The Left and the Unions
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-11-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 63 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 63
machines as the old Broad Lefts.
Militant looks to capturing the apparatus of the trade unions and devotes lots of energ to winning elections in them. In itself, this is reasonable and necessary; but Militant look no further.
Socialists need to democratise the trade unions, and fight to replace bureaucrats with a new fighting leadership. Elections are important — it makes a difference whether a union is led by Eric Hammond or Arthur Scargill.
But the key to transforming the unions is the rank and file itself. A socialist policy tries to develop the confidence and organisation of the rank and file. So while fighting to replace old, right wing leaders, we have to build a rank and file movement that can, to a degree, act independently of the officials. The lack of such a rank and file movement across the unions was one of the reasons the miners' strike of 1984-5 was lost: when the TUC refused to do anything to help the miners, those activists who did want to do something had no means to build solidarity.
The Broad Lefts could have helped build a rank and file movement. They didn't because Militant had no interest in fighting for that. Just like the CP before them, they did not represent a fighting leadership in the unions. The Broad Lefts they dominated were either largely lifeless front organisations seen as recruiting grounds to the Militant or, where they did have life, were electoral machines.
The jewel in BLOC's crown is the Broad Left in the Civil and Public Servants Associa tion (CPSA). This Broad Left is large and u: ed to be quite active and lively; but now it does very little outside of union elections. Militant motion of BL conference in 1987 argued: "... the priority must be the reelection of the Broad Left NEC"
That year Militant supporter John Macreadie had his election as General Secretary ruled out by the CPSA. Macreadie took the CPSA to court — at a cost of £20,000 — violating the principle of trade union independence from the courts. He never consulted the Broad Left - and then had the nerve to ask the BL to pay for it. He lost both court case and re-run.
Militant frequently oppose the extension of union democracy. For example, they are against the annual election of full-time officers like Macreadie, who is now Deputy General Secretary for a five year period. Militant say five years is short enough...
In the late seventies the left in the union argued for individual ballots at workplace meetings, Militant opposed this by supporting the old system of branch block votes.
Militant's reasoning was simple, they feared that extendine democracy in the union so, pal?
LIVERPOOL LIVERPOO WRONG: would weaken their influence so they opposed it, "we can't allow the right wing" was the arguement. They put their own short-term sect interests above basic union democracy.
Militant see the Broad Left as their property. When a policy was passed by the Broad Left that the leadership disagreed with, committing the BL to fight for action over the sacking of trade unionists at GCHQ, Militant supporters who are Broad Left officers just ignored it. They even refused to put out a Broad Left leaflet explaining the policy. A fine example of commitment to rank and file control and workers' democracy!
Broad Left conferences are like Militant rallies, with guest (Militant) speakers who even intervene in debates on contentious The BL have controlled the CPSA Executive twice. They did so in 1982-3 - and their record matched against the class strugg was not impressive.
The big battle during the period of office was by DHSS workers in Oxford and Birmingham against job cuts. They organised no mass pickets or demonstrations.
In 1987-8 Militant were no better. The NEC under their control failed to organise any strike action against YTS, although sporadic strike action was already taking place. They stuck to producing a few glossy leaflets.
They failed to hold a Labour Party affilia tion ballot, although it was conference polic! to do so, because the Treasury threatened to stop the deduction of union contributions at source. There ws no campaign against the Treasury, or even an attempt to find ways round it.
The NEC failed to call out civil servants o the one day strike over the NHS on 14 Marc 1988. John Macreadie (who is the CPSA delegate of the TUC) called on the TUC have a one-day strike instead. The TUC should have had a strike; but Militant's policy was just a posture.
The Broad Left National Committee did not meet for four months after the NEC victory, and never consulted the BL about its actions.
As a result the BL was effectively paralyse as a serious rank and file organisation in the vital period of the 1987 pay claim. This paralysis allowed the right-wing to step in and do their best to sabotage the ballot for all out strike action. The BL lost that ballot and the seeds were sown for the return of the right to power in the union in 1988.
The defeat at the '88 conference was ra tionalised by Militant as a mere lull before the storm'. We'll be back next year they vain. ly boasted. Tragically the BL's inactivity over the last few months makes that prospect 20p plus