeserved credit to the bureaucracies.

It is also to gloss up the conditions of the workers, talking about "social gains" when Soviet miners have to strike for the demand that they should get a flat within ten years! Phil Hearse said that Stalinism was only "fake" barthe bureaucracies with confused ideas. Socialist Organiser says: support the workers. Socialist Outlook tends to say: support the workers if they have clear socialist ideas, but watch out in case they threaten the great progressive work done by the bureaucracies.

After other contributions from the floor, the main speakers summed up.

Phil Hearse said that in the USSR and China today workers are mobilising to defend the social gains which these so-called modern slaves and victims of totalitarianism have established under the bureaucratic regimes. In China the workers were defending the gains of relative equality and job security. In the USSR the workers defend the gains of cheap housing and job security threatened by perestroika.

But from Socialist Organiser's viewpoint, why not American Cuba? Maybe the invasion would create the conditions for free trade unions in Cuba.

It's not true Socialist 80p plus 15p posta from SO, PO Box 8 London SE15 4NA. Also available: "Reassessing the Eastern Bloc', 50p plus 15p postage OR IST ORGANISER PAMPHLET 80 PENCE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 424

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →