Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Direct action and

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 66–68 · about 3,573 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 66 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 66

bizarre results, like the denunciation of miners' support committees as 'left-wing Oxfam' for the first five or six months of the miners' strike!

There have recently been some signs of the SWP trying to get its act together again in the unions and to rebuild its old credibility amongst militants. SWP members have even started standing for shop stewards' positions again. But given the lousy reputation the organisation has won for itself (thanks to years of zany antics in the unions) it seems unlikely that it will ever regain the standing it once had, or rebuild any sort of rank and file movement.

Perhaps the biggest disservice the SWP has done the labour movement is to have discredited the very notion of 'rank and fileism' amongst many militants. The term is now tainted with organisational sectarianism, narrow economism — indeed, full-blown syndicalism for most practical purposes in thi unions — and a tendency to avoid the question of the union leadership.

All these faults did, indeed, characterise the IS/SWP's version of rank and file-ism. But they are all faults of the IS/SWP's politics — not inherent features of a serious rank and file orientation that takes as its sta ting point the needs of the class struggle and not the immediate organisational advantage of a particular sect.

Trotsky's criticisms of the Comintern's union work during the crazy "Third Period' days of 1930 could equally well apply to the IS/SWP.

«What we are obliged to do is not to close our eyes to facts in the name of pitiful schemata, but to see the course of economic development as it really is and to work out trade union tacties on the basis of facts...for the Comintern...tactics consist of periodic zigzags and strategy is the arithmetical sum of the zigzags." A broken spring.

As long as five years ago, when Workers' Fight was part of IS, we proposed that IS the building of a Rank and File Movement. should take as one of its major objectives We saw it as necessary, and incidentally a way of building an organised periphery around IS, rather than the approach of the IS leadership of direct mass recruitment into the organisation itself of people with, often, little political education and only a vague idea of what IS was.

Five years later on, IS has anything up to 4,000 members recruited on this loose basis, without selection or tempering and with little education other than the demagogic catch-cries of the IS leaders.

Long ago this method of building the alleged 'revolutionary party', which leaves no method of leadership open to the IS leaders except internal manipulation and demagogy, had destroyed any real interna democracy inside IS.

It is this organisation that now seeks to build a rank and file movement. It is probably inevitable that any such movement would be dominated by some political tendency. The question is, which tendency with which politics. The trouble with this movement is that it is IS, with its tailist, line-of-least-resistance politics that is dominating.

Nevertheless, on balance (and its discrete manipulations last Saturday notwithstanding), IS's domination a political and not a bureaucratic domination. So far, that is.

Leon Trotsky once said that a revolutionary conception without a revolutionary will is like a watch with broken spring. A rank and file movem led by the politics of IS also has a brol spring. It is the job of revolutionaries fight to instal a new spring - that of Marxist politics.

From Workers' Fight August 6 problems, Jack Cleary reviews 'Bolsheviks in the Isarist Russia did not have parliamentary democracy. One the basic political demands around which the workers' movement in Russia — perhaps the most consistently revolutionary workers' movement that has ever existed — organised was the demand for a democratic parliament on the model of the British or French parliaments.

After the defeat of the 1905 revolution, feeble mockery of a bourgeois parliament, the Duma, was set up. It had no real power and was not democratically elected. For example, the workers elected their deputies in special group (curia), and a worker's vote was worth only a fraction of the vote of various other social classes.

This Duma bore all the marks of its origin as a reactionary substitute for the democrati parliament demanded by workers and middl class alike, of something imposed by the vicious Tsarist reaction.

What should the attitude of the Russian workers be to this Duma? When it was first imposed the Bolsheviks boycotted it: there was still a chance to fight for something better, and not to boycott it would be to lend it authority and thus help the Tsar to set it up. But the revolution continued to ebb. Nothing better was likely in the period ahead.

So Lenin concluded that the working class should use the Duma as a platform from which to agitate and make propaganda which would help drum up the forces that could eventually go beyond the Tsar's feeble and hobbled parliament. Most Bolsheviks, however, did not agree. Lenin was virtually isolated in the Bolsheviks ranks, and in uncomfortable agreement with the less revolutionary wing of the workers movement, the Mensheviks.

But events — the continued decline of the workers' movement itself among them -converted most Bolsheviks to Lenin's view. And thus you got the paradox that the most consistently revolutionary party in history participated as fully as it legally could in the Tsar's reactionary and counter-revolutionary counterfeit of a parliament, and put it to good use as a labour movement platform. Lenin later commented that if the Bolsheviks had not known how to do such things there would have been no Russian workers' revolu tion in 1917.

Six Bolshevik deputies were elected to the Duma in 1912, and Badayev was one of them, and his book is an account of their work until 1915, when they were tried and sentenced to Siberian exile for life. It is a day-by-day account of the parliamentary fraction of the Bolshevik party as it immers itself in the newly-revived Russian labour movement. Acting as one of a number of party bodies, subordinate to the party, the parliamentary fraction used the Duma platform to support workers in struggle and to give workers a political lead.

Badayev's account is an inspiring report from one part of the political front of the many-fronted class war waged by the ideological fronts as well as the political front.

This combination of different fronts of struggle was the essence of the Bolshevik par ty as a revolutionary workers' party - this, and not any formal organisational rules, for Lenin's organisation changed frequently, in line with changing conditions of legality and illegality, etc. It allowed the party to link flexibly with the spontaneous workers' movement in all its phases, whether of flow or ebb, militancy or exhaustion.

The struggle in the Duma was the main political front at that time and in that place. The Bolsheviks knew that it was necessary to be able to function on every front of the class struggle, and that otherwise the less revolutionary wing of the labour movement, or the bourgeoisie, would occupy the political space. And thus the Bolsheviks went into, worked within, and told the workers to orient politically to, the bloody-handed Tsar's reactionary Duma.

Almost as arresting as the self-linkage of the Bolsheviks to the reactionary Duma is the incongruous publication of this book by the British Socialist Workers' Party (SWP). The SWP thereby commits a dangerously selfexposing act of piety or commercial calculation (or both). It is as if Alexinsky or Bogdanov, Lenin's leading Bolshevik opponents on using the Duma, had published pamphlet in favour of it!

Most of the time the SWP fights shy of propounding basic principles of any sort and of binding itself by them. It makes no dogmatic principle of anti-parliamentarism such as certain syndicalists and ultra-left 'council communists' do. Nevertheless, in what it writes and says about current politics there is a sub-text of dogmatic antiparliamentarism.

It goes far beyond the necessary revolutionary socialist stress on direct action, on the primacy over parliamentary jousting of activities which involve workers directly in struggle for their own economic and other interests; it counterposes such direct action to parliament.

Parliament, concern for parliament, involvement in parliament, wish to win parliamentary elections — these are bad, these are necessarily and properly the terrai of the right wing and the soft left. Left-win; politics cannot win elections, at least in nor mal times, therefore concern for elections drags you irresistibly to the right.

Propaganda against parliament is central the SWP, and even though it is never rigorously codified or even consistently expounded, they are in practical politics unconditionally hostile to parliament. For example, much that they say about the Labour Party, and the condemnation they make of socialists who are in the Labour Party for being there, is grounded on denunciations of the Labour Party for its involvement in parliament. They even explain the dirty dealings of Militant in Liverpool by the Labour Party's involvement in parliament.

If you focus on parliament — so the argument goes - then you must subordinate the class struggle to electoral considerations. So fight parliamentarism!

But in practice that means leaving parliament - and effectively, most of current politics — to the Labour Party right and soft left. The SWP focuses on industrial struggles and socialist propaganda for a future society. In the proper place of politics, the place filled by traditional Marxist parties ana also by the Bolshevik party with limited political objectives - in that place the SWP puts the demand: 'build the SWP' It seems revolutionary and radical, but it isn't at all. It means abandoning the broad labour movement to others. The workers, perforce, will wind up accepting the answers that 'the others' give to the immediate political questions — like what to do about the Tories and what to replace them by, now.

This is a version of 'economism' (one of the one-sided predecessors of the Bolsheviks in the Russian labour movement) superficially "Leninised' by the focus on 'the revolutionary party'

Scan page 67

The 'Economists' wanted to organise the workers, make socialist propaganda, organise a socialist party — and leave the political struggle against the Tsar and his system to the rising Russian bourgeoisie. They had the theoretical excuse that they expected the replacement of the Tsar to be not workers' power (because the working-class was too small and industry was too weak) but a bourgeois-democratic regime.

