Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A serious count for socialists

Socialist Organiser no. 424, 16 November 1989 · scan p. 2 · about 1,589 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Clive Bradley looks the forthcoming election in Brazil B Caulte is rected one do razil is not a serious Gaulle is reputed once to have said.

The current somewhat volatile election campaign might have confirmed him in this opinion it un- SEurO. pean arrogance though undoubtedly is.

It now seems likely that the winner will be right-of-centre populist demagogue Fernando Collor de Mellor. But until his recent disqualification, a close challenger seemed to be Silvio Santos, a Brazilian TV mogul standing on a very unserious ticket.

So discredited are most of the country's supposedly serious politicians that even joke candidates are in with a chance.

Top of the popular hate list is sitting President Jose Sarney, not standing for re-election. Sarney, who travels around everywhere with a much-needed bodyguard, was never elected President.

The army, which vacated power in 1985 atter 21 years, had set up an electoral college to choose a civilian ruler. It chose a popular but ageing oppositionist, Tancredo Neves, who promptly died on the eve of taking office. Sarney, who was to have been vice-president, was in fact a defector from the right-wing military backed party.

He has made a terrible mess of being President, from the point of view both of the ruling class and the increasingly poverty stricken masses.

Just as discredited, however, is the "official" opposition from the days of the junta, the clumsily named Brazilian Democratic Movement Party (PMDB). For the last two years it has had a thumping majority in Parliament, where it has backed Sarney. The first thing it did, within days of winning the parliamentary election, was approve an austerity programme that provoked a huge wave of strikes. The government was forced, not for the last time, to back down.

Now the candidate of the PMDB for President, Ulysses Guimaraes, is the "most rejected" candidate, according to opinion polls, which is to say that nearly 50% of those polled said they would not vote for him in "any hypothesis". Unpopular man.

A poll published by O Globo in mid-September gave Ulysses 2.5% of the vote, putting him in seventh place. Top of the poll was Collor (41.1%), followed by Leonel Brizola (14.8%) and 'Lula' of the Workers Party (6.4%). More recent polls suggest Lula might do better.

Brizola is the modern face of traditional Brazilian populism. His party, the Democratic Labour Party, is the inheritor of "Vargismo' the nationalist-populist-statist movement that largely dominated Brazil from the 1930s through to the coup in 1964.

Under Vargas, strict labour laws were introduced tying and subordinating the labour movement to the state. In a slightly more radical guise, under Joao Goulart, 'Vargismo' scared the ruling class in the early 1960s and led to the coup. Brizola • was Goulart's brother-inlaw, and seen as a radical figure in that period.

From a socialist point of view, the Workers Party, or PT (Partido dos Trabalhadores) is a lot more interesting. It was born out of the enormous strike movement that began in 1978, of which Lula, a "The existence of the has represented an metalworkers' leader in one of Sao Paulo's big industrial suburbs, became the public face, indeed the personification.

The 1978 strike wave, centred around the big multinational car factories, ended a decade of working class inactivity. In subsequent years it was followed by more strikes, occupations and political upheaval; and it was those that forced the dictatorship to give up The dictatorship had presided over the so-called Brazilian economic "miracle" of fantastically rapid economic growth. The growth was accompanied by huge social inequality, which capitalist apologists were always less keen to note: in Rio de Janeiro, appalling slums still get washed down the cliffs every time it rains, while a short distance away the fabulously rich enjoy their pleasure beaches. But an economic transformation it certainly was.

The dictatorship was forced to allow a return to civilian rule, which it finally did in 1985. But it tried to control the transition. There were to be no direct elections for President. The PT was instrumental in launching the massive 'Dereitas Ja' (direction elections now campaign that year, the biggest mass campaign in Brazilian history.

Various tendencies came together to form the PT, which became a legal party in 1980. Within the unions, oppositionists had been secretly organising for years, often in connection with the radical church. Many. of these union oppositionists were syndicalists, looking to democratic rank and file organisation in the factories and rejecting political organisation; but many also saw the need to supplement trade union activity.

