Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Was this "too political'?

Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles, 11 November 1989 · scan pp. 65–66 · about 785 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 65 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 65

ship between the Rank and File Movement and the IS/SWP was to dog the project throughout its existence, and eventually led a lot of good militants (including many IS workers) giving up on it.

The other central weakness of the entire project was also apparent at the first conference: though dominated organisationally by IS, the whole affair was narrowly apolitical. The main official resolution was a general statement of militant trade unionism, which studiously avoided such 'difficult" issues as nationalisation, workers' control, in ternational solidarity or women's rights. Ever the issue of racism was scarcely touched upon. An amendment from Stanton Steelworkers (supported by Workers Fight, a forerunner of Socialist Organiser) raised the issues of workers' control, nationalisation, racism and women's rights. Workers Fight commented afterwards:

«Most indicative of the control of IS, as well as the politics of IS, was the incredible rejection of the Stanton amendment. It is scarcely credible that, without IS's urging, a conference of militant, politically oriented rank and file trade unionists would have opposed the inclusion in the programme' of a rank and file movement of demands for nationalisation. As for the voting down of the section on racism, this is scarcely to be understood except in terms of crude IS factionalism, a refusal to be 'corrected' by another tendency."

A second conference, in November of same year, was slightly larger (49 shop stewards' committees sent delegates) but otherwise pretty much a repeat performance of the March event - with all the same pro blems very much in evidence. But after that came...nothing.

SWP theoreticians have since tried to explain away their failure by arguing that the "objective situation' made building such a movement impossible: 'In the wake of the Social Contract, industrial militancy collaps - the number of working days lost due to strikes in 1976 was the lowest since the 1950 This is the amendment that IS opposed at the March 1974 Rank and File Conference on the grounds that the ideas on fighting racism an This conference pledges itself to fight against racialism and religious sertarianism. We advocate campaigns to recruit immigrant workers to trade un (using leaflets in the immigrants' own languages, etc.) We fight against any discrimination at work or within the unions (including social clubs). We fight full equality in pay, conditions, status, grading, training, further education, access to skilled jobs and promotion oppor. tunities, in support of any demands black or immigrant workers make for educa. tional and special religious rights (holy day paid leave, right to wear religious dress, turbans, etc.) Against all immigration laws and controls or discriminatory legislation against their offshoots, the contract labour system, voucher system and deportations. For the physical defence of black workers under attack. For automatic official endorsement of industrial action by black or immigrant workers against instances of racialism whether they are in the minority or not.

We stand for the expropriation without compensation of the key branches of industry and finance, transport, distribution and land. Likewise the expropriation of thi most parasitic capitalists. We stand for the nationalisation of all enterprises that cannot meet the requirements of their workers. We advocate the placing of all such nationalised or expropriated enter. prises under direct workers' control. We fight for workers' control over work condi. tions, over hiring and firing, over the actual aims of production and distribution in factories and branches of industry both as an advance within capitalist society and as a school for socialism - the collective ownership of the means of production by the working class organised as the ruling class. We demand workers' factory inspectorates with full legal powers. We demand an end to business secrecy - "open the books" - giving workers the right to investigate and expose publicly the operations of the capitalists, not just in one firm or branch of industry, but in all their financial and state connections. We oppose all schemes of participation where workers, instead of being responsible solely for the well-being of their class, take responsibility for profitability and work discipline.

For a charter of women's rights, including: We fight for full equality in pay, conditions, status, grading, training, further education, access to skilled jobs and pro. motion opportunities, equal state benefits, abolition of the separate category of women's jobs, 24-hour free state-run nurseries, special medical and hygiene facilities where appropriate, time allowances for woren with family responsibilities to be fully paid by management. To offset the insecurity of seasonal, term time and other casual and semi-casual orcupations, we demand full pay with a guarantee of re-employment. We demand free contraception and abortion on demand.

Scan page 66

Bolshevik party, on the economic and

----- pull-quotes -----

a charter for women's righ 'too political'

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 421–423: New Problems, New Struggles

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →