4 FOR A WORKERS' EUROPE EAST AND WEST Is Stalinism a step forward?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
IN_MASS PROTEST rickets, in advance, £8 (waged)/£4 (low wager From Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc (CSWEB), 56 Kevan House, Wyndham Road, London SE5. Cheques to Are the Eastern Bloc systems workers states in any sense at all? Are they an quarter of the way, towards socialism?
Everyday evidence says, more and more emphatically, no. Yet many anti-Stalinist socialists still say yes Socialist Organiser (which says no)
debated last Monday, November, with Socialist Outlook and Briefing (which say yes).
John O'Mahony Socialist Organiser of pened debate. In previous de bates Socialist Outlook speakers have not insisted on the term "workers' states" for the Eastern Bloc, choosing to take their stand instead on the term "post-capitalist".
Yet what's happening today shows that post-capitalist is precisely what the Eastern Bloc states are not. They do not represent a whole stage of history more progressive than capitalism. They are not in transition from capitalism to socialism. They are a historical dead end.
The Bloc Conference "Solidarity Conference"
have been the sole rulers of society over decades. That record stamps them as ruling classes, albeit with peculiar features.
To say, on the contrary, that the workers rule there defies common sense. The only possible theoretical argument could be that a nationalised economy, with some planning and the overthrow of the old ruling class, is necessarily an advance on capitalism, and some sort of workers' state. But history demolishes that argument.
Trotsky and the Bolsheviks never believed that socialism would be possible in Russia alone. They advocated a workers' revolution that would have to be spread to other, more advanced, capitalist countries before socialism could be possible.
But the other revolutions were defeated. The Bolsheviks conducted a controlled retreat, with the New Economic Policy, reviving the market, allowing petty capitalism to develop. Alongside the NEP bourgeoisie, a bureaucratic elite developed round Stalin.
The bureaucracy rose above the working class, balanced between the working class and the bourgeoisie, suppressed the working class opposition and then turned on the bourgeoisie. From the early "30s the bureaucracy became the sole controller of the economic structure and the sole master of the surplus product (as Trotsky described it retrospectively in 1940).
The bureaucracy could manage some economic progress by combining imported technology with vast armies of dragooned labour. But as early as 1935 Trotsky pointed out that the bureuacracy's capacity for economic progress would vanish with the need to introduce more advanced technology.
In 1939 Trotsky said that the bureaucracy had all the features of a ruling class apart from stability (eg. the right of inheritance) and a clear role in history. But that same year he conceded the theoretical • Stalls eveningFloor, ULU advance, f8 (waged)/£4 (low And E. Germanv THE ONE WHO GOT AWAY IT slaps down new border ban TRAVELLERS TOLD TO GET OUT OF TRAINS nant to a Were Con BERLIN. Wodnesday. - West VETTIT and by the linet and to pretent the 7 Mall of action cannon Hat Brace Claree MIDNIGHT CLOSURE resee it he Brander here at mpert at Trom berder lown Ruenaes August 196i , when the Berlin ryu wen the Berl possibility that the bureaucracy could become a new ruling class on the basis of a fully nationalised economy.
He still insisted that the USSR state"* "degenerated workers' • But he said that if the bureaucracy proved to have more stability than he predicted, then he would have to revise his attitude and admit it had been a ruling class. After the Second World War, the bureaucracy, far from being overthrown, expanded its control into sion of monopoly capitalism analysed by Lenin in 1916; it has other forms, and the USSR is one of those.
Meanwhile Stalinist movements in Yugoslavia and China led autonomous revolutions creating systems similar to the USSR.
Those developments made the • Speakers from the Soviet Union, speaking about free trade unionism • A speaker from the Polish Socialist Party (RD)
in Warsaw, on the fight for women's liberation in Poland and the current Men abortion rights • Cheung Siu Ming (National -C inese Solidarity Campaign) on the need for democracy in China • Greg Benton (Chinese Department, in ing. fom Ifor Domocratie China-UK) - an eyewitness report from Tiananmen • Gunther Minnerup on German reunification • Hillel Ticktin (Soviet Studies Department, Glasgow University) - The Soviet Union in Crisis • Peter Tatchell on the fight for lesbian and gay rights in Eastern Europe • Adam Novotny workers and national conflict in Yugoslavia • Bill Lomax on 8 Inche 56 t O'Mahony - why the vement workers in thr toll Ebening Standard AUCUST 16.1961 Red riot police train water gun on the U.S. C in Cas he tours sector border Craydon boys lie in school Wall was built "workers' state" thesis untenab But Socialist Outlook's forerunne argued that Yugoslavia, Chin Poland and so on were "worke states" like the USSR.
This led them, for exampl credulously to accept the Maoist claims of tremendous progress du ing the Great Leap Forward ( 1958-60, when in fact some 2 million people died. They didn call for a workers' political revol tion against Mao until 1967.
They were also confused an divided, for example, in the response to the Polish worker!
struggles in 1980-1. After martia law in December 1981, Solidarnos called for a boycott of Polis goods.