Other forces, including Trotskyists, different leftist currents reemerging after the devastation of the sixties (pro-Cubans, exguerrillaists), and community activists, united to form the PT.

Now the PT is a major force in Brazilian politics, although undoubtedly it has moved to the right since 1980.

Earlier this year the PT scored important victories in municipal elections, most dramatically in Sao Paulo, South America's biggest metropolis. The new PT council under Louisa Erendinha attempted to establish democratic "people's councils" in the city to involve the masses in decision making. Facing economic pressures even worse than local councils in Britain, they have since raised transport prices. How serious this retreat may be is hard to assess from this distance.

The existence of the PT has represented an immense gain for the Brazilian working class, which is the strongest and most independently minded in Latin America. It works closely with the CUT, a ten-million strong rank and file-based union federation now much more powerful than the old official structure (these days called the CGT). The CUT jealously guards its independence from any political party, but it is PT militants who dominate it politically.

14 and 15 March this year saw a general strike by 35 million workers against a new austerity programme (the Plano Verao, "Summer Plan' nicknamed by the workers the Plano Ladrao, "Thieves' Plan'). The CGT collaborated in this action, but the CUT largely organised it. A further militant strike wave followed in May.

Lula The PT has moved to the right, although there remains a distinct left wing in the party, and several Trotskyist groups function in it (with some success it would seem). Lula's programme for the election is quite vague, saying little beyond the call for renegotiating Brazil's colossal foreign debt in tandem with other Latin American countries (a policy criticised by unionists and the PT left as 'third worldist' ie. failing to focus on the fact that the Latin American countries are divided into classes).

Lula himself, apparently impressed by Sweden, has become increasingly ambivalent on the issue of the PT's commitment to socialism; according to reports, he no longer calls for the nationalisation even of the banks, although this remains party policy.

But the PT is still a long way from Western European social democracy. Its future course could depend a lot on the activity of socialists within it. It has half a million members, and certainly any socialist policy for Brazil must start with them.

The current elections reflect the increasing impasse in Brazilian politics and society. They are the first direct presidential elections since 1960, but there is widespread cynicism about them, which enables someone like Collor, who has no policies but is popular for opposing corruption, to gain a lot of support. The PT also has been subject to a scandal-mongering campaign about corruption.

Whoever wins, and it is very unlikely to be Lula, Brazil will continue to face huge problems of inequality, debt, and inflation. But from within its strong and militant workers' movement, inspiring things are sure to emerge. Brazil is a country for socialists to watch. Charles de Gaulle was only very superficially right.

Doctors all too often treat D their women patients very badly, especially where it is a matter of "women's complaints".

How do I know? Guess! Like so many women I have chronic cystitis. Although I don't have the back-up knowledge, I do know about cystitis.

I know what antibiotics I need, and when I need them. I know how to manage the symptoms and how to avoid attacks.

This knowledge has had to be gained over many painful years, and it had to be gained without the help of the medical profession.

Thankfully, the medical profession does now advise women on how to help themselves through an attack and the Health Education Council does produce a booklet. But women are still sent for clinical procedures which do nothing to help.

Doctors do not (in my experience) suggest herbal teas and tablets to relieve the symptoms, or even tell women to take an analgesic for the pain. Only one doctor has ever provided me with medicine to combat thrush - the inevitable side effect of antibiotics.

Because of this experience I am a firm believer in medical selfmanagement.

Take another aspect of my cystitis problem. I am allergic to penicillin. At least I think I am. I don't know for sure because I was a child when I had the allergic reaction to the mystery antibiotic. prescribed to me by a 'locum doctor.

For a regular antibiotics junkie this is a bit of a nuisance.

A sympathetic doctor once made me describe my childhood symptoms, and deduced that they were most likely caused by penicillin. Since then I have avoided it.

But most doctors don't have time for that sort of thing.

The simplest way to avoid confusion is to take your notes from doc-

----- pull-quotes -----

immense gain for the Brazilian working class

Doctors ar rs and complaints"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 424

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →