FOR A WORKERS' EUROPE EAST AND WES How the Wall was broken
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
unified? Yes.
Neither the USSR, nor the US, nor France, nor Britain, has any right to stop the German people reuniting the country if they want to.
They say a united Germany of 80 million people would be too powerful and would destabilise Europe. How are the Germans supposed to take that from the world superpowers, the USSR and the US? From Britain, which only recently had a huge colonial empire and is still the Western world's second military power? From France, which still has a sizeable colonial empire?
Only nationalist prejudice can blame the whole German people tor Hitler's crimes. The first victims of Hitler were, after all, Germans — German communists, German socialists, German Jews. And most Germans today had not even been born when Hitler died.
The German people have the right to reunity their country. It would be best if that reunification The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01 639 7965. reports: first post comes as part of uniting all Europe, but the Germans have the right to reunify anyway.
All the powers-that-be are against reunification in the short term. The rulers of both Germanies fear the reactions of the superpowers. The Eastern bureaucrats also fear that reunification would mean them losing all their powers and privileges, as their territory was swamped by West German capital.
Socialists do not accept the concerns of the capitalists and the bureaucrats. But we are not nationalists, either. for us reunification is not a fetish or an overriding concern.
Most Germans seem to think likewise. The mass demonstrations in East Germany have had very few slogans about reunification. The leaders of the East German opposition say that they don't want East Germany absorbed into the West German system: instead they want a "better socialism" in East Germany At mass rallies in West Berlin the day the Berlin Wall was opened, the German national anthem booed. Kohl was booed, too, not only, it seems, because he is a right-winger, but because -0T119 tionalist rhetoric about reunificaFor by phone Monday PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU).
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser The Brandenburg Gate tion.
Opinion polls in West Germany show a big majority for reunification in principle, but a small minority seeing it as an immediate answer.
One reason, doubtless, is the pressure ol the capitalists and bureaucrats on public opinion. Another is that the question of reunification is complicated by the different social regimes in East and West Germany.
Reunification would mean not just political change, but also changing the economic and social regime in at least one part of Germany. The current talk of reunification is based on the assumption that a private-profit economy will be restored in East Germany.
Socialist Organiser does not believe East Germany is socialist. We do not believe that its statemonopoly system is better than capitalism. But we do not want the state-monopoly system replaced by capitalism. We want it replaced by working class socialism.
If the grip of the bureaucrats over East Germany's workers and over East Germany's factories is to be broken, we want it replaced not by the profit-grabbing of DaimlerBenz, Hoechst, or the Deutsche Bank, but by workers' control and collective workers' ownership. To win democratic rights, the East German workers should look to their own struggle, not to what the West German capitalists may grant them.
Therefore, while we say reunify Germany, we say more than this: we say, reunify Germany on the basis of workers' liberty East and West! Reunify Germany on the basis of the workers overthrowing the bureaucrats in the East and the capitalists in the West!
f anyone has told me a year ago that the Berlin Wall would not exist today, l would have said that they were mad!
The speed and force of the development of the mass movement in the GDR and the depth of the regime's crisis has taken everyone by surprise - from the CIA and President Bush (seen on Friday looking at a map of Germany in some puzzlement) through to Trotskyists.
The movement started following widespread indignation at the obvious rigging of local elections in the spring. It was obviously spurrea by events in Polanc and Hungary, which demonstrated that the Soviet Union was prepared to tolerate independent political developments within the Warsaw Pact.
Throughout October demonstrations calling for reform, free travel, a free media, the right of free assembly and free elections spread throughout the GDR and grew until they included hundreds of thousands of people.
On 18 October Egon Krenz replaced Erich Honecker as head of the SED. He seems now to have decided early on that he could not use repression against the opposition, particularly without Soviet backing. Krenz, Honecker's hand picked successor: who conthe Chinese on the Tiananmen Square massacre, ther began a policy of conceding just a: much as he thought was necessary to prevent things getting worse This included a 'dialogue offen sivil the day he Pore yad been dieSheen ae hard Stalinist backers of Honecker called meetings to listen to what the people had to say to them. Most then concluded that the people's complaints had substance and that the SED was just about to put everything right!
This naturally bred further cycnicism, especially when most of the rulers were the same people as before. As always in prerevolutionary situations, concessions merely appear as a sign of weakness and fuel further demands.
The government allowed GDR citizens out of the country to Czechoslovakia and large numbers again began going into the West German embassy and emigrating.
Having in the meantime seen November - 71 years to the day after the revolt of the workers, soldiers and sailors brought down the Kaiser (Emperor). Like that revolution, last week's events only mark a beginning - a beginning that could lead in several different directions.
Within the GDR now everything is still up for grabs. Krenz has announced elections for next year, though it is still unclear under what conditions they will take place. New Forum, the opposition umbrella group, has gone from a few dozen to 200,000 members in two months. It may soon be legalised. Members of the government have held semi-official talks with members of it.
An action programme published by the government has promised a freer press, independent courts, economic changes and independent unions but leaves in place the SED's "leading role', which is unacceptable to the opposition.
Nobody trusts Krenz or sees him as a credibie clormer. Un monuay 13th, between 200,000 and 500,000 people marched in Leipzig and the opposition is still growing and demanding more guarantees of real change. Gorbachev in Moscow, Krenz responded by getting the Politburo to resign en bloc on 8 November. The SED Central Committee elected a new one, two-thirds of them old Honecker supporters, some of whom have subsequently resigned after being voted out by local SED organisations.
Only the Dresden party leader, Hans Modrow, now confirmed Prime Minister, had a serious reputation as a reformer, partly because he had been among the first to talk to demonstrators, before it became fashionable.
At the same time, West German Chancellor Kohl began to put on pressure by hinting that economic aid would be traded for reform and calling on the SED to give up its monopoly on power.
At this point Krenz first conceded the right to free travel and later said that free elections will be held. The removal of border restrictions was partly an attempt to end the exodus and partly an attempt to get some economic aid from the West Germans.
Of the 4 million East Germans who crossed the border last weekend only about 10,000 applied to stay and the flow through Hungary and Czechoslovakia has virtually stopped.
On the economic front, It looks unlikely that any large-scale aid will be given until the economy is reformed along lines acceptable to the West German banks.] An emergency congress of the SED is now to be held in December to allow the election of a new Central Committee to present a postHonecker face for the SED. Like the Polish and Hungarian CPs, the SED is in a race against time to try to appear seriously reform-minded before having to face real elections.
This has even gone as far as closing the shops with Western goods in frite for me homes of al. the basement of the Central Comburo members in case the demand that they be open to the public is conceded!
It is not yet clear under what conditions the elections will be held or who will be able to take part. The "leading role' of the SED is written into the constitution and there have been statements that only parties accepting the constitution will be able to stand. However, it is unlikely that, in the present situation, the SED could get away with rigged elections. What will come out of them depends on how well the opposition can organise and on what programme.
urope Yet the opposition is only very slowly beginning to look beyond demands such as free elections to discuss more fundamental political questions. Demands that a few weeks ago seemed at best hopeful and maximalist now run the risk of being overtaken by events.
One New Forum speaker said that he hoped elections would not occur too quickly before political parties had a chance to develop real programmes.
This is particularly true for the left wing of the movement. The Guardian recently commented: "There is a real constituency for socialism in East Germany," and it is crucial that these people are not just prêsented with the choice between a refurbished SED (CP) and a range of non-socialist parties.
The removal of the Wall is the start of a period in which the old division of Europe is starting to break down, and it is not yet clear what will replace it. Our perspecave should be the United Socialist States of Europe as an alternative to Stalinism and capitalism.
We must give support and aid to the East German opposition and encourage the crystallisation of socialist elements within it. The events of the last week should be an encouragement to us in that task.
----- pull-quotes -----
a Workers' From page