The group of which Socialis Outlook was then part, the IMG refused to give that solidarity to th Polish workers. Some people in th IMG wanted to give solidarity, bu they were paralysed by others whe shied away from action against the Polish "workers' state"
Phil Hearse spoke from Socialis Outlook. The bureaucratically cen tralised Stalinist economies are in ¿ massive, and potentially terminal The historical balance sheet is that they were very good at carrying through basic industrialisation, bui incapable of developing a dynamic of intensive growth and innovatioin. Gorbachev's proposals have little chance of working.
There are two basic solutions to the crisis of the deformed and degenerated workers' states either the restoration of capitalism or the establishment of workers' Do want worker-managed society. overthrow of the bureaucracy, so power and the you might think that not much divides us politically in this debate.
But there is one programmatic difference: Socialist Organiser no longer defends the bureaucratised workers' states against imperialism. For them it is a matter of indifference whether these countries are ruled by the Stalinist bureaucracies on the basis of collectivised property, or dominated by imperialism.
Indeed, when Socialist Organiser says that there is nothing fundamental, as far as the working class is concerned, between Stalinist states and the imperialistdominated states, except that in some of the capitalist states the workers have more freedom to organise, it comes very close to saying that capitalist rule is preferable. In the view of Socialist Outlook, however, the destruction of the socialised property relations in the workers' states and their replacement by capitalism would be a world-historic disaster.
And Socialist Organiser are irresponsible because they disagree CLOSIN FOX From DANDA SAYS '1 QM 'bandits are under lock and key among themselves on whether the Stalinist states are "state-capitalist"
or "bureaucratic collectivist". How can they know whether there is a ruling class if they do not have a collective theory about the mode of production?
Socialist Organiser says that the bureaucratically dominated societies developed the productive forces in a broadly parallel way to capitalism. But that would imply that the 20th century has been dominated by historically redundant revolutions which didn't solve anything.
The seizure of power by postcapitalist regimes was irrelevant because the productive forces would have been developed by imperialism anyway. The vast bulk of 20th century history has been a historical detour.
But this is a massive piece of historical speculation. The collectivised societies created by the Cuban, Chinese, Yugoslav and Russian revolutions did industrialise their countries. That is historical fact. How can you know that imperialism would have developed those countries similarly? The whole point of the theory of permanent revolution was that imperialism would be incapable of industrialising the semi-colonial countries.
One historical comparison is devastating and irrefutable: between China and India. Compare India, dominated by imperialism, to China, even with its brutal bureaucracy: China's conditions are much better in longevity, infant mortality, and so on.
One of the factors behind the rebellion this summer was the bureaucracy's attempt to remove the "Iron Rice Bowl" enjoyed by the Chinese workers. There is no "Iron Rice Bowl" in India.
When the Chinese workers rebelled this summer, they said they didn't want a return to capitalism, they wanted socialism with a human face. it e basic question is this:
does matter capitalism is restored in the bureaucratised workers' states? Our answer is that it does matter. The masses would be worse off.
If you go by formal arguments about workers' liberty and the rights to organise, what conclusion do you come to? In the United States workers have the right to organise trade unions independent of the state. So are they freer than workers in Cuba? If you say yes, that means critical support American intervention to overthrow the Cuban regime!
Shachtman said that the bureaucratised workers' states were characterised by totalitarianism, modern slaves, and the complete control of society by the bureaucracy. It's not true. It's bizarre that Socialist Organiser should move towards such ideas at the same time as the mass movements are emerging in the In the Eastern Bloc there are social gains to be defended against capitalism - security of employment, social services, rhythm of work, cheap housing. cheap transport, and so on, all ofi which reflect the suppression of market relations in those countries. And it is absolutely wrong to say that the masses have no social power in those countries, as alleged by the old Cold War theory of totalitarianism. The USSR today is alive with politics. It is not all controlled by a tiny group of bureaucrats at the top.
And it is not true that the USSR forms imperialist. All pre-capitalist of imperialism involved systematic plunder of the subject states. But today the USSR subsidises the East European states and Cuba. Contrast that with the Philippines, At least 40 per cent of
Scan page 5
)R A WORKERS' EUROPE EAST AND WEST 5 Barricade erected ju: economic activity ther by the US, and at lea of the people live in al ty. Those two facts ar Of course the turm‹ revolution can create capitalist restoration. political revolution i We still support pol tion. But we insist tha tion of capitalism historical catastrophe ing class.
The workers' state! bureaucracies, have material buffer agains barism of ecological and world war — not barism of Shachtman of Stalinism. 5, despite the acted as a i the asal barcatastrophe the fake baris description st before the Berlin Wall was built e is controlled Tiananmen Square. That's not an st 80 percent advance on capitalism, it's barbsolute pover- baric. re connected. pil of political Mike Phipps from Socialist a chance of Newsletter defended the definition A risk-free of the Stalinist states as workers' s impossible. states.
They could not be a "historical litical revolu- dead-end" if they developed the it the restora- productive forces. And if new would be a ruling classes have developed the for the work- productive forces, then we are in for a whole historical epoch of state capitalism. The next progressive class on the agenda is not the working class, it is the statecapitalist class.
The Stalinist states lack the freedom to organise - though that's changing in the USSR - but barism. So Phil is so tough that he doesn't find labour camps and mass slaughter barbaric?
The differences aren't over our attitude to the bureaucracies' current moves to denationalise industry and restore capitalism. Socialist Organiser is against those moves just as much as Socialist Outlook, though our argument to the Eastern Bloc workers would cerrepresents huge gainer status quo And the differences aren't over whether the US should invade Cuba. We don't like the system in Cuba, but we defend Cuban self-determination against US imperialism.
The difference is over our attitude when workers move against Outlook only supports the workers if they're opposing the bureaucrats on the right lines. Our comrades supported the Hungarian revolution in 1956 although many of the workers had social-democratic, Catholic, Ideas. In 1980-1 we revolutionary supported the Polish workers.
Socialist Outlook is for the political revolution. Socialist Organiser doesn't even have a new theory of its own, yet it says everyone else is wrong.
John O'Mahony said - suppose it's true that the Stalinist regimes have given the workers some social benefits. That's good. But we're not interested in a totalitarian state keeping the workers as suppressed but contented sheep. Our concern for democracy is not a matter of abstractions, but of the preconditions for our class to organise itself as a force for revolution.
Even if everything Socialist Outlook says about the benefits of Stalinism is true, the whole attitude is wrong. For us the working class must be the self-acting subject of history, not the passive, imprisoned, recipient of the welfare benefits of the totalitarian Stalinist states.
We do not want to see the Stalinist states conquered by imperialism. It's a fact that the workers in America have more rights than in any Stalinist state, but it doesn't follow at all that if the Americans conquered a Stalinist state they would then benignly extend the rights of their own country to the colony. That's not how imperialism works.
We don't want a capitalist restoration. We want to replace the existing Stalinist nationalised economies by workers' power. But what's your attitude when a mass workers' movement, as in Poland - for various reasons — wants to restore market forces, and the bureaucracy wants to retain nationalised property? What's most mportant? In our view, the free ac. tivity of the working class is more important than nationalised economy under a bureaucracy.
Socialist Outlook are soft on Stalinism. Trotsky believed the Soviet Union was an advance on capitalism. But Trotsky hated the Stalinist regime. He would never have praised the pauper welfare benefits of the totalitarian states as if they were very important.
This stress on the welfare benefits of Stalinism is new for Socialist Outlook's political current. They used to stress its allegedly progressive significance, its 'vanguard role' in the world revolution. There seems to be a slow retreat from the old position.
Of course, Socialist Outlook aren't Stalinists. Of course they want the same thing as we do, a regime of democratic workers councils. But that's not enough. Socialist Outlook's history is one of repeatedly developing illusions, for periods long or short, in the ruling bureaucrats. For China, for example, Socialist Outlook's forerunners did not support a political revolution until 1967 or 1969. For Cuba, Socialist Outlook still doesn't support a political revolution, unless they have made some recent change of position.
Socialist Outlook have the same programme as us, but lose sight of who is going to carry it through, and are willing for whole periods to accept the bureaucracies as the historical protagonists, with criticisims, but also with great illusions, as when they gave credence to the Maoists' claims about the great leap forward.
So Socialist Outlook are Trotskyists on the Soviet Union - for political revolution. In other Stalinist states where there have been autonomous revolutions, they have looked at the bureaucrats not with the eyes of the Trotskyists of the 1930s, but, with the eyes of another group of Communists from the 1930s, the Brandlerites.
The Brandlerites were critical of Stalin, they wanted democracy but they did not believe the bureaucracy was an alien force and they did not believe in political revolution.
Likewise Socialist Outlook, for a whole historic period, accepted the Maoist bureaucracy as the protagonist of history. Because the working class was in disarray throughout the world and Stalinists in backward countries were making revolutions, Socialist Outlook's forerunners accepted those Stalinist petty-bourgeois bureaucrats as the protagonists of history. How does that look when the Chinese working class has become an active force again?
It's true that you can have a pretty clear anti-Stalinist record on the basis of the "workers' state" position. Socialist Organiser's forerunners were not sufficiently critical of the Indochinese Stalinists during the war with America, but apart irom that we were very clear even when we had a "workers' position.
In 1981 Phil and some of his comrades may have been in favour of supporting Solidarnosc's call for a boycott, but the fact is that the organisation they were in, the iNu, did not support that call.
Socialist Organiser is having an open discussion. As a result of that discussion we may solve some of the problems that have bedevilled Trotskyism for 40 years. That's why it is an important discussion.
----- pull-quotes -----
Solidarity with Workers in the
advance on capitalism - half the way, or
A labour movement Saturday 27 January 11.00 — 5.00 Malet St, London WC1 & students)/£2 (unwaged)
Eastern Europe. It was imperialist. Imperialism is not just the expan-
Speakers includes
WON'T STAY IN FEDERATION'