If the SWP would accept the analogy the! would say: yes - and we expect the Labourites once more to be the government and each time to expose themselves, until they fall apart.

The problem is that you cannot separate out the Labour Party from the labour move ment like that. The labour movement has to be revolutionised from within, and because the 'politics' of the SWP means leaving that is concerned. Throughout the years of bitter struggle by the left in the Labour Party, the SWP sat on the sidelines, sourly commentin: If the Bolsheviks had done the analogous thing in Russia, then there would have been no workers' revolution. There would have been a liberal or socialist-reformist labour movement at one pole, and a small 'maximalist' Marxist sect at the other, impotent and irresponsible, though very selfgratifyingly irreconcilable and I...r...revolutionary.

The SWP's contradictions are shown up in the introduction by Tony Cliff, which takes as its task to square the SWP's practice with the radically different practice which Badayev records. From paragraph one Cliff sets out to show that for the Bolsheviks 'Parliament was never the central focus on political activity" , and stresses that Badayev "shows the role the Bolshevik deputies played in the industrial struggle of the workers" . True as it stands, but the deflation of the work of the deputies to that of auxiliary to the industrial struggle is a deflation of politics.

Industrial struggle alone could not be a central focus of 'political activity'. Whereas the job of Marxists, of those who want to build a revolutionary party according to Lenin's real model, is to link and combine the different fronts of the class struggle and integrate them into a strategy, Cliff is no les restrictively one-sided than the one-sided parliamentarians of the British labour move ment.

Cliff says that the British labour movement, with its parliamentarism, is the pure antithesis of Bolshevism. Not so, or not quite. One-sided, a-political or pretendpolitical, syndicalism is the real opposite of British parliamentarism, both in logic and in the history of our movement. Bolshevism is distant from both, yet it subsumes both and transforms them into a qualitatively higher unity.

You would never think from Cliff's pictur that the central political slogan of the Bolsheviks throughout this period was the mand for a fully governing, freely elected parliament, a slogan that remained central until after the October Revolution.

Socialists in the Lenin and Trotsky tradi. tion would quarrel not, of course, with Cliff's positive emphasis on direct action, l with his one-sidedness. And with his a-historical history: for example, he makes much of the class composition of the Bolshevik Duma fraction, who were metal and textile workers, and then neglects to mention that the leader of the Bolshevik deputies, 'the metalworker Malinovsky" was a police spy (shot by the Bolsheviks in 1918).

He belabours Eric Heffer for his views on parliament, accusing him of downgrading direct action, especially during the great struggles of the early 1970s, when the genera strike was on the order of the day. He attacks Heffer for not advocating a general strike.

Well, though IS (the predecessor of the SWP) did advocate the general strike on an off after 1970, the record shows that in Jul 1972, when a quarter of a million workers struck spontaneously against the jailing of five dockers under the Tory Industrial Relations Act, and the TUC declared a one-day general strike, forcing the government to release the five, IS didn't dare call for a general strike at the point when it mattered.

The depths of nonsense are reached when Cliff endorses (from the left) the ultra-rightwing claim that working-class industrial defeat can be electorally good for Labour, citing the steady growth of the Labour vote after 1926, which culminated in Labour being the biggest party in the House of Commons after the October 1929 general election.

The fact, of course, is that there is often a zig-zag pattern. Blocked in industry, the class turns to politics. Blocked in politics by a Tory government, as in the '50s, or frustrater by a right-wing Labour government, as in the '60s, the class turns, if employment and other conditions are favourable, to industrial struggle.

To say that one of these things is 'bad', to condemn the turn to politics because it isn't the 'pure' industrial class struggle, and implicitly to identify it as necessarily right wing - as Cliff does - is both stupid and defeatist.

Defeatist, because it is a central fact of working-class life that we experience industrial defeats, and that there is a limit to what can be achieved by industrial gains unless the workers 'go political'. Short of generalised industrial action - a general strike — leading to revolution, no amount of pure industrial militancy can generate a socialist solution. The great merit of Bolshevism was that it linked up the industrial militancy of the Russian working class with revolutionary politics.

That being so, to 'insist' on the movement remaining on one, industrial, plane, and snobbishly to reject and disdain the other, political, plane - which is what Cliff does ir the guise of rejecting Parliament — is to rule out real development of the real working class in the world as it is.

Cliff substitutes 'the party' for politics — or tries to, for of course 'build the party" can't and doesn't substitute for real politics. It is toy-town politics. The terrible consequence of toy-town Bolshevism is that the right and soft left have the arena of working class politics left to them by default of the Marxists.

You might say that Cliff's formula is 'boom-time Trotskyism'. When the workers are on the up and up then we have a role -when they are down we have no political role, except to help to rebuild on the small, local issues and to make general socialist pro paganda, and the right and soft left come into their own.

But even this is incoherent. For the workers were very much on the up and up in 1973-4. We took on the Tory government, challenged its authority, and panicked Heath into a general election which he lost. It was then that the and soft their own.

For they had the political wing of the movement; and the workers needed politics The workers, however militant, had no governmental alternative to the Labour Par - and thus the great and successful industrial push against the Tory government resulted in a Labour government... which soon demobilised the industrial militancy.

That experience brings out the real essenc of the matter for socialists as it is posed in principle and in British reality: the political struggle and the industrial have to be integrated and for socialists to be able to integrate them they have to do more than builc an organisation - though that is irreplaceable — they have to win the ideological battle, against both the straightforward versions of ruling-class ideas and the more subtle versions we get within the labour movement which tie the workers to the bourgeoisie.

One of the central ideas of the latter sort of course the notion that you can get socialism through parliament. But one of the sources of this false idea is that you can get some things through parliamentary politics. We cannot defeat the idea of socialism through parliament by counterposing to it no different politics in parliament and everywhere else but 'pure' industrial struggle. The SWP's a-political, or pretend-political, syndicalism and talk of 'building the revolutionary party now' , is no substitute for engaging wholeheartedly in such 'parliamentary politics' as the fight to return a Labour government now.

True to its trimming, havering and eclectic politics, the SWP will opportunistically say "vote Labour' on election day — otherwise it would risk isolation. But that is only the election-time version of its routine abandonment of politics to the right. Indeed, at election time it is more glaring. In 1979 Paul Foot put it like this: 'For the next three weeks I am a very strong Labour supporter' The working class needs a revolutionary party. But such a party will not be a small propagandist apparatus, a small machine counterposed to the existing labour movement. A party is a party if it can minimally perform a certain range of activities, including conducting itself in all the affairs of the working class - which means all the political affairs of society, for these concern the working class, and if the working class does not have socialist answers it will accept the answers of the bourgeoisie.

The SWP cannot even perform the basic fulcrum activity of the revolutionary party which conditions everything else, including conduct in the industrial struggle — the ideological battle.

The early Christians lived in daily expectacion that the Second Coming of Christ was imminent. It would be the end of the world, and the Kingdom of God would come into being instead.

Then as the decades passed they began to lose faith in the imminence of the Second Coming - and of course they never thought that they could do anything except pray to bring it about. So they turned instead to the belief that 'for now' the Church was the visi ble Kingdom of God on earth.

So too with the socialists who substitute for the Marxist work of political struggle within the labour movement the building-up of their own organisation. 'The party' becomes their Kingdom of socialism on eart Worse than the Christians, they regress from the Marxist belief in struggle on all fronts to a helpless waiting for the 'millennium', which for them is the revival of the industrial militancy of the '70s. (In this way they parallel earlier Marxists who waited paralysed for decades for the Great Slump ti come back to radicalise the working class).

Hope for a millennium is comforting. It is especially comforting in periods of disappointment, setbacks and defeat, like that we are going through. But it is in its essence a turning away from the root of socialism -the working class in the whole range of phases and concerns of its struggles.

Scan page 68

Eric Heffer MP owadays Neil Kinnock and the • Labour leaders always try to avoid taking the side of strikmilitancy.

They refuse even to commit themselves to the repeal of the Tories anti-union laws.

This is short-sighted nonsense!

One of the big things to remember is that we fought the Tory Industrial Relations Bill [1972-4] consistently in the House of Commons, and we gave total And nowadays they say if you do that then you are bound to lose support!

In fact it was precisely the mobilisation

----- pull-quotes -----

Tsarist Duma', , by A Y Badayev with an introduction by Tony Cliff, published by Bookma

movement to the right and soft left it is no politics at all as far as the labour movement

ing workers. They fear being 'tainted' by association with trade union

